Labeling gone too far or not?

Post Reply New Topic

I like having labels to some extent. Personally I have autism, Tourette syndrome, Obsessive compulsive disorder and ADHD. That's already quite a lot. Technically speaking though, it would be easy to label myself with many more conditions even though they might actually be parts of the four main conditions. To be honest, ADHD and OCD (In my case at least) are probably part of my Tourettes.) I could also (self) diagnose:

Dyspraxia
Dysgraphia
Proposognasia
Intermittent explosive disorder/rage attacks
Dyscalculia
sensory processing disorder
auditory integration disorder
misophonia

etc.

Most of these 'conditions', you could argue, are parts of my main diagnoses of autism and TS. Is there any benefit in labelling each thing separately? Not that I can see. You can almost develop an obsession with labels which either borders on or becomes an OCD obsession which is extremely unhealthy. If people learn to see each individual with maybe one or two diagnoses as unique, then this is more beneficial than having a long list of labels as long as the problems are treated.

_________________
I have HFA, ADHD, OCD & Tourette syndrome. I love animals, especially my bunnies and hamster. I skate in a roller derby team (but I'll try not to bite )

I think illnesses have been invented (eg personality disorders) for people with annoying traits that impair them because they are hard to be with and they alienate people around them. They have even made grieving into a condition because some people grieve to a point where they play the blame game and it has torn families apart and sometimes they blame it on someone thinking they did it and they can't move on accepting that person had nothing to do with the death of someone. I will agree this is a "disorder" if this is what they are talking about when they say how they are making it a condition.

I wonder when ignorance will become a condition or stupidity or being an as*hole. I am not saying problems are not real, I just think they have all been given names and there are still people out there that have problems but don't fit in either box due to not enough symptoms so we have NOS labels or labels they don't even have enough for for a DX but are given that label anyway and sometimes people are treated for their symptoms than for a condition.

Think of when Asperger's was just being a quirk and people with it were just eccentric and absent minded. Now it's a condition because times have changed. Back when my parents were kids, having poor social skills was just eccentric, now it's a disability because they are now required when in the past they could still get jobs and live a normal life but times have changed. Plus I believe with this Asperger's label now and the whole autism spectrum, less aspies are learning because they are letting themselves be held back by it or their parents are doing it. Temple Grandin has talked about this too and also said in a video on youtube that people who are less affected by her can't even walk into a fast food place and order their own food and she can do that. My mom used to make me order my own food and would help me if I had trouble but I was still expected to say it. I had to overcome that fear and shyness and learning what to say when I order. I still have troubles with it sometimes but I still get through it.

Education has changed too so now there are more people with learning differences because work isn't taught their style anymore so they now need accommodations. I remember being told in 6th grade I have a different learning style and then I found out that was the reason why I was having problems learning in school and why I would get frustrated and then start acting up. I always thought I was stupid and I couldn't understand why I couldn't be smart and be like everyone else. Supposedly it was my Asperger's that caused this, that is what I have been told.

I think when society keeps changing, more and more problems will keep being discovered and then a new name would be invented for it. I feel I would have been "normal" if I lived in my grandparents time from when they were kids or young adults but I would just be seen as different or weird or eccentric or odd or a loner or shy or rude. My grandma managed to live through life without any labels. My mom thought she was Bipolar and she and dad also thought she had Asperger's and she had anxiety. Only DX she ever got was Alzheimer's and that was back in the late 90's. But times have changed and now getting employment is hard (it's hard for anyone) and I collect disability. Do I like it? Not really.