Dec 1st, recruiting people for the war on Christmas.
Vexcalibur wrote:
The only people that are for real flipping their sh** over what holiday greetings you use is Christians getting mad at Happy Holidays.
So by this, it logically follows that the person who created this thread is, by your definition, a Christian getting mad at Happy Holidays.
That seems a bit strange to me.
Bitoku wrote:
Vexcalibur wrote:
The only people that are for real flipping their sh** over what holiday greetings you use is Christians getting mad at Happy Holidays.
So by this, it logically follows that the person who created this thread is, by your definition, a Christian getting mad at Happy Holidays.
That seems a bit strange to me.
That was sarcasm.
Bitoku wrote:
Vexcalibur wrote:
A Christian getting told "Happy Holidays" is not the equivalent to a non-Christian (read: Jewish, Muslim) getting told "Merry Christmas".
You're right, it's actually much worse.
The problem here is when non-religous people are going around trying to tell religious people what they should or shouldn't be saying. If you're Christian, then you should be saying Merry Christmas. If you're Muslim, you should say whatever they say for Ramadan. If you're Jewish, you should say Happy Hanukah or whatever they say for that. But why say Happy Holidays? What does that even mean? Does it mean you're going so celebrate all of the different religious holidays that fall around this time of the year? Because if not, I really can't see how it makes any sense.
If you're going to celebrate one of the religious holidays, then stop beating around the bush and just say it by name. And if you're not celebrating any of the religious holidays, then just stop sounding stupid and shut up about the whole thing already.
"Happy Holidays" is useful in a retail/business environment since it doesn't alienate any consumer base. The ultimate goal of a business is to make as much money as humanly possible, so it pays not to offend anyone. That's why businesses and the media are perceived to be "politically correct". They don't care about Social Justice Warrior stuff. They just don't want a section of the consumer population to stop spending their money on their products.
TheGoggles wrote:
Bitoku wrote:
Vexcalibur wrote:
A Christian getting told "Happy Holidays" is not the equivalent to a non-Christian (read: Jewish, Muslim) getting told "Merry Christmas".
You're right, it's actually much worse.
The problem here is when non-religous people are going around trying to tell religious people what they should or shouldn't be saying. If you're Christian, then you should be saying Merry Christmas. If you're Muslim, you should say whatever they say for Ramadan. If you're Jewish, you should say Happy Hanukah or whatever they say for that. But why say Happy Holidays? What does that even mean? Does it mean you're going so celebrate all of the different religious holidays that fall around this time of the year? Because if not, I really can't see how it makes any sense.
If you're going to celebrate one of the religious holidays, then stop beating around the bush and just say it by name. And if you're not celebrating any of the religious holidays, then just stop sounding stupid and shut up about the whole thing already.
"Happy Holidays" is useful in a retail/business environment since it doesn't alienate any consumer base. The ultimate goal of a business is to make as much money as humanly possible, so it pays not to offend anyone. That's why businesses and the media are perceived to be "politically correct". They don't care about Social Justice Warrior stuff. They just don't want a section of the consumer population to stop spending their money on their products.
If that's the case, why do they break out the christmas stuff before Halloween these days? It certainly alienates me.
LKL wrote:
If that's the case, why do they break out the christmas stuff before Halloween these days? It certainly alienates me.
I was just in an two officially Islamic countries. In pretty much all the malls they have the decorations up for Christmas and they all say 'Merry Christmas', not 'Happy Holidays'. During my time there I also attended a Hindu festival, which was very interesting (the food was great). In the morning the call for prayer could be heard pretty much everywhere. Both have significant religious tensions and identity issues and I am sure the love of Christmas there was very much a support of the retail industry. During Islamic festivals you get really interesting pastries and they still had signs everywhere for Diwali (which you really have to attend at some point). If I took anything away from my time in such a polyglot environment it was that tolerance should not be a bland thing, like westernized Chinese food. If you are offended by the music and the decorations then TBH, have a cup of concrete.
_________________
Life is real ! Life is earnest!
And the grave is not its goal ;
Dust thou art, to dust returnest,
Was not spoken of the soul.
TheGoggles wrote:
"Happy Holidays" is useful in a retail/business environment since it doesn't alienate any consumer base. The ultimate goal of a business is to make as much money as humanly possible, so it pays not to offend anyone. That's why businesses and the media are perceived to be "politically correct". They don't care about Social Justice Warrior stuff. They just don't want a section of the consumer population to stop spending their money on their products.
I suppose this is a reason to use the term "Happy Holidays" instead of "Merry Christmas" or some other religious-specific term.
Not really sure that it's a good reason, mind you...
Merry Christmas heathens and thank you for not overcrowding heaven
We appreciate your gesture, making room for others at this time of year. After all if everyone got in...would anyone really want to go there?
