Parents question concerning dairy and gluten free diet

Page 1 of 2 [ 28 posts ]  Go to page 1, 2  Next


Is a dairy and gluten free diet helpful to autistic children?
Yes, it's important 8%  8%  [ 1 ]
No, it won't make any difference 92%  92%  [ 12 ]
Don't know but you should stick to it 0%  0%  [ 0 ]
Total votes : 13

BTDT
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 26 Jul 2010
Age: 60
Gender: Female
Posts: 7,120

22 Mar 2019, 8:46 am

Perhaps it would help to plot what he eats visually on a large graph, to help spot correlations with his health.



Jon81
Snowy Owl
Snowy Owl

Joined: 4 Jul 2018
Age: 43
Gender: Male
Posts: 168
Location: Sweden

24 Mar 2019, 3:00 pm

BTDT wrote:
I have no problem eating a gluten free diet. The other night I had rice, filet mignon, and a salad. I'm having grilled flank steak and rice today for lunch. Rice is better from a storage issue if you cook for one.

You could try the Lactaid pills to see if that changes the situation any. I find I can eat a small amount of ice cream at the beginning of lunch or dinner without issues.

I am Asian and do have lactose intolerance.

A kid may prefer baked or grilled meatballs instead of steak as being easier to eat.


He used to like rice. Now almost all the basic stuff in food has gone. It’s now down to mashed potatoe. He wants that for breakfast, brunch, lunch, dinner etc. Can’t get enough of it. At least it’s something. I don’t know if your diet consists of asian food, but the asian kitchen is just adorable with all its dishes – I don’t know if I’d put grilled meatballs in there?? Same with Indian food. Not a lot of gluten and dairy at all in those dishes.

Fnord wrote:
Jon81 wrote:
Fnord wrote:
The only people that such a diet would help are those who have lactose intolerance and/or celiac disease. Otherwise, you're just wasting your time.
Thank you for that input. I don't think we have any kind of intolerance on my family side. On my wives side there are some issues that are diffuse. Think they have something called IBS and then some gluten intolerance that her father has.
Yes, Irritable Bowel Syndrome may also require less gluten and/or dairy products, but that seems to vary from person to person.

There is a lot of false information regarding the causes and treatment of people with autism. There are even false claims of cures for autism -- DO NOT ATTEMPT TO USE THE "BLEACH CURE", as it could actually injure your child, cripple him, or even kill him.


I know there’s a lot of awful information out there. I’m considering myself smart enough to be able to shield off that kind of BS. However, there’s always someone out there willing to try so it’s a good thing to constantly try to inform people. Just last week Amazon had to withdraw a book on how to ”cure autism” because it contained information which I believe was that bleach cure method.
There are also numerous videos on youtube with autistic people talking about lifting some fog from their mind by changing their diet. I’m not looking so deep into all of that bio-med and diet as my wife is. I’m not sure what celiac disease is to be honest.

jimmy m wrote:
If your son is a picky eater, it is important to provide him vitamin/mineral supplements to ensure that he is not missing out on important vitamins because of his eating habits.


Yes, we are giving him some vitamins to keep him on track. It became apparent that something was missing from his diet when he constantly got sick.

fluffysaurus wrote:
Yes there is a terrible amount of bad and contradictory information out there about autism and a lot of it is aimed at either ripping parents off or blaming them. If you do not suspect your child of being dairy intolerant, then reintroduce dairy (very slowly because you may have made him intolerant by cutting it for so long) and the same with gluten. A general healthy diet is best for most people including autistics, unless you know there is an issue with something. I developed an intolerance to dairy as an adult but was fine with it as a child. It did not affect my autism and I am not intolerant to gluten. Before following any more advice feel free to check in here with it as a lot of the advice out there is useless and some is harmful, even dangerous.


It’s just crazy how some people can be so highly regarded and seen as experts when there’s no one out there who knows the full solution to the autism question. They call themselves doctors. One thing that I believe is one of the most desperate attempts are the DAN!-doctors. Those bio-med suppliments and checklists should be put in the same category as bioresonance therapy – absolute garbage.

BenderRodriguez wrote:
Sorry if this sounds harsh, but gluten-free bread and vegan cheese are neither particularly nutritious or appetising. It's perfectly possible to eat gluten, lactose free food that actually tastes great and has high nutritional value, but you need to do a lot of experimenting and cooking from scratch, using fresh ingredients.

If he's not actually intolerant, the diet won't help and if he actually is you'll need to find a better solution, or he'll probably stop eating altogether.


Arganger wrote:
It will only every help at all if she has an actual allergy or true sensitivity to it and most people don't.



