I voted for creamy, since it's my favorite, but I like all peanutbutter - even the thick, oily natural kind. I prefer Simply Jif (white label - reduced sugar and salt). I eat it right out of the jar with a spoon.
Peanutbutter and chocolate is the best combination ever. But since I don't like milk chocolate, "with peanut(butter)" is the only way I can tolerate it. I won't eat plain M&Ms, but I LOVE Peanut M&Ms. I detest plain milk chocolate bars, but I LOVE Reese's Peanutbutter Cups! (Dark chocolate rules!)
When I was in school, my lunch every day was a peanut butter and strawberry jelly sandwich, a banana, and a nickle for milk. (Sound familiar, Scoots? ) Lucky you on getting the Oreos, too - the banana was supposed to be my dessert!
Even better than peanutbutter: Nutella. Now that stuff is seriously addicting...