Aspergers and victim complex
He doesn't "need" to do anything. What you think is helpful might not be. In reality, it's true that he can't (by can't I mean it's not realistic) expect it to attract women. It doesn't mean he will. Even if he doesn't accept that, it still doesn't invalidate his problem. People begin to blame him for his own misery and act like it's a trivial issue when they realize he won't accept their "helpful" advice. All I'm saying is in REALITY, things are more complicated. It's not necessarily about blame anymore. It's not just about him, and it's not just about society. There are many sides to every problem.
Also, being mean and invalidating to someone with a victim complex will make them regress into being more of a victim. It's literally not helping. It becomes a cycle where people get mad, blame them, they feel victimized again, people are once again angry, so on. It's funny watching it happen sometimes. Tough love advocates are extremely oblivious how their own role helps perpetrate a victim mentality.
He doesn't "need" to do anything. What you think is helpful might not be. In reality, it's true that he can't (by can't I mean it's not realistic) expect it to attract women. It doesn't mean he will. Even if he doesn't accept that, it still doesn't invalidate his problem. People begin to blame him for his own misery and act like it's a trivial issue when they realize he won't accept their "helpful" advice. All I'm saying is in REALITY, things are more complicated. It's not necessarily about blame anymore. It's not just about him, and it's not just about society. There are many sides to every problem.
He does "need" to do one thing. He needs to accept people are going to get sick of trying to give him help and or advice on here after they see the 10th thread on the same thing, and expect frustrated replies in the thread.
_________________
New dating site for geeks:
http://www.ingeeklove.com
My latest youtube video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8RnfTXt-Tu4
Everyone feels anxious sometimes, it is a natural human feeling....people get anxious over job interviews and various potential stressful situations which is natural. But if someone has an anxiety disorder it means they experience anxiety a lot more than the typical person and it causes them problems in functioning. I mean you've probably felt anxious...imagine if that was your default state much of the time, like constantly feeling that way for days, weeks or months.
Sort of the same issue with depression, everyone feels depressed...but having a depressive disorder means you feel like that so often it deeply interferes with your functioning...and its not always based on a reason someone would feel depressed. Like everything is good but you still feel like you have an empty void inside of you and can't feel the positive feelings you know you should be feeling.
Essentially all mental illnesses, are extremes of human behavior...like everyone feels anxious sometimes but not to the extent it constantly interferes with their life and functioning. With normal depression and anxiety that everyone experiences much of the time you can sort of push yourself through it and use willpower to sort of come out of it...but with having a mental illness its not so simple.
I do have an anxiety disorder and I have questioned it myself because I can't relate to other people with it. I wonder if what I am feeling is actually normal than a disorder. I guess the difference is I get it too much while everyone else doesn't get it as much as I do and they only have it in certain situations. My anxiety was real bad in my teens and then it got better. My anxiety has always came and went but yet I was on pills for it at age 15 and they helped. I don't fit into any anxiety disorder category but yet OCD is considered one.
_________________
Titanic is a good diaper movie, lots of flooding
Well, if this was just a miscommunication and you truly didn't mean how you seemed to be wording things, then you don't have to pay attention to half of what I said.
I, too, can have trouble wording what I actually mean. I don't think I did here, but one of the reasons this started to upset me so much is because NTs told me the same exact things that are being advocated here. I just see far too many grey areas to really put full blame on one person or another most of the time.
Being told that you can do something but you just have the "I can't" attitude can lead to more frustration. Pretty much you try, but you fail, and then you blame yourself because you figure well, people tell you that you CAN do it, but here you can't. So, the problem must be YOU. In that, you can regress into depression.
If this helps anyone: How I helped myself was learning to accept my emotions and thoughts. They are mine, and they are not bad. If I feel like complaining, I can. I let myself have "pity parties" and I don't feel guilty that I'm "wallowing" in depression like others have told me. It has resulted in drastic improvement of my life. I pretty much made a deal with my mind to accept me exactly as I am.
He doesn't "need" to do anything. What you think is helpful might not be. In reality, it's true that he can't (by can't I mean it's not realistic) expect it to attract women. It doesn't mean he will. Even if he doesn't accept that, it still doesn't invalidate his problem. People begin to blame him for his own misery and act like it's a trivial issue when they realize he won't accept their "helpful" advice. All I'm saying is in REALITY, things are more complicated. It's not necessarily about blame anymore. It's not just about him, and it's not just about society. There are many sides to every problem.
He does "need" to do one thing. He needs to accept people are going to get sick of trying to give him help and or advice on here after they see the 10th thread on the same thing, and expect frustrated replies in the thread.
