Optimal numbers of resposes in discussion threads?

Post Reply New Topic

This discusison-forum seemed like the best place to post. (Re-edited from previous post).

Through my experience with WrongPlanet, one statistical criteria of note is how many responses are within discussion-thread topics within any given WP Forum.

A few examples from my experiences.

For WP in-general, two-dozen (24) responses seems most optimal - that is discussion-threads containing more than two-dozen responses may become too confusing in scope to follow, and understand.

The 'General Autism Discussion,' and the 'In-Depth Adult Life Discussion' forums seem to contain examples of discussion threads where a two-dozen response (rough) guideline seems optimal.

Exceptions to the two-dozen response (rough) benchmark apply -that is the true dynamics of the 'Politics, Philosophy, and Religion' and 'Random Discussion' forums may become apparent when over three-dozen (36) responses are in discussion-thread topics in these two forums.

As few as one-dozen (12) responses in discussion-threads in the forums; 'Social Skills and Making Friends' - 'WrongPlanet.net Discussion', and the 'Computers, Math, Science, and Technology' forums seems optimal.

In most of the 'Topical Discussion Forums' - discussion threads containing between twelve and twenty-four (12-24) responses might provide just enough content to minimize confusion.

Outside of rough benchmarks, has WrongPlanet reassessed just what may, or may not be optimal numbers of responses for each of WPs (29) forums? Is there a "consensus of sorts?"

Statistical information to that degree of precision is not recorded.

I don't think the optimal number of responses per forum has ever been considered: the forums operate on a "whoever posts, posts - threads thrive or fade based on that activity" basis with no consideration given to optimal responses.

In some threads, one response is optimal.

In others, maybe 500 or so.

Some threads have gone for 300 pages and have 4000 replies (like the ones about dreams).
Others -just one reply is enough.

And isnt the word "optimum"? And not "optimal"?

optimal: adjective

best; most likely to bring success or advantage:
 Several treatment sessions are required in order to obtain optimal results.
 Conditions in the chamber are optimal for diffusion, reaching very high temperatures.
Synonym: optimum

https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictio ... sh/optimal