Should girls be beaten less severely than boys?
Every day throughout the South, Black children routinely receive beatings from school officials. Call it the South's "Peculiar Institution."
This time, the victim was a diminutive White girl
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2EWRJb0MtUg[/youtube]
The beating left her buttocks severely bruised and blistered.
The fact that, this time, the victim was a little blonde honour student of course elevated the nation's interest. A typical little Black girl, and no-one would have cared.
Anyway, the girl volunteered for the beating (to avoid being compelled to miss another day of classes), and her mother said "Go ahead, flog away", with the understanding that the beating would be administered by a woman.
Apparently, the big strong male vice president was turned on strongly enough at the idea of stroking this lovely lass's ass, that he did not want to defer the opportunity to anyone else.
The issue, for Texan mothers, is that they feel that White girls should only be beaten by adult White women, who would, presumably, beat their daughters more gently.
So, what say ye? Should girls be entitled to less severe beatings than boys? Or, has Feminism run amok in the South?
Last edited by ArrantPariah on 11 Oct 2012, 10:26 am, edited 1 time in total.
Shatbat
Veteran
Joined: 19 Feb 2012
Age: 31
Gender: Male
Posts: 5,791
Location: Where two great rivers meet
I don't like the idea of school officers beating students, in general.
But assuming I was and going from there, women should be beat by women and men by men, especially when something as sexually charged as spanking is involved. Black or white is irrelevant, that part was just racist.
_________________
To build may have to be the slow and laborious task of years. To destroy can be the thoughtless act of a single day. - Winston Churchill
But assuming I was and going from there, women should be beat by women and men by men, .
Why? That means men will get a harder punishment because women literally hit like girls. It's gender discrimination to punish men harder than women (even though the rest of the legal system does as well).
Shatbat
Veteran
Joined: 19 Feb 2012
Age: 31
Gender: Male
Posts: 5,791
Location: Where two great rivers meet
Well, it should be a heavy handed woman. The alternative is having some creep getting pleasure from spaking his students. But what if we could be assured the guy doing the spanking would do it without getting any gratification from it? Or what if it was a woman doing the spanking but she was a creep? Ideally the one doing the spaking should be professional about it, regardless of gender, but realistically, what usually works on that aspect is dividing them in gender, as the police do when policemen are searched by men, and policewomen by women. That's not perfect either, but is the best solution I know.
And going back to the main idea, if it's between men getting beaten harder than women, and women getting sexually harassed over men, I'll have to pick the former, even though yes, it would be unfair towards men. That would be a problem, so women should be required to be more stern with their punishments, or men should be required to go easier on theirs.
But you know what? I like better the idea of not beating up anyone at all. If anything, that should be left to family (yeah I'm one of those who agree on physical punishment, as long as it doesn't leave anything worse than bruising, but this thread is not about that so please don't derail this specific topic if anyone disagrees with me on this issue)
_________________
To build may have to be the slow and laborious task of years. To destroy can be the thoughtless act of a single day. - Winston Churchill
Well, it should be a heavy handed woman. The alternative is having some creep getting pleasure from spaking his students. But what if we could be assured the guy doing the spanking would do it without getting any gratification from it? Or what if it was a woman doing the spanking but she was a creep? Ideally the one doing the spaking should be professional about it, regardless of gender, but realistically, what usually works on that aspect is dividing them in gender, as the police do where policemen are searched by men, and policewomen by women. That's not perfect either, but is the best solution I know.
What if the student being spanked is a masochist that enjoys a nice spanking by an authority figure? What if the student is a gay masochist getting pleasure off it? The reason why dividing by gender for being searched would work is that physical strength is not a big issue there, but here both the tendency I'd be of women of not only hitting more softly due to strength issues but also due to feeling sorry for the person being spanked play a role.
Moral of the story, don't cheat.
*On an unrelated note, as a man I prefer being searched by female police officers and TSA agents.*
If we really want to go scientific, we could put a pressure pad on the behind of the student to measure the impact of each swing.
I do find it ironic, that you consider every single instance of punishment towards a male being "sterner" as less of an evil than perhaps women feeling sexually harassed some percentage of the time.
Of course, I will be quoting you the next time I need to defend my argument that society has ALWAYS valued women over men.
No one should be beaten, period. To suggest that anytime a male administers physical punishment to a female, that it's sexual in nature and he gets off on it is f*****g absurd. Not only that, but it plays into the whole "well, he's male, so he must want to rape me" BS.
Not every man is a rapist, god damnit. NOBODY SHOULD BE BEATEN, but if they're going to do it, it needs to be done EQUALLY to EVERYONE, as much as that's even possible. This question need not even be asked... What kind of f****d up society is this, where we honestly have to even ask these kinds of questions? Here we go again, women want special treatment but claim to be equal... MAKE UP YOUR MINDS.
Perhaps a new professional advancement class for teachers?
Corporeal Punishment 101: Beating Children for Fun and Profit
Covering topics such as: how to not leave marks, paddle vs. hand, and how to disguise an erection.
Similar Topics | |
---|---|
Autistic Boys and Men Camouflage, Too |
05 Feb 2024, 8:37 am |
We don't girls here - Parents protest outside school |
31 Jan 2024, 4:20 pm |
L.I. county bans trans athletes from competing with girls |
08 Mar 2024, 12:32 pm |
Autistic Girls Face Three Times the Risk of Sexual Assault |
16 Feb 2024, 9:46 pm |