Kraichgauer wrote:
While I got to watch The Whisperer in Darkness, which my wife had gotten me as a Valentine's gift on DVD. Basically, this was a tale by H.P. Lovecraft put on film. All I can say is, while I love Lovecraft, this, like most movie adaptions of his work, didn't translate well from page to screen. Still, better than most other Lovecraft adaptions out there.
It's funny how the unofficial Lovecraft movies are the best, the ones that capture the essence of his writing with the most accuracy and power. If someone asked me to name the best Lovecraft movie, I would say
The Thing, followed by
In the Mouth of Madness. As faithful as the HPL Historical Society movies are, they just come across to me as gimmicky novelties and fan films. I watch them and think "this is a pretty nifty modern silent film" rather than "this is a great film, and something that I'll be recommending to anyone who wants to know what Lovecraft is all about."