The controversy over ABA for autism
The controversy over ABA: "These advocates, many of them childhood recipients of ABA, say that the therapy is harmful. They contend that ABA is based on a cruel premise . . . "
“ABA has a predatory approach to parents,” says Ari Ne’eman
https://spectrumnews.org/features/deep- ... n-therapy/
_________________
I'm Alex Plank, the founder of Wrong Planet. Follow me (Alex Plank) on Blue Sky: https://bsky.app/profile/alexplank.bsky.social
androbot01
Veteran
Joined: 17 Sep 2014
Age: 53
Gender: Female
Posts: 6,746
Location: Kingston, Ontario, Canada
The core problem with ABA is that “the focus is placed on changing behaviors to make an autistic child appear non-autistic, instead of trying to figure out why an individual is exhibiting a certain behavior,”
If ABA therapists think their treatments can make a client's autism disappear they are mistaken. ABA can teach you the proper script and expectations of socializing, but it will only be an act. And performing this act is costly to people with autism. ABA teaches you to hate who you are.
The core problem with ABA is that “the focus is placed on changing behaviors to make an autistic child appear non-autistic, instead of trying to figure out why an individual is exhibiting a certain behavior,”
If ABA therapists think their treatments can make a client's autism disappear they are mistaken. ABA can teach you the proper script and expectations of socializing, but it will only be an act. And performing this act is costly to people with autism. ABA teaches you to hate who you are.
^ Well said. I probably would have said something like that.
_________________
ever changing evolving and growing
I am pieplup i have level 3 autism and a number of severe mental illnesses. I am rarely active on here anymore.
I run a discord for moderate-severely autistic people if anyone would like to join. You can also contact me on discord @Pieplup or by email at [email protected]
I'm looking into exactly this at the moment - I've seen how negatively my son responds to coercion of any kind, in particular in terms of his self-esteem and feelings of real motivation, and it seems to me that not only punishments but also supposed 'positive reinforcements' - let's face it, the withdrawal or withholding of which, if the desired behaviour or result is not forthcoming, amounts to punishment in any case - are counterproductive. They actually seem to work against creativity, self-esteem, sense of community and voluntary collaboration, self-motivation and the happiness of individuals and of society as a whole.
I'll look into the article you recommend, and I'd be very interested (also by PM) to hear what your personal and direct experiences - your own or others you know - of this issue are. I feel it's perhaps premature to be jumping to conclusions of my own, based on my experience of one child Also it's clear that ABA and its equivalents have many strong advocates, hardly surprising in our culture. I'm quite scared to attempt to stand up against it, and all it stands for (as well as competitive models, conformism for its own sake, and lots of other standard procedures in parenting and schooling today), but I feel I have to do so.
I'm on a bit of a mission - my husband says I'm obsessed (!), but I can see what damaging effects on all children but in particular on ASD ones, these strategies have (last year I worked in the school where my son attended and I did a lot of observation there). I want to do something about it. I'm still thinking about what ..
ASPartOfMe
Veteran
Joined: 25 Aug 2013
Age: 66
Gender: Male
Posts: 34,462
Location: Long Island, New York
They complain we are to literal, to repetitive and have to much black and white thinking but then they push a treatment based on repetition and defining right and wrong behavoirs (SMH).
Supporters love to throw "evidence based" to stifle dissent but ignore the evidence that lessining or ending the treatments lessens the "desired" results. ABA is at most permenent band aid approach.
Of course while trying 25 to 40 hours a week to get the "desired" result they ignore the mental illnesses that maybe caused by bieng told in one way or another that you are wrong. Also ignored is teaching impressionable young children to conform to others wishes 25 to 40 hours a week you are going to create adults that are conformists who are unable to stand up for themselves.
_________________
Professionally Identified and joined WP August 26, 2013
DSM 5: Autism Spectrum Disorder, DSM IV: Aspergers Moderate Severity
It is Autism Acceptance Month
“My autism is not a superpower. It also isn’t some kind of god-forsaken, endless fountain of suffering inflicted on my family. It’s just part of who I am as a person”. - Sara Luterman
Supporters love to throw "evidence based" to stifle dissent but ignore the evidence that lessining or ending the treatments lessens the "desired" results. ABA is at most permenent band aid approach.
Of course while trying 25 to 40 hours a week to get the "desired" result they ignore the mental illnesses that maybe caused by bieng told in one way or another that you are wrong. Also ignored is teaching impressionable young children to conform to others wishes 25 to 40 hours a week you are going to create adults that are conformists who are unable to stand up for themselves.
ASPartOfMe, I think I see what you're saying, and this is what I also suspect..
Yes, as for claiming that the techniques are 'evidence based', the fact is that rewarding and punishing DO usually 'work', if you wish to obtain short-term compliance (which many parents and educators take to be a sign of being successful, without thinking more deeply about it).
So too few people ask: 'they work, but towards what end?'
