Overkill wrote:
If I wanted to win favor with the "troo" metal camp, I would say Justice. But if I'm really honest with myself, I'll have to go with the black album. Regardless of what the elitists say, it WAS a metal album. Besides, it was what ultimately introduced me to Metal.
And Justice For All was the album that converted me into a Metal fan, so there ya go.
So I say ....And Justice For All
With these runner ups:
Master of Puppets
The Black album
Death Magnetic (could have been mixed better though, particularly in regards to the drums)
I saw them live twice on the And Justice For All tour, and twice on the Black album tour (once with Guns n' Roses).
I also met 3 members during the And Justice For All tour, c/o working in the retail music industry.