21 Sep 2017, 2:04 pm
jrjones9933 wrote:
Underweight and stronger than I look, usually. I did go into BMI overweight territory for a year. I feel and look the best at the very top of my BMI healthy range. I can handle cold temperatures better, have more energy, and my mood stabilizes when I get good nutrition and stay active. I can also have bad nutrition occasionally without much worry. 
BMI is not accurate, and I would refrain from using that as an accurate way to estimate body fat percentage, which it simply cannot do.
21 Sep 2017, 3:25 pm
rvacountrysinger wrote:
jrjones9933 wrote:
Underweight and stronger than I look, usually. I did go into BMI overweight territory for a year. I feel and look the best at the very top of my BMI healthy range. I can handle cold temperatures better, have more energy, and my mood stabilizes when I get good nutrition and stay active. I can also have bad nutrition occasionally without much worry.
BMI is not accurate, and I would refrain from using that as an accurate way to estimate body fat percentage, which it simply cannot do.
BMI is not measuring your body fat. Those are two different things. BMIs are very accurate but not for pregnant women and those who are body builders.
You can be in the normal BMI range and still be skinny fat. That means you have more body fat than muscle and that also isn't healthy either.
21 Sep 2017, 5:49 pm
Biscuitman wrote:
had eating disorders as a teen, it just became a total obsession of mine and ruled my life.
20 years later after not having eating disorders but certainly obsessing over my weight at times and fluctuating down, and even further down, I discovered weight lifting and love it. In the gym 5 days a week, there is loads to learn (so I can obsess over that!) it makes me feel good about myself, makes me sleep really well and keeps my head on straight every day!
20 years later after not having eating disorders but certainly obsessing over my weight at times and fluctuating down, and even further down, I discovered weight lifting and love it. In the gym 5 days a week, there is loads to learn (so I can obsess over that!) it makes me feel good about myself, makes me sleep really well and keeps my head on straight every day!
Weight lifting helped me get over my issues with food and weight as well. I used to be underweight but now I am well into the normal range with quite a lot of muscle. The only weight I obsess over these days is how much I can lift
I feel the same way about how much it helps keep my head on every day. I'd go crazy without it.
jrjones9933
Veteran
Joined: 13 May 2011
Age: 55
Gender: Male
Posts: 13,144
Location: The end of the northwest passage
21 Sep 2017, 6:44 pm
League_Girl wrote:
rvacountrysinger wrote:
jrjones9933 wrote:
Underweight and stronger than I look, usually. I did go into BMI overweight territory for a year. I feel and look the best at the very top of my BMI healthy range. I can handle cold temperatures better, have more energy, and my mood stabilizes when I get good nutrition and stay active. I can also have bad nutrition occasionally without much worry.
BMI is not accurate, and I would refrain from using that as an accurate way to estimate body fat percentage, which it simply cannot do.
BMI is not measuring your body fat. Those are two different things. BMIs are very accurate but not for pregnant women and those who are body builders.
You can be in the normal BMI range and still be skinny fat. That means you have more body fat than muscle and that also isn't healthy either.
I could have a lot of muscle to fat ratios at my preferred BMI, but I meant the ones where I eat well and stay active. If I have healthy levels of both fat and muscle, I feel the best.
22 Sep 2017, 12:40 am
22 Sep 2017, 12:44 pm
League_Girl wrote:
rvacountrysinger wrote:
jrjones9933 wrote:
Underweight and stronger than I look, usually. I did go into BMI overweight territory for a year. I feel and look the best at the very top of my BMI healthy range. I can handle cold temperatures better, have more energy, and my mood stabilizes when I get good nutrition and stay active. I can also have bad nutrition occasionally without much worry.
BMI is not accurate, and I would refrain from using that as an accurate way to estimate body fat percentage, which it simply cannot do.
BMI is not measuring your body fat. Those are two different things. BMIs are very accurate but not for pregnant women and those who are body builders.
You can be in the normal BMI range and still be skinny fat. That means you have more body fat than muscle and that also isn't healthy either.
