rosered wrote:
Here's my dirty little secret, i love the police captains voice LOL
does anyone else?
Yes. One of my special interests is knowing who people are when they've a face or voice that appeals to me. Ted Levine as Stottelmayer-not sure how to spell the character's name. He was Jaime Gumm (the killer with the skin fixation) in "Silence of the Lambs". Looks much different now, but I knew the voice was familiar when I first saw the show "Monk".
Tony Shaloub is interesting as another actor I've noticed, too.
Admit I wish his character would "come out" as having Asperger's...Would it really narrow or shrink the target demographic audience ? If ASD's are suddenly so prevalent, one would think TV execs. or writers would be in favor of identifying "Monk" as having that dx.
Danielismyname wrote:
Sometimes they show his OCD a little too overtly, but they're pointing it out for those who aren't as familiar with the disorder as many of “us” are, and it's a big part of the show obviously…so that’s cool.
Agree. His "hangups" seem so arbitrary & strange to me-except when they actually seem comparable to mine. I find the writing & setups to be predictable & kinda' boring (sorry to say)-but I still watch it because of what I do enjoy about "Monk".
cecilfinkelstien wrote:
The one thing I hate is when tv or movies make fools out of people with ailments. It makes me feel like a freak show when I have some of the traits like the charector. I felt this way kinda in Rainman but more so in Mozart and the Whale. I don't know maybe I'm just self- conscience. I love my positive traits and its about time the entertainment industry got it right. Good job monk!
My non-aspie (but OCD) boyfriend likes the show (and the movie "Mozart & the Whale"). He says they (the show & the film) help him understand me & see things that he recognizes. I'm too focussed on particular dissimilarities between myself & these others, I feel so unique.
"Rainman" I saw long before my dx, so I didn't think I was that way-though parts felt familiar, to a lesser degree of severity or extremity. But that was the case for any "different" "outsider" "mentally iconoclastic" character I'd see or hear about, I identified with whichever bits seemed "like me" & discarded the bits that I couldn't relate to.
gekitsu wrote:
for one, the show really is entertaining and not too shallow to be boring, but not too deep to make it too heavy to digest.
but what i think is really great about monk is that a character with a lot of autistic traits is displayed in a way that everyone likes him. for the way he is, adrian monk is displayed as a most loveable person. i think that this is a big step for us - more than autistic pride day and all the demonstrations together.
even the obsessions, which freak a lot of people out, are displayed in a positive way
Appreciate the intent of the show, even when I quibble with the details or concessions made to mainstream audience. It's just part of who he is, it doesn't make him a bad or dangerous person-sometimes seems that message hasn't been absorbed by society, it's good that the show reminds people of that. Also, the dual experiences of being both trapped & empowered by one's neurological difference, how strengths & weaknesses originate from same trait/wiring/temperment. Individuals aren't all strong or all weak, each is a blend of more or less of both, in a wide variety of life aspects.
_________________
*"I don't know what it is, but I know what it isn't."*