Killing babies no different from abortion, experts say

Post Reply New Topic

In a singularity scenario, there will be a lot of people who gather in communities to live only with the technology they have right before it happens. If the day comes I think I'll be one of those people, with the exception of medical technology.

It'll truly be our cultural and ontological version of the 'gray goo' scenario and I don't know, especially when nanobots and drones the size of flies go out created and armed by super-intelligences built by super-intelligences built by super-intelligences, that there will be any place on earth that will be safe from such invasion.

Here are my comments on this article. 1. The difference between a zygote, and a viable foetus is that the latter can survive, and function outside the womb. The question remains however, just when does viability begin. http://www.bbc.co.uk/ethics/abortion/child/alive_1.shtml I also happen to think that infants have at least some cognitive function. Therefore they have a personal psyche. Therefore I do not think that it would be an appropiate for any people to have the authority to diminish the inherent indivisual value of some persons simply because they have some charecteristics that might make them less worthwhile to some people. This was what happened in such times, and places, as ancient Rome, under the pater familis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pater_familias#Children, and also in Nazi Germany, with regard to Aktion T4. So none of this is new. 2. I want to address this quotation, from the OP article.

I think there's a grey area on the continuum.

It's perfectly acceptable to kill a 2 week old embryo.

It is not acceptable to kill a 12 year old child.

That's doesn't mean there is a point in between those two where suddenly it stops being acceptable to kill.

IMO a newborn baby human is "below" a newborn chimp, and certainly an adult chimp. If you have the choice to save an adult chimp or a newborn baby from a housefire, then assuming neither possessed particularly importance for you then you should save the chimp, which is more aware of its surroundings, capable of "higher thought" than the baby, and so forth.