#
Should students be allowed to use a calculator in school?

That would mean is that dyscalculiacs receive a lesser education.

Lesser education? Can you explain?

We were allowed TI-nSpires even on portions of the SAT.

I'll never know why schools buy TI-nSpires when they are more expensive than netbooks all for less capability. The TI-84s they replaced were fine anyway. Just about spending **ALL** of the budget whether it is necessary or not. They claim to be short of funds these days, I wonder why...

_________________

******************************************************

-Richardj / richard3700hz

nick007

Veteran

Joined: 4 May 2010

Age: 36

Gender: Male

Posts: 22,266

Location: was Louisiana but now Vermont

I have a TI-86 that I used in class. I played games on it sometimes during class. It comes in handy when comparing stats in RPG games. I can see a few different problems written out & compare the numbers.

_________________

*But I don't want to go among mad people, Alice remarked.*

Oh, you can't help that, said the Cat: we're all mad here. I'm mad. You're mad.

How do you know I'm mad? said Alice.

You must be, said the Cat, or you wouldn't have come here.

Oh, you can't help that, said the Cat: we're all mad here. I'm mad. You're mad.

How do you know I'm mad? said Alice.

You must be, said the Cat, or you wouldn't have come here.

https://collegereadiness.collegeboard.o ... tor-policy

They won't let you use calculators that can communicate with the outside world. Or feature a better data entry technique.

That would mean is that dyscalculiacs receive a lesser education.

Lesser education? Can you explain?

If they've been permitted to reach a given grade, while not having learned the same things as their non-dyscalculiac peers to get that grade, they leave school with a lesser education

*vis-à-vis*those non-dyscalculiacs, while having been duped by a given grade into thinking otherwise.

*vis-à-vis*those non-dyscalculiacs, while having been duped by a given grade into thinking otherwise.

But, that is always the case. There are always exceptional students who will learn far more than anyone else. I figured out two variable calculus at before I completed high school education at 17 years old as part of a voluntary class I took during lunch time taught by a highly gifted teacher for his enthusiastic students. As well as those who learn far less. Educational achievement is just a much a spectrum as autism is a spectrum.

Tollorin

Veteran

Joined: 14 Jun 2009

Age: 37

Gender: Male

Posts: 3,165

Location: Sherbrooke, Québec, Canada

Define "math skills".

Mathematics is more that just arithmetic, and having the right to use calculators from middle school made a great difference for me, as I had a lot more ease with algebra and what came after that with arithmetic; to the point of having perfect scores in algebra tests and some mathematics beyond, while I was struggling with mathematics test in elementary school.

I'm bad at arithmetic, but not in all of mathematics.

*vis-à-vis*those non-dyscalculiacs, while having been duped by a given grade into thinking otherwise.

But, that is always the case. There are always exceptional students who will learn far more than anyone else. I figured out two variable calculus at before I completed high school education at 17 years old as part of a voluntary class I took during lunch time taught by a highly gifted teacher for his enthusiastic students. As well as those who learn far less. Educational achievement is just a much a spectrum as autism is a spectrum.

The point I'm making is about the corruption of standards.

SRSLY?

Everyone in my class were using calculators. I remember my math teacher was like: "in my time we weren't allowed to use them". I got 85 in math and that was even in the LOWEST level of math class (yes, all the idiots who have trouble in practical subjects)

I would be damned without a calc. I thank the guy who invented it, he made me graduate high school so I could do my Bachelors in something not math related. However my Masters is more related to math/physics and I like it - just as long as I don't do the calculations on paper (that's what computers are for).

Yes, in many places of employment automation has eliminated the need for human calculator skills.

Unfortunately for aspies this means that other skills, such as social interactions with customers, are now more important that your ability to calculate sales tax. But who can calculate sales tax with three significant digits? It is 6.35% in Connecticut.

Calculators are tools. Computers are tools. Some of the Math software available are really out of this world. It can take math tasks that would take weeks to figure out and make it possible to do it in seconds.

So I feel it is really important to learn how to do math long hand in school. One must know the basics. But then it is equally important to know how to use other tools like calculators and computers to streamline the process of getting to the correct answer.

Sometimes I shop for groceries or other items. Everything is automated. The clerks do not even know how to add and subtract. The cash register tells them how much change to return. Very simple. But sometimes the cash register doesn't alway work correctly. It may miss the discounted price and charge the original price rather than the sales price. The clerks sometimes are in a quandary not knowing how to figure and solve the problem. So yes I think the basics are fairly important.

I also think that it is important to know how to read a map. Everyone relies on GPS systems to navigate places and that is all fine and good. But a massive solar storm can destroy the GPS satellites and the GPS system can as a result become inoperative. And I worry that many people will be unable to even find their way home. Map reading is a basic tool in navigation.

I agree with everything Jimmy said; children leaving school unable to do basic arithmetic or to read/write/speak proper English is one of the most terrifying trends in the modern world. Cartographic illiteracy is another thing that really gets on my nerves. Where were the teachers and parents?

Similar Topics | |
---|---|

New York Middle School Allowed Nooses As A School Display |
23 Mar 2019, 1:33 pm |

Should NT students be allowed to take "smart drugs" |
06 Jan 2009, 8:03 am |

Should NT students be allowed to take "smart drugs" |
23 Jul 2009, 3:58 am |

I'm NOT allowed to go to school |
16 May 2007, 11:34 am |