Autism Talk TV - Ep. 6 - Steve Silberman - Pt 1

Post Reply New Topic

According to the statement she made at the time, Alison Singer left Autism Speaks because she disagreed with their continued focus on vaccines as a likely cause of autism:

I think it is a good idea to try to change Autism Speaks from the inside. It is the best way to change the attitude in society, as most NTs will not go here to get their information. I've been on their boards, and receive their emails since a while back, but I have limited time for doing anything productive. In fact, I prefer to voice my rather radical ideas on my site & blog instead.

I don't mind if we have dialogues and debates with Autism Speaks, because there are things we can learn from each other and movements that don't try to understand and communicate effectively with their opponents (and that's what Autism Speaks should be at this time) get dogmatic and stagnant. I liked hearing the arguments of Peter Bell, although he does strike me as somewhat phony, and i thoroughly enjoyed the interview with Geraldine Dawson. She seems much more in-line with our position than that of Autism Speaks, and i wonder what she's doing there, of all the awareness organizations there are.
But why the hell is an episode of Autism Talk TV being sponsored by that organization? There are fundamental ideological differences between Wrongplanet and Autism Speaks. We are by autistics, and primarily for autistics. Their demographic is parents and professionals, and they DO NOT HAVE AUTISTIC PEOPLE IN POSITIONS OF POWER. They support a "cure," treat autism like a conventional "illness," and do not recognize aspergians and the high-functioning as even being autistic. Our site recognizes everyone on the spectrum, plus those with ADD, PDD, etc. This is what i was told about the site's mission, and the reason for our disagreement with Autism Speaks. Was that all propaganda?
If they want to reconcile with us, they should publicly take back their offensive positions. If they have done that, good for them. If not, they are not our "friends" and we should not take their sponsorship money.
No one can force Autism Speaks to change, they have to want to. As long as they are the group they are, we have to present a real alternative.

I doubt very much that Autism Speaks will change its core values. It doesn't believe that autism should exist. Attempting to sue activists who spoke out against it didn't work. Now it's trying another tactic. Attempting to negotiate with these people won't change them; it will only change us. It will turn us into Uncle Toms.

Alison Singer wanted to drive off the bridge because she was in despair and probably majorly depressed, this does happen. Also having thoughts about things that you would never do is not unusual I would have thought.

This is a great interview guys. I'm looking forward to watching part-two. My THANKS to everyone involved.

What a wonderful interview with Steve. It's encouraging to think we have contributed to society.

Also, if Alex wants to interview Autism Speaks then so be it, it's his website after all. If it weren't for him we wouldn't have this "autistic haven" we call Wrong Planet. Thanks Alex for providing us with this website and the interviews, etc!

thanks guys! Part 2 is now on the front page.

hello

i think jack is good looking, i mean his t-shirt is nice