Philologos wrote:
Cultural appropriation - I know that is not the focus, but I cannot help reacting. Exactly what proportion of the culture of African sourced Americans - and cultures would be more correct - does anyone seriously believe is African? My answer - very little. A god bit of independently evolved due to voluntary / involuntrary segregation. And a lot of American melting pot.
Welcome back Philogos. Long time no see.
I hope that you realize that the posters on this thread who are talking about "cultural appropriation" are being purely sarcastic ( are making fun of folks who care about 'cultural appropriation'- whatever that even is).
But even if they were being serious - its "cultural appropriation from Black Americans" - but since you supposedly can't call Blacks "Blacks" anymore- you have to call them "African American"-you have to phrase it as "cultural appropriation from African Americans". But that doesn't necessarily mean that anyone is claiming that the culture being appropriated from African Americans is African in origin. Kinda like a "Kurt Vonnegut Jr. College". It would NOT be a "junior college". It would be a four year college named after a famous author whose name ended with "junior". Lol!
And you're right that though Blacks do have a distinct subculture in the USA very little of it is the legacy of Africa- and most is from separate cultural evolution right here in North America. Though if you dig deep enough you can find Africa in some areas of the Black subculture (like styles of Christian worship).In contrast much of Africa is quite obvious in the Black communities in Brazil, and in the Caribbean.