#
Why is math so difficult to learn?

Funny thing is, I can't do PSLE maths (in Singapore here), which is what I would call "common sense maths".

But I'm quite fond of Elementary Mathematics and Additional Mathematics in Secondary level here.

dy/dx, dy/dx~

I'm not sure how to answer your question, but I think it may have to do with our perception of numbers and the way we can manipulate them, as well as our own biological mechanical functions (maybe poor memory, for memorising formulas etc).

Maybe it's difficulty with comprehension. Someone might explain to you again and again how to find the Square Root of a number through an equation, but at the end of the day you still don't follow what the hell they're talking about or what the point of it all is.

It's like trying to cross a language barrier. Often I think a popular technique of teaching a second language is merely Phrase Memorization. You might get around with that a bit but always feeling you don't really have a good proper grasp of your second language.

Otherwise there is language immersion which takes a lot longer but rewards you with superior comprehension.

I guess where I'm going with this thought is we tend to rely on the less time consuming Memorization of Equations method just to drive it into your head to pass exams. You don't know what square roots or why you would want to work them out but you can do them on paper for a test.

You are in good company, or at least plentiful company. The human brain is not particularly optimized for doing abstract mathematics. We are too attached to our linguistic function. Humans are genetically evolved to be blabber mouths, singers of song and tellers of story. We are not generally well suited for proving theorems rigorously. That is why there are so few first rate creative mathematicians.

ruveyn

I've never had any trouble with math. It comes natural to me.

I guess I'm just weird.

I think many people struggle with math because it is taught poorly by people who really don't have a solid understanding of math themselves.

I also agree with the hypothesis of math & language being somewhat incomparable.

Generally those who are really good at math, are challenged with language, so they have difficulty explaining it to others. And those who are good at language aren't very good at math, so they have a tough time explaining a subject they don't understand.

_________________

Your Aspie score: 172 of 200

Your neurotypical (non-autistic) score: 35 of 200

You are very likely an Aspie

Diagnosed in 2005

An interesting question,** DuneyBlues**. I shall attempt to give my explanation on the matter in the context below.

I *assume* it is due to the fact that in general, mathmatics (or math) relies dominantly on abstract, logical and cognitive processing. From a personal standpoint, I have experienced numerous individuals who have either found the subject to be very comprehensive from the start, to laboriously difficult. I would speculate that it holds some genetic correlation with how the left hemisphere of a person's brain is *structured*? You know, gray matter and all.

I personally indulge in math as a matter of usual practice (wherein I encounter occasions of spare time), as I am conjointly interested in subjects that to a large extent rely on it, Physics and Visual C++ scriptwriting being two notable examples, so it is, as a requirement, to have decent math skills in order to interpret the other subjects, which are in themselves not math, but rely on it predominantly (the same applies for Chemistry, as well, as it is a Science subject).

Nurture and other environmental factors are both applicable to take into hand, as well.

Last edited by Crysisrocks on 11 Dec 2011, 3:22 pm, edited 1 time in total.

LostInEmulation

Veteran

Joined: 10 Feb 2008

Age: 38

Gender: Female

Posts: 2,047

Location: Ireland, dreaming of Germany

Am I the only one who is seriously pissed off with the convention of every teacher and textbook to use either i and j or u and v or n and m as variables? For me, this visual barrier was there and it was annoying. Is it only because I am visually impaired?

_________________

I am not a native speaker. Please contact me if I made grammatical mistakes in the posting above.

Penguins cannot fly because what cannot fly cannot crash!

Possibly. These letters are easily distinguishable by most sighted-readers.

ruveyn

XFilesGeek

Forum Moderator

Joined: 24 Jul 2010

Age: 37

Gender: Female

Posts: 5,616

Location: The Oort Cloud

It's like trying to cross a language barrier. Often I think a popular technique of teaching a second language is merely Phrase Memorization. You might get around with that a bit but always feeling you don't really have a good proper grasp of your second language.

Otherwise there is language immersion which takes a lot longer but rewards you with superior comprehension.

I guess where I'm going with this thought is we tend to rely on the less time consuming Memorization of Equations method just to drive it into your head to pass exams. You don't know what square roots or why you would want to work them out but you can do them on paper for a test.

This.

_________________

"If we fail to anticipate the unforeseen or expect the unexpected in a universe of infinite possibilities, we may find ourselves at the mercy of anyone or anything that cannot be programmed, categorized or easily referenced."

-XFG (no longer a moderator)

Once reasoning was made rule based, others improved and expanded the logic used by mathematicians. Even so mathematics was not rendered "logical" until mid 19 th century and logic was not expressed in a mathematical manner until late 19 th century (Boole, Frege, Russel, Whitehead, Kantor and others).

ruveyn

The Greeks made some pretty major contributions to the development of mathematics but they also inherited some mathematics from the Egyptians and Babylonians.

The Greeks made some pretty major contributions to the development of mathematics but they also inherited some mathematics from the Egyptians and Babylonians.

Crude as Egyptian mathematics was, it was sufficient to use in building the great pyramids, which were the largest tallest structures on earth until the construction of the Eiffel Tower.

The Egyptians gave us tall structures. The Greeks opened the path to the Cosmos.

ruveyn

kxmode

Supporting Member

Joined: 14 Oct 2007

Gender: Male

Posts: 2,613

Location: In your neighborhood, knocking on your door. :)

I'd think it has something to do with how intensive on working memory a lot of elementary arithmetic (which, while not synonymous with math, is still used in it) and algebraic problems can be. I know in my case that pronounced deficits in spatial working memory and nonverbal processing speed have made quite a bit of mathematics (algebra problems, geometry, etc) rather difficult and time-consuming.

**Quote:**

about following directions, it’s about making new direction

- Paul Lockhart ,

*A Mathematicians Lament*

Sure but then we might as well say that most people who are "good at something" are really not. Living one's life is not about following directions...oh wait, it is.

Uh, no. Life isn't

*just*about following directions, it's also about comparing the relative advantages of different directions against one's profile of strengths and weaknesses and deciding which "to follow".

That is why there are so few first rate creative mathematicians.

ruveyn

Perhaps that explains why all these companies overstated their balance sheets and plunged the economy into recessions.

_________________

Scott, Founder/Program Director - GCA Centre for Adult Autism

**The mission of GCA Centre for Adult Autism:**

"Empowering the lives of autistic adults and young adults and their parents/caregivers by serving as a resource center to provide mutual support, information, and activities" in the Southeast USA

http://www.gcaspies.org

**2nd Annual Southeast Adult Autism Symposium**

- Early Bird online registration starts in late March 2018

- More information can be found at http://www.gcaspies.org/symposiumhomepage

Similar Topics | |
---|---|

Learn math or get better at math with Khan Academy! |
11 Mar 2011, 6:54 pm |

The Most Difficult Languages To Learn In The World |
19 Nov 2017, 1:45 pm |

at least two ways to learn math |
05 May 2016, 11:24 am |

How did the visual thinkers learn math? |
03 Jan 2012, 7:23 pm |