Should There Be a worldwide Moratorium on eating dog meat ?

Post Reply New Topic

Now of course I know in the US and Europe, eating dog meat is strictly taboo and I have a beloved pet dog and would never eat dog meat because I would just feel uncomfortable eating dogs or cats, for that matter. For the record, I couldn't eat wild squirrels or any kind of rabbits either but I might be able to tolerate venison.

So this post doesn't reflect what I personally would do or want to do.

This post is about others who aren't me and what they want to do and what they want to eat and it has an ethical component about what we should and shouldn't eat.

A festival in Yulin China is about to go underway and it draws a lot of fire because this particular region has traditionally eaten dog meat and this festival celebrated the consumption of canines. I am not going to post links because it's too graphic and upsetting so I am going to avoid that.

Now keep in mind, we, in the US eat plenty of cattle, pigs, chickens, turkeys, and fish. Buffalo and mutton are sometimes consumed to quench our delicate palates and it's not always pretty, what happens in the food chain, yet some would be appalled by the idea of eating dog meat. Right now this Yulin Festival (Yulin is a dog eating town) over in China is getting a lot of publicity because some want it to cease. But my question is, what about the consumption of dog meat in general? Does the world have a right to say to these people who have eaten it for generations they cannot eat it even though the majority of the world insists on eating animals and would not tolerate being told they must give up the consumption of beef, pork, chicken or turkey? Isn't it hypocritical and controlling to dictate what one culture will eat while refusing to be told what you will eat yourself?

What should be done is to make sure animals don't suffer when they're farmed.

What animal is farmed doesn't really matter.

I don't eat dog meat but I think if they're going to eat the dog or any animal then they shouldn't torture it like that and just kill it in a different fast less painful way

Lobster is put in a pot with a half inch of cold water. Then it is slowly brought to a boil.

Meat is meat in China.

Mostly called unwanted pets. Here the Vet, the Animal Shelter, kills millions, and throws them in a dumpster.

Americans spend more on dog food than Africa spends on food. We feed horses to dogs, or send them to Mexico where people eat them. The French eat horsemeat.

The intelligent thing to do would be collect unwanted pets in America, feed them the scraps from the slaughter of unwanted pets, as we do with cows and sheep. Then we can send them to a nice farm upstate where they can run and play all the way to the slaughter house, and their good meat can be frozen and sent to China.

One of our exports is chicken feet. They are popular in China.

As for China, a hundred years ago human flesh was openly for sale in the markets. Like the Aztecs meat is a craving where it is in short supply. Live on rice or corn, meat is drug strength food.

We are past peak soil. Worldwide a third of farmland has been ruined. It was the best that was farmed first. A hundred years ago most all farming was animal powered. Our mechanical and chemical farming is very new, and has reached the limits.

World population keeps increasing, and everyone wants some meat with their grain.

We as a people are throwing away hundreds of tons of meat others would eat.

We are valuing our pets above world hunger, and yet we abandon, take to the pound, or have killed at the vet, vast numbers of dogs.

Hungry people would think we are just mean. I have seen many people keep dogs that are dying alive. They are not happy.

I have had a stronger attachment to horses. All old, injured, or sick horses go to the glue factory. No one wants a 1200 pound dead animal in the yard.

All cattle are raised with slaughter in mind.

AIDS came from eating apes for bush meat.

Guinea pigs were developed as food by the Inca.

I do not think we should tell people what to eat.

Why ban eating one kind of animal but still allow another kind to be eaten?
Why eat pigs but not dogs? There are plenty of people that keep a pig as a pet, they are as smart and loyal as dogs, so should be stop eating pigs as well?

I understand why it is taboo to eat "traditional pets", but banning it, especially worldwide, is going too far.
As long as the animal has been treated with respect and killed quickly and painlessly, i don't see a problem with eating any kind of animal.

Personally, I find it a little weird how America places so much value on dogs and cats while not seeming to give a s**t about chickens or pigs or cows.

I agree there does seem to be a certain amount of hypocisy about eating dogs in China, But you should see the way animals are kept for sale and chickens waiting to be killed in private homes.

Dont like the idea of folks eating rover.

And I especially don't like the idea of folks torturing rover before eating him/her.

But there isnt much we can do about it. And the thing is that dogs aren't an endangered species. They may suffer, but they arent about to go extinct.

So for the moment I would rather see energy put into a moratorium on bushmeat, or on elephant ivory, than on one on eating a numerous non endangered domestic animal. At least thats the fight I would pick.

When I was in China, they didn't care what animal it was, they're all treated the same. Everything is food, and I'm fine with the idea of being able to eat everything (why should we waste dogs who are going to be killed anyway? Why not use the meat and the fur? Put them to use!) but I do not like the idea of how they treat animals.

Here in the states we have our own problems, and yes, a lot of hypocrisy. We also have organizations that try to help fix the problems we have here, so while we do have a lot of animal wastage, we have a higher rate of happier animals.
I don't think we should mess with them unless we're going to attack them for everything they torture, kill, and eat. We can't just pick one.