But we have to accept that he may not accept that. It goes both ways. If people are so frustrated over a person that does that, they are enabling it by doing this "tough love" act. Not only that, but in the end, you will be the one frustrated, right? Also, remember: unless people ask for advice, they generally just want to be listened to. As in, they want to be told "It'll be OK, buddy" or something similar. This can actually build confidence over time and motivate. I have a rule usually: If I offer advice, don't be mad if people don't take it.
I've learned a few things from this thread.
But please know that I never actually dismiss someone's problem as "Not a problem".
_________________
New dating site for geeks:
http://www.ingeeklove.com
My latest youtube video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8RnfTXt-Tu4
Last edited by hale_bopp on 02 May 2014, 8:00 pm, edited 1 time in total.
He doesn't "need" to do anything. What you think is helpful might not be. In reality, it's true that he can't (by can't I mean it's not realistic) expect it to attract women. It doesn't mean he will. Even if he doesn't accept that, it still doesn't invalidate his problem. People begin to blame him for his own misery and act like it's a trivial issue when they realize he won't accept their "helpful" advice. All I'm saying is in REALITY, things are more complicated. It's not necessarily about blame anymore. It's not just about him, and it's not just about society. There are many sides to every problem.
He does "need" to do one thing. He needs to accept people are going to get sick of trying to give him help and or advice on here after they see the 10th thread on the same thing, and expect frustrated replies in the thread.
Perhaps he just wants support....but when is the last time this poster posted, I think I have a pretty good idea of which one is being talked about and as far as I know they have not posted in a long time. From what I understand they mentioned horrid living conditions with a rat infested bathroom and having next to no money to live on...living with a sister and mother who are mentally ill as well and living off disability checks. The impression I got was someone feeling really hopeless in need of some help and no idea how to get it...but remaining unhappy and needing to vent about it.
People like to think their advice is an immediate solution and get agressive towards people who don't find the advice helpful or cannot follow it for whatever reason.
_________________
Winter is coming.
Err.. I've never heard of them. That must have been someone else.
_________________
New dating site for geeks:
http://www.ingeeklove.com
My latest youtube video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8RnfTXt-Tu4
Re bullying, from pre-K to 12th grade, only the 7th grade was bully free. I'm intorvert and HSP too. In combination, I think that makes me a target -is being an antelope before a hungry lion a victim over-identification problem?
Here's the thing I want to ask you all who may know/relate. Have you experienced the effects of gaslighting, or character assassination, or severe ostracisicm or any much of such pyschopathy? One person on WP had said that was also a problem in her life with her brother. I've been experiencing this for long with my family. I'm in counseling over it all and can prove such actually happened to me by names, dates, places, witnesses, etc., but that doesn't matter. The counselor attributes it all to me (I've hardly spent 3 hours w/her and she's 1/2 my age with only a BA.)
So, while it is reported here by others that Aspies can be targeted for their naivatie, social awarkwardness, etc., and are prone to being bullied, does all such mean everything is our fault and we seek victim sympathy when we're undeservedly taken advantage of & accused? I mean, was Ingrid Bergman at fault in that "Gas Light" movie or was it her husband? Was Ingrid just seeking sympathy and feeling sorry for herself? Or, did she actually need help against her predator?
I'm poor now and have trouble finding work. My siblings benefited by taking advantage of me to the tune of $1m. Just one fraud of theirs, which I have the documents to prove would have me with $232k in the bank. I'm about near homeless and ill and others are saying it's "all my fault". I just want some justice recognition, not victim sympathy. Plus, I'd like some input on any experiences you may have had re this and any helpful advice on dealing with/recovering from such.
"Avoid the wicked" has been my motto, but that gets harder and now it's a bit late. Thanks for any comments
I had gas-lighting happen all of the time with ALL of my family and mental health professionals. The counselor seems irresponsible. If you want them to just listen, they should be doing that. In fact, in a place where you are supposed to feel safe, someone blaming you can cause you to run away and not get help for your problems again. This is a bad move on her part. VERY bad. And invalidating.
My mother has borderline personality disorder. She may or may not mean to manipulate (or appear to) people into believing she is a victim of my abuse and I do horrible things to her. That's what happened, though. As a result, I was told I was the cause of ALL of my family's problems. If only I would change, the rest of my family would too, I was told. The problem with this is that it's extremely irrational to believe that. In abusive situations, the victim is often blamed for the problems. If they are charming and manipulative (or appear that way), therapy sessions turn into scapegoating the actual patient time. I really think an experienced, objective, and empathetic psychologist would see through a lot of this. If they don't, therapy actually reinforces not only that the patient "deserves it", but that they are the ones who need help. I'm sure you know about how abusers work, so you will know this is one of the fundamental techniques they employ when essentially brainwashing you into staying in this dynamic so they can abuse you. They will blame everything on you, then come back and say sorry (maybe not say that at all, but there is usually a period of "niceness" if you want to call it that) and eventually you feel nuts inside. Gas-lighting is even worse. It makes you question your own memories and sanity, essentially locking you into this horrible cycle if you can't manage to get "yourself" back.