I believe you are correct about what kind of adults you are helping to create
ASPartOfMe
Veteran
Joined: 25 Aug 2013
Age: 66
Gender: Male
Posts: 34,462
Location: Long Island, New York
Supporters love to throw "evidence based" to stifle dissent but ignore the evidence that lessining or ending the treatments lessens the "desired" results. ABA is at most permenent band aid approach.
Of course while trying 25 to 40 hours a week to get the "desired" result they ignore the mental illnesses that maybe caused by bieng told in one way or another that you are wrong. Also ignored is teaching impressionable young children to conform to others wishes 25 to 40 hours a week you are going to create adults that are conformists who are unable to stand up for themselves.
ASPartOfMe, I think I see what you're saying, and this is what I also suspect..
Yes, as for claiming that the techniques are 'evidence based', the fact is that rewarding and punishing DO usually 'work', if you wish to obtain short-term compliance (which many parents and educators take to be a sign of being successful, without thinking more deeply about it).
So too few people ask: 'they work, but towards what end?'
I believe you are correct about what kind of adults you are helping to create
Is ABA considered the "gold standard" treatment for Autism in Italy like it is in America?
_________________
Professionally Identified and joined WP August 26, 2013
DSM 5: Autism Spectrum Disorder, DSM IV: Aspergers Moderate Severity
It is Autism Acceptance Month
“My autism is not a superpower. It also isn’t some kind of god-forsaken, endless fountain of suffering inflicted on my family. It’s just part of who I am as a person”. - Sara Luterman
The core problem with ABA is that “the focus is placed on changing behaviors to make an autistic child appear non-autistic, instead of trying to figure out why an individual is exhibiting a certain behavior,”
If ABA therapists think their treatments can make a client's autism disappear they are mistaken. ABA can teach you the proper script and expectations of socializing, but it will only be an act. And performing this act is costly to people with autism. ABA teaches you to hate who you are.
^ Well said. I probably would have said something like that.
I agree and that's the worst thing you can do to a kid on the spectrum, or any child.
_________________
Who wants to adopt a Sweet Pea?
The core problem with ABA is that “the focus is placed on changing behaviors to make an autistic child appear non-autistic, instead of trying to figure out why an individual is exhibiting a certain behavior,”
If ABA therapists think their treatments can make a client's autism disappear they are mistaken. ABA can teach you the proper script and expectations of socializing, but it will only be an act. And performing this act is costly to people with autism. ABA teaches you to hate who you are.
^ Well said. I probably would have said something like that.
I agree and that's the worst thing you can do to a kid on the spectrum, or any child.
Supporters love to throw "evidence based" to stifle dissent but ignore the evidence that lessining or ending the treatments lessens the "desired" results. ABA is at most permenent band aid approach.
Of course while trying 25 to 40 hours a week to get the "desired" result they ignore the mental illnesses that maybe caused by bieng told in one way or another that you are wrong. Also ignored is teaching impressionable young children to conform to others wishes 25 to 40 hours a week you are going to create adults that are conformists who are unable to stand up for themselves.
ASPartOfMe, I think I see what you're saying, and this is what I also suspect..
Yes, as for claiming that the techniques are 'evidence based', the fact is that rewarding and punishing DO usually 'work', if you wish to obtain short-term compliance (which many parents and educators take to be a sign of being successful, without thinking more deeply about it).
So too few people ask: 'they work, but towards what end?'
I believe you are correct about what kind of adults you are helping to create
Is ABA considered the "gold standard" treatment for Autism in Italy like it is in America?
Not to the same extent, though the principles are the same for raising children all over in the developed world...
I was shocked to find out that it is standard in schools in Germany to use ABA on autistic kids, though they make a point that they only use the 'positive reinforcements'.
When I began to read a bit of Alfie Kohn on the principles used in education (competition, rewards, grading, etc.), that was when I began to to see that actually we are basing our methodologies on a lot of assumptions about what is good for people. I mean for things like developing autonomy, self-motivation, decisiveness, powers of analysis, self esteem, resourcefulness. And so on. The things we think we'd like for our kids but may be going about it in a slightly misguided way, to put it mildly. If you then go on to read John Taylor Gatto then you may also start to wonder WHY the system is set up how it is.....
Whether I or anyone I know has had ABA used on them? Thankfully no. But I have enough experience of the principles (having also worked in schools, and specialised in education theory) to know how they work. But of course the really important thing again, is to ask ourselves not just IF they work, but TO WHAT PURPOSE?? Short term compliance, usually. Conformist behaviour, probably. But what does that achieve for those kids in the long run? The things I listed above? I don't think so.. it sounds like we're all pretty much in agreement about this. Though the mainstream system isn't, or course - very far from it!
Similar Topics | |
---|---|
Autism |
13 Mar 2024, 7:44 am |
When autism is more obvious in some than others! |
16 Feb 2024, 5:31 am |
Grief and Autism |
13 Feb 2024, 1:53 pm |
Autism Question. |
10 Mar 2024, 6:30 pm |