Free-Will

Post Reply New Topic

I tend to the view that there is no free-will in the sense that everything that happens is a result of what has happened before. I don't see how it is possible for something to spontaneousely occur that is not part of this deterministic process. That is not to say that novel things cannot arise, only that we are incapable of any intervention in the process.

Let me see otherwise if you can.

I agree. I think free will is a concept that was invented to justify punishment.

From an old post:
I am almost certain that free will (we chose to do things based solely on volition) does not exist. I think that the causes of our behavior are complex in that they are untraceable to a 'definite origin.' Imagine a line of dominoes as knocking the other down, one by one, you can always say, "this domino fell because the previous one pushed on it." But if you have a nearly infinite number of dominoes in an infinite amount of direction, ( which is reality) you then can't find or "sense" the casual chain, so we think the domino fell because 'it wanted to.' That is how I think we look at our own free will - it's an inexperience of the voluminous hidden mechanisms, or just merely the way we experience doing what we do.


This topic has been exhausted here and in many other places , but one cannot get away from the fact that we are essentially mechanic, and there is nothing behind the mechanism other than a network of neuronal switching relays, functioning on a linear timeline.

We feel free if we are unaware of the programming. But the reality of it is we become conscious that we have decided.

I think you're confusing free will with determinism.
Neither implies the other.

if there is no "free will", then an insurance company i see advertising on the TV continuously is falsely representing themselves.

in the ad i see in every ad break, it says that with every insurance policy bought, they will throw in a "free will" kit for....free.

i wonder how many people who are constrained by expectation have bought that insurance policy just to get the "free will" kit.

i wonder whether they got what they wanted.

And also there is a great variety of theories out there. Why just assume linearity? Seems this simplification is a few hundred years old now shamelessly used by everybody.
Does quantum theory kill determinism? How is free will defined, how does it work? How does determinism come into play? It is certainly not linear and possibly multi-dimensional problem. Determinists have to go great lengths to keep up with its opponents these days.