PG-13 Movies That Should Have Been Rated R

Post Reply New Topic

What movies that were rated PG-13 do you think should have better off rated R?

I can think of one PG-13 movie that was *nearly* rated R: Gremlins. I read on TV Tropes they were originally going to have Billy's mother decapitated by one of the Gremlins after she puree'd one in a blender and blew up another in a microwave, and Billy was to come home to see his mom's head rolling down the stairs.
But they wanted to keep the movie at a PG-13 rating so they left that part out, but it's why you don't see much of her until near the end of the movie. You got to admit though, she was one tough mom for directly killing those other vicious Gremlins!

Star Wars Clone Wars tv series (and 'animated movie') clearly have R rated stuff.

The clones are shown getting murdered nonstop, some in rather horrific and imaginative ways... and also the droid army is routinely seen executing wounded/on the ground clones.

I don't really agree with movie ratings...it depends on the person what movies/shows people can handle. I have seen R rated movies that seem perfectly appropriate for younger audiences and I've seen PG-13 movies that would probably disturb some 13 year olds. Ratings tend to be rather inaccurate, for instance violence is ok for PG 13 but bad language automatically gets an R rating....so half they time I don't get how they decide on the standards by which to rate things.

I agree. Film ratings are stupid, mainly because of how they influence the way movies are made. A lot of R-rated films have actually had to be toned down in content just to avoid getting NC-17, so that more theaters will show them. Likewise, a lot of films that would have originally gotten G or PG ratings have had extra "mature" content added conspicuously just to move them up into the next rating bracket, to encourage ticket sales. The one trend that annoys me the most however, is how a lot of action movies and such are being toned down in content to get into the PG-13 "sweet spot", as PG-13 is the highest unrestricted rating in the MPAA system.

I liked it better back when filmmakers weren't pressured to make their films conform to certain ratings to ensure sales.

Anyway, back to the original topic, one PG-13 film that surprised me was Salt. That movie was crazy violent even compared to a lot of R-rated films I've seen. Awesome movie, but damn. Another was Goldeneye. Granted, Goldeneye was probably typical for PG-13 films in the mid-90s, but I think it would come close to getting an R-rating today, depending on who's day it is to determine the ratings.