May I suggest an alternative such as a Hindu heaven? Spicy huh? Or R'lyeh perhaps? Dreamy.
Either way, we are ready to X you out of X-mas and sincerely thank you for your sacrifice at this time. I hear Islam is looking to expand it's market, or Scientology...? ![]()
_________________
"I don't care half so much about making money as I do about making my point, and coming out ahead."
"What do I care about law? Ain't I got the power?"
Cornelius Vanderbilt
91 wrote:
LKL wrote:
If that's the case, why do they break out the christmas stuff before Halloween these days? It certainly alienates me.
I was just in an two officially Islamic countries. In pretty much all the malls they have the decorations up for Christmas and they all say 'Merry Christmas', not 'Happy Holidays'. During my time there I also attended a Hindu festival, which was very interesting (the food was great). In the morning the call for prayer could be heard pretty much everywhere. Both have significant religious tensions and identity issues and I am sure the love of Christmas there was very much a support of the retail industry. During Islamic festivals you get really interesting pastries and they still had signs everywhere for Diwali (which you really have to attend at some point). If I took anything away from my time in such a polyglot environment it was that tolerance should not be a bland thing, like westernized Chinese food. If you are offended by the music and the decorations then TBH, have a cup of concrete.
I'm not offended by the music and the decorations per se; I'm offended by the fact that they're out before Halloweeen. In your travels, are there any other regions where a one-day holiday has been stretched out to a quarter of the entire year?
LKL wrote:
I'm not offended by the music and the decorations per se; I'm offended by the fact that they're out before Halloweeen. In your travels, are there any other regions where a one-day holiday has been stretched out to a quarter of the entire year?
Well that's not fair, Hinduism has like a thousand festivals, they just all last one day. In Islam Ramdan goes on for ages but the late night food is awesome. Christmas is not a one day festival it is the Season of Advent. Certainly there is a retail aspect to Christmas but I'm not much of a grinch about it, I always find the decorations to be pretty good.
_________________
Life is real ! Life is earnest!
And the grave is not its goal ;
Dust thou art, to dust returnest,
Was not spoken of the soul.
Misslizard wrote:
^^^People would jump over ceremonial fires,maybe that's it.
When I was little I thought they were playing leap frog.
When I was little I thought they were playing leap frog.
Could be a reference to some daredevil thing like that that they were into the middle ages.
Most people imagine boys leap frogging. I think of it as ten solemn gentlemen from the House of Lords in powdered wigs leaping for your spouse's amusement. Which just doesnt compute.
91 wrote:
LKL wrote:
I'm not offended by the music and the decorations per se; I'm offended by the fact that they're out before Halloweeen. In your travels, are there any other regions where a one-day holiday has been stretched out to a quarter of the entire year?
Well that's not fair, Hinduism has like a thousand festivals, they just all last one day. In Islam Ramdan goes on for ages but the late night food is awesome. Christmas is not a one day festival it is the Season of Advent. Certainly there is a retail aspect to Christmas but I'm not much of a grinch about it, I always find the decorations to be pretty good.
IIrc the 'season of advent' used to at least be confined to just December.
AutisticMillionaire wrote:
Merry Christmas heathens and thank you for not overcrowding heaven 
We appreciate your gesture, making room for others at this time of year. After all if everyone got in...would anyone really want to go there?
May I suggest an alternative such as a Hindu heaven? Spicy huh? Or R'lyeh perhaps? Dreamy.
Either way, we are ready to X you out of X-mas and sincerely thank you for your sacrifice at this time. I hear Islam is looking to expand it's market, or Scientology...?
Christmas is a secular holiday. The meaning of Christmas? Gifts and family reunions. Tons of atheists celebrate "Christmas", as in take this time of the year to share with family and spend money like pigs. The spirit of Christmas? To make stores move from red to black. (Ever heard of "black" Friday?). It is good for the economy hence why stores advertise for everyone, and not just Xtians.

We appreciate your gesture, making room for others at this time of year. After all if everyone got in...would anyone really want to go there?
May I suggest an alternative such as a Hindu heaven? Spicy huh? Or R'lyeh perhaps? Dreamy.
Either way, we are ready to X you out of X-mas and sincerely thank you for your sacrifice at this time. I hear Islam is looking to expand it's market, or Scientology...?
_________________
.
| Similar Topics | |
|---|---|
| So what are you getting people for Christmas? |
21 Nov 2005, 11:09 pm |
| now recruiting |
04 Jan 2011, 8:23 pm |
| What are you wanting to buy people for Christmas? |
18 Oct 2008, 9:02 pm |
| Thread for people who actually like Christmas |
26 Dec 2013, 7:49 pm |