MagicMeerkat wrote:
Unless they have a legit lactose or dairy allergy or intolerance and celiac disease, you're not going to accomplish anything.


I think this is the answer that I should try to get across to my wife…

underwater wrote:
Most people on this site are autistic, parents included. I'm an autistic parent to an NT child. You won't run into a lot of NT parents here, but I'd say we give better advice on this kind of issue.

Firstly, autistic people have higher incidences of autoimmune diseases than the average population, and particularly gastrointestinal issues. If you have reason to believe your child has such an illness, get him tested. If not, a varied diet helps with everything. A restricted diet makes everything worse, see https://www.theguardian.com/uk_news/sto ... 48,00.html

The thing is, modern diets contain unhealthy amounts of processed wheat and dairy. If your child doesn't have gastrointestinal issues, there is no reason to keep him gluten and dairy free. On the other hand it's important to limit such foodstuffs to reasonable amounts, and feed him enough fruit and veg. I notice myself that my ability to focus and communicate gets worse if I eat junk food or a very limited diet.

Some stims are for fun and some are because of stress. If he's stimming more, I 'd look for sources of stress in his environment, but having a restricted diet could be a source of stress. The eye thing is probably just a visual stim, I did lotsa that. Anyway, stimming is generally good. The stuff he is doing seems harmless, and it's important not to restrict stimming too much, it affects mental health badly. Detrimental stims may be redirected/replaced by other stims.

I second the vitamins and minerals. And watch out for sweeteners if IBS is an issue.


I consider myself NT but I’m not sure at all. I’ve been having these kind of feelings about being different since 1996 when I was chatting on the internet (mirc) and I noticed I just couldn’t keep a conversation going – at all. This became a big issue for me and I’ve always kept my ears open to learn from people around me. The frustrating thing is I can’t find the strategy to make it work. I just get exhausted from having to small talk. I get nothing out of it at all, however I can enjoy hearing others do the talking. And then I did this Rdos test (I belive that’s the name for it?) and ended up with something like 114p for AS and 106p NT. I asked my wife to do the test and she did. As she did the test she was making remarks on how many things were typical for me. Then as she showed me her results I understood that my results were not just a little bit off – they were awfully off. Her results were 8p AS and like… I don’t remember but 180p NT probably. My profile is a crap AS person and a crap NT person…

Went a bit off topic there, but I really enjoyed reading your post. Especially about the stims. Some stims are for fun? That’s really cute. I think I have found a stim that I haven’t been aware of. My jacket has rubber zippers on the pockets and not long ago I noticed they had lost their pathern because my fingers had been constantly rubbing them whenever I was wearing that jacket. Perhaps I should post a picture to show how ridiculous it is. I am not aware of that I’m doing it before I start thinking about it. Then I’m at it again just a couple of seconds later. Like a tic.



DW_a_mom wrote:
Underwater said much of what I was going to say.

yes, ASD children may have more food issues than NT kids.

no, the special diet won't help unless your child actually is sensitive to those foods.

Pure coincidence that a certain number of ASD children improved with the special diet. Let's be honest, if a child feels awful all the time he isn't gong to learn and he isn't going to behave his best. Remove the foods making him feel awful, and you will see improvements.

For my son, the food was soy (obviously it would have been self-defeating if we had tried being diary free with him). For others, it can be eggs. Red dye. You name it. ANYTHING people are commonly sensitive to might prove to be a problem for your unique child. The only way to know is by elimination diets (testing shows allergies, but not usually that tricky thing called "sensitivity"). We found my son's sensitivity by pure luck. That happens a lot. But let's be clear: my son was and still is ASD. That never changed. His level of comfort changed and, as a result, his mood and mind did. Healthy children are happier and easier going children.

All kids narrow their food choices around your child's age. I raised one ASD child and one NT child, and they BOTH got very picky, then eventually expanded their eating again. This is normal. Keep a healthy variety of food available to your child and let him eat naturally.

Kind of a side note, gluten and casein (in diary) don't have to be tied together. It is possible to be sensitive to one and not the other. The complete elimination of both is a traditional diet for Celiac disease. In the US some people believe that our gluten is particularly troublesome due to chemicals more common here than in other parts of the world. Soooo many factors go into how our bodies react to food, it really can be tricky figuring it out.


One of his cousins (supposedly NT but his half brother is the one who’s probably ASD) is in a picky period now. My little brother was the same with eating. It’s so easy to forget or just see what you have infront of you. Sometimes I just don’t know what a ”normal” child is suppose to do. And most of the times I think the NT children are the ones with the mental problems. My boy never touches any other kid or make trouble. The other kids are in his face and one is constantly bulling the others. I even found one of the kids, one who is completely nuts, in the process of strangling another kid one day when I came to pick up my boy.