Definitely not accurate if people with too much body fat are still considered a "healthy weight" . And by contrast, people with low body fat are considered overweight or even obese according to a BMI. I thik a better estimate would be body measurements. It does vary by height, but men are obese at around 40 inch waist or more, and women at 35 inches.
22 Sep 2017, 1:19 pm
22 Sep 2017, 6:08 pm
rvacountrysinger wrote:
League_Girl wrote:
rvacountrysinger wrote:
jrjones9933 wrote:
Underweight and stronger than I look, usually. I did go into BMI overweight territory for a year. I feel and look the best at the very top of my BMI healthy range. I can handle cold temperatures better, have more energy, and my mood stabilizes when I get good nutrition and stay active. I can also have bad nutrition occasionally without much worry.
BMI is not accurate, and I would refrain from using that as an accurate way to estimate body fat percentage, which it simply cannot do.
BMI is not measuring your body fat. Those are two different things. BMIs are very accurate but not for pregnant women and those who are body builders.
You can be in the normal BMI range and still be skinny fat. That means you have more body fat than muscle and that also isn't healthy either.
Definitely not accurate if people with too much body fat are still considered a "healthy weight" . And by contrast, people with low body fat are considered overweight or even obese according to a BMI. I thik a better estimate would be body measurements. It does vary by height, but men are obese at around 40 inch waist or more, and women at 35 inches.
BMI=Body Mass Index
BFP: Body Fat Percentage.
Both two different things. BMI is not measuring how much body fat you have. I used to have that misconception too until I joined r/fatlogic.
StampySquiddyFan
Veteran
Joined: 19 Jul 2017
Age: 20
Gender: Female
Posts: 3,754
Location: Stampy's Lovely World
22 Sep 2017, 6:16 pm
Quote:
You can be in the normal BMI range and still be skinny fat. That means you have more body fat than muscle and that also isn't healthy either.
And this is where I fall into
.I have an average BMI and I am not overweight, but I am certainly not physically fit either!
23 Sep 2017, 4:07 am
23 Sep 2017, 11:05 am
24 Sep 2017, 12:56 pm
24 Sep 2017, 12:59 pm
League_Girl wrote:
rvacountrysinger wrote:
League_Girl wrote:
rvacountrysinger wrote:
jrjones9933 wrote:
Underweight and stronger than I look, usually. I did go into BMI overweight territory for a year. I feel and look the best at the very top of my BMI healthy range. I can handle cold temperatures better, have more energy, and my mood stabilizes when I get good nutrition and stay active. I can also have bad nutrition occasionally without much worry.
BMI is not accurate, and I would refrain from using that as an accurate way to estimate body fat percentage, which it simply cannot do.
BMI is not measuring your body fat. Those are two different things. BMIs are very accurate but not for pregnant women and those who are body builders.
You can be in the normal BMI range and still be skinny fat. That means you have more body fat than muscle and that also isn't healthy either.
Definitely not accurate if people with too much body fat are still considered a "healthy weight" . And by contrast, people with low body fat are considered overweight or even obese according to a BMI. I thik a better estimate would be body measurements. It does vary by height, but men are obese at around 40 inch waist or more, and women at 35 inches.
BMI=Body Mass Index
BFP: Body Fat Percentage.
Both two different things. BMI is not measuring how much body fat you have. I used to have that misconception too until I joined r/fatlogic.
But that was my point. Body fat percentage is more related to health, so why is BMI used as the litmus test for obesity? If it can't determine the body fat vs muscle ratio. It may even give people a false sense of security .
25 Sep 2017, 9:21 pm
I have about an 18 BMI. My anorexic friend literally has higher than that (don't tell her ). I walk about twenty miles a day.
26 Sep 2017, 12:11 am
| Similar Topics | |
|---|---|
| Putting on weight as you gey older? |
Yesterday, 2:29 pm |
| Oprah's Weight Loss Special |
04 Apr 2024, 9:36 pm |
| Losing weight as a picky eater? |
26 Feb 2024, 9:15 pm |
| Baby Suffocated in Couch Cushions Under Weight of Her Sleepi |
07 Apr 2024, 8:42 am |
