Nothing makes sense anymore

Post Reply New Topic

I recently came across a video on youtube that I used to just scroll past every time I saw it or any other related video lurking about. I finally gave into checking the topic out with no intention of believing there was any fact to the matter....actually I went into it assuming it was just some kind of joke, a topic that was existed exclusively for entertainment purposes.

The topic I'm referring to here is: "the flat earth theory". Sounds ridiculous I know, but I went ahead and watched that video, followed by a lot of thought and a lot more videos. The feeling I got was almost gut wrenching as my thoughts and believes around the very nature of our existence started to become shaky. However the more digging I do the more the evidence seems to support the unconventional theory.

I beg you guys give this video a serious look with an open mind so we could possibly have a mature and scientific discussion about this extremely controversial topic. Here's the link to one of the better videos I have watched: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5YQ0dMJEjsk

For me the obvious fact that: even over bodies of water that stretch for hundreds of miles in every direction, the water does not bend, and the horizon remains completely flat. That doesn't make any sense when you take the supposed curvature of the earth into consideration....no sense at all.

As we all know, it's impossible to tell a parody of an extremist belief from an actual extremist belief. You can always find science to back something up (aided by a few fallacies here and there), regardless of what you believe. Moreover, the flat earth hypothesis is no more ridiculous than all those other conspiracy theories.

One of the things on my bucket list is to travel to a little town called Wendover, on the Utah/Nevada border, just off I 80. Just outside of this little town is a little hill with an observation platform at the top. If you climb to the top of the hill, and look out over the salt flats of western Utah, you can actually see the bend in the earth's surface. Supposedly it's one of the few places on earth where you can see it.

Also, the ancient Greeks realized that the earth was round because it casts a round shadow on the moon. Another thing is that handheld two way radios, for ham use or FRS/GMRS as it's called in the US, can only transmit for around a mile or so from handset to handset because of a curved earth. If the earth was flat, the signals would carry MUCH farther.

There were also plenty of Youtube videos that "proved" that the world would end on 12/21/12. It didn't. Be wary of believing anonymous jerks with Youtube accounts. The whole phenomenon of people believing any message delivered over a technologically new medium is something I call the "Welles Effect", after Orson Welles and his War of the Worlds radio broadcast in 1938 that sent people into the streets in a panic. Radio was as inscrutable to Americans in 1938-many of who had no more than a primary school education, if that-as the internet is to today's Americans. New media that seems to be magic and is perceived to be THE voice of authority. I really think that the Welles Effect should be better studied.

The Welles Effect was used by some slaveowners to control their slaves. As we all know, solar eclipses can be predicted. However, slaves in the Old South were deliberately kept uneducated. One effect of this is that owners used to make it appear that they had magical powers that could make the sun disappear. Perhaps the popularity of Voudoun (voodoo) and other such religions in the Black Caribbean are linked to slave beliefs that whites possessed magic powers, due to the Welles Effect. It's likely similar to the Cargo Cults in Polynesia.

There's a theory in Physics that the entire universe could be 2-dimensional and that the 3-dimensional world we perceive is simply akin to a holographic projection. It's not been proven, but it's entirely possible according to physicists given our current understanding. In a very real sense, if true, that would mean that not just the earth, but the entire universe is utterly and totally flat.

I don't waste much time thinking about it all, because the possibilities are endless and you can easily lose your sanity by indulging in speculation about the what-ifs. Though, it's very silly to think the way we currently perceive the world and universe is entirely correct, or even close to it.

seen it, thought about it, concluded it was crackpot.

as stated: ships sailing at the horizon are clear evidence of the curvature of the earth.
you can see the curvature at high mountains, sattelites orbit in all directions (including north-south), and planes follow that same pattern; neither of these are possible with a flat earth.

i must admit that the point of directional gravity would make a flat earth seem round, but (assuming the north pole is at the "centre") once you can move past the south pole and back north without turning around, at any altitude, your idea falls flat.

Watched it. Caught some errors in logic. For example he confuses normal timekeeping with sidereal time.

One of his arguments against this idea that the earth revolves around the Sun is that if the earth were rotating while it was revolving around the sun then every six months midnight and noon would trade places, and it would be darkest at noon, and brightest day at midnight ( and then go back again). But the fact is that it IS that way- if you're a professional astronomer because astronomers operate on sidereal time (in which the day is a tiny bit longer than the normal day). In sidereal time the length of the day is calibrated to the Earth's absolute position ( ie position relative to the stars outside the solar system). Normal time is calibrated to the position of the sun in the sky (which really means to the earth's orientation to the sun).High noon is 24 hours after the last high noon. So in conventional time keeping day stays day, and night stays night. But since astronomers need to study the stars they use sidereal time: in which the sun changes its position slightly day to day to day, but the background stars stay in the same place ( obviously the sun changes position in normal time due to the seasons as well- but Im giving a simplified explanation) and for astronomers every six months "day" and "night" do reverse.