_________________
Din Aspie poäng: 102 av 200
Din neurotypiska (icke-autistiska) poäng: 108 av 200
Du verkar ha både Aspie och neurotypiska drag
Diagnosed with ADHD 2022


MrsPeel
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 1 Oct 2017
Age: 52
Gender: Non-binary
Posts: 1,746
Location: Australia

25 Mar 2019, 2:36 am

I hesitated to post, because I've never tried gluten/casein free myself (it always seemed too difficult).
But this funny thing happened to me recently, thought I'd share for what it's worth.

I was trying to eat healthily so I started eating more whole grains, like wholemeal bread and brown rice. Just got chronic diarrhoea, painful joints and low mood for my trouble.

Read this book by Dr Grundy(?) called the Plant Paradox, about the problem with lectins(?) And an article about how glucosamine supplements bind gluten before they can pass through the gut and cause trouble.

So I axed the whole grains, went back to white bread, took a glucosamine tablet, and that straight away cleared up the diarrhoea 8O Still got a painful tendon in my foot, though, so... :?



kokopelli
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 27 Nov 2017
Gender: Male
Posts: 3,657
Location: amid the sunlight and the dust and the wind

25 Mar 2019, 6:53 am

I would hate to have a gluten free or dairy free diet imposed upon me, especially because it has become some kind of fad among hipsters.

I've been given gluten free cookies on occasion at someone's home and they were all, without exception, pretty bad. Not once did I want a second cookie and mainly just ate the first cookie to be polite.

While I don't eat cheese, I do like to use milk and butter in my cooking.

I suspect that both could gluten-free and dairy-free could work but only by sticking to foods that just don't have gluten or dairy products in them. But that would be a rather limited and boring diet.

For example, Indian food uses ghee which is a dairy product. Chinese food uses breading for some items but would otherwise probably be your best bet.

The worst, I think, is to try to replace dairy products or gluten products in your food. The reason those are used in the first place is that they work very well.

Unless there is a very specific medical condition requiring one to avoid gluten or dairy products, trying to follow some popular fad diet is just plain stupid.



kokopelli
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 27 Nov 2017
Gender: Male
Posts: 3,657
Location: amid the sunlight and the dust and the wind

25 Mar 2019, 6:59 am

BTDT wrote:
I have no problem eating a gluten free diet. The other night I had rice, filet mignon, and a salad. I'm having grilled flank steak and rice today for lunch. Rice is better from a storage issue if you cook for one.

You could try the Lactaid pills to see if that changes the situation any. I find I can eat a small amount of ice cream at the beginning of lunch or dinner without issues.

I am Asian and do have lactose intolerance.

A kid may prefer baked or grilled meatballs instead of steak as being easier to eat.


I ran out of lactaid about 8 months ago and didn't bother to get any more. I need to eat less ice cream anyway so now I just limit myself to about a scoop which I can handle.

One of my favorite deserts is a lime sherbet with sliced strawberries. For that, it needs to be a pretty strong lime taste. It works great with Kemp's lime sherbet but not much with Blue Bell's lime sherbet.



kokopelli
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 27 Nov 2017
Gender: Male
Posts: 3,657
Location: amid the sunlight and the dust and the wind

25 Mar 2019, 7:03 am

Jon81 wrote:
The reason we put him on the diet is because we were desperately looking for answer to why our boy just didn't develop all of a sudden. As a parent to an autistic child you will come across tons of material and there is no doctor in the world who can give you any kind of advice - it's usually on the contrary :cry:
So you have to make all these decisions all on your own and there's absolutely no time to lose. Judgement is not your strongest side under conditions such as depression, shock, despair, grief and anger. Some people go a lot further than just the dairy and gluten free diet. I think this diet thing was a small sacrifice to make if it could help him. Now I'm ready to re-evaluate this decision and I want to know what other parents (and perhaps autistics themselves) feel about this subject.

How is it good judgment to suddenly put a kid on some fad diet to try to solve some problem totally unrelated to that diet?

Hint: any time someone suggests a fad diet, punch them in the nose as hard as you can. Maybe they will get the message.



DW_a_mom
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 22 Feb 2008
Gender: Female
Posts: 13,687
Location: Northern California

29 Mar 2019, 12:05 am

Jon81 wrote:
There are also numerous videos on youtube with autistic people talking about lifting some fog from their mind by changing their diet.


It isn't just autistic people who say that. Lots