Why do Americans consider Canada to be a left wing country?

Post Reply New Topic

I'm Canadian, and I'm not insulted or offended by it at all, I just often hear Americans online call Canada, a more left wing country than the US is, but that makes me think why do you think that?

The government has less freedoms on things in Canada and more restrictions on things compared to the US, so I've always thought of Canada as more right wing, compared to the US, so I wonder why Americans think that, just out of shear curiosity, if anyone knows?

More social security network - healthcare, education, etc. - from what I gather.
Less importance of radical religions.
But I'm Atlantic away, I might not know well enough.

Yes, it is more left wing. The Canadian prime minister recently banned "assault weapons". There is socialized healthcare. The more left wing party is in power. You can more easily get in legal trouble just for saying things deemed offensive. All of these things are, at least in American politics- left wing positions.

Well the thing, I don't understand is, is that left wing means people wanting equality and freedoms, and more rights. Or that is what I read.

Where as things like more severe gun control, and not having freedom of speech as much, is not freedom and equality. So therefore, wouldn't that make it more right, if there is less freedom and equality there?

Then, that's the difference of what one considers "right" or "left".
It varies locally. Generally, I think, the Left is more progressive and the Right is more conservative. But, as countries have different histories, being "progressive" and "conservative" may mean different postulates in different parts of the world.

Conservatism in particular can be highly variable from country to country, and across time.

In C19th Britain it was the conservatives who made it legal for the poorest classes to vote.
But that was after a long period of conservative governments using armed force to repress their political movements.
Changed their minds in the course of a generation.

Oh okay, well I am quoting a wikipedia page, and here is what it says:

"Generally, the left-wing is characterized by an emphasis on "ideas such as freedom, equality, fraternity, rights, progress, reform and internationalism" while the right-wing is characterized by an emphasis on "notions such as authority, hierarchy, order, duty, tradition, reaction and nationalism"

But if that's true, it seems Canada is right wing, since bringing in new severe gun control, and less freedom of speech is authority and hierarcy, isn't it?

Left. We take away or limit rights to the few, and benefit the many.

Some Americans can make a lot of money, and pay low taxes because of deductions.

Canadians don't appear to have many deductions.

Why must people own assault weapons?

From what I see now, in America, the right wing puts more emphasis on individual freedom and the left wing puts more emphasis on cooperation and responsibility for environment, so those lists of values are not really precise.

I think in the US, there is a freedom vs equality thing, with the (local) left opting on equality first and the (local) right opting for freedom first.

Is it because Canada has left hand drive cars?