Orwell wrote:
Here's one advantage of my "outdated" Debian system. I've still got Gnome 2.30 with support for the next couple years until someone else gets around to writing a workable desktop environment. KDE4 is almost usable by now, so it should be good enough when I finally have to leave Squeeze. Or maybe Gnome3 will suck less by then.
I get that. And I'd be lying if I said I wasn't tempted to try Debian again, throughout this "Unity"-inspired distro-hopping binge I've been on.
I simply don't agree with their philosophy. (particularly regarding "non-free" modules/drivers and the Mozilla branding.)
I've been trying out Arch for the last couple of weeks, and so far, I'm pretty happy with it. It's
insanely fast, great documentation, and I like the rolling release concept.
Though I'll admit, I don't fully agree with "The Arch Way" either. It's like, "simple is doing everything yourself". (Or if you prefer, "freedom is slavery"

)
In any case, Mate seems perfectly stable and usable at this point. And Cinnamon also seems promising.
Hopefully the success of these projects will convince Gnome and Cannonical to change course - Whether by merging Cinnamon, or taking a whole new direction.