Intentions do matter, hale_bopp. Sometimes, even though our intention is to be good, how we word things is different from our intentions. That's why how people word things can often be the difference between being supportive or being, well, nasty. And I won't lie, I've done this, too. I have to be consciously aware of how I word things at all times, especially because I'm sensitive myself and I hate it when people word things in a way which upsets me. Some might consider that walking on eggshells. I say it's because I've had a bad life and I just want people to say supportive words to me.
Sometimes, in our heads, we picture saying this response that is well thought out. In reality, it may be well thought out, but the way in which it is phrased really changes the meaning. That may or may not be what's going on here. All I know is that people have dismissed me all my life, and part of being "empowered" and taking my life back is stopping people and saying, "NO! My feelings, thoughts, and experiences ARE valid, and so is this persons!" By stopping the same type of language used by people that have abused me, hurt me, and broke me, people begin to learn that what they say really DOES matter.
Also, sometimes certain word usage is so common and taboo to criticize that people don't even fathom it could hurt people. After all, if it's so common, people think it couldn't do that. Example: It's kind of like saying sexist stuff "accidentally". You pretty much just repeat things you've heard your whole life without really deconstructing it and figuring out it really is sexist. Therefor, you might argue that it's not sexist unless you take a critical view of it yourself.
Last edited by bleh12345 on 02 May 2014, 8:15 pm, edited 1 time in total.
I've never heard the term "gaslighting" before today.
That's a terrible thing to do: create false memory, or deny true memories.
There is a very good movie about this....its an old black and white movie, can't think of the name. But basically its about this woman being gaslighted by her family or some relatives that where trying to steal from her essentially by inducing her to have a mental breakdown and think she was losing it. Its a very disturbing movie but its a perfect portrayal of what gaslighting could look like.
Essentially its trying to make someone question their sanity, and feel as though they are totally out of their head...when reality they aren't and its other people deliberately doing things to make that person feel as though they are going totally insane and are becoming entirely incompetent. Its a very sick form of abuse in my opinion. I think the term initially came from an incident where some guy would turn on what is called a gas light when it was already turned off so his wife thought she was going crazy because she'd put it out but then it would be lit again ....so the husband told her she was delusional, never actually turned it off and was going insane if I remember right.
_________________
Winter is coming.
Thanks. Bleh. This whole situation has me in a spin. My new "counselor" is young, not highly educated or experienced - very green, into forms and simplistic tests. Just one horrible example is that she decided I had agoraphobia - I had to show her pictures of how I grew up on the range and vast open spaces, vacation in that and love it! I was a a pilot, mountain climber, black-slope siker, big game hunter and fisher! I'm an agoraphile! So, talk about getting it wrong and deferring to "family" is really unreal. I need to get out of this. I am invalidated and feel unsafe/not listened to. But want to "leave my record", true grit and all.
Yes, there is the family/group projection problem you experienced. Sorry. Borderlines are very difficult. Mine were meglomaniacs/malignant narcissists and psychopaths. The results/effects of such can be the same. I went into intensive research on all this alone, no other help. One thing I can and would like to share with you all, if you've gone through such or feel vulnerable, is: www.aftermath-survivingpsychopathy.org . More info can be found at www.ponerology.blogspot.com (ponerology is the science of the study of evil) - I'd read "The Sociopath Next Door" by Martha Stout, PhD in '09 when this crap was billowing upon me again. Clinically, at least 25% of the population has such anti-social personality disorders and it is written that such do seek marks/targets among others for their own gain. "Crazy making" is one of the techniques used. So, your insights/comments helped.
Self protection needs to be learned and developed. Aspies can be too trusting. Too late I tuned into such ASPD types. I see the clues now better and I need to listen to my "gut" when I feel I'm in sick situations. Appreciate the input, hang in there.
| Similar Topics | |
|---|---|
| Aspergers Syndrome and complex emotions/interactions |
12 May 2012, 9:51 am |
| the victim box |
17 May 2013, 3:11 pm |
| Another Victim |
09 Mar 2008, 10:27 am |
| Are you a Victim? |
14 Jul 2011, 3:07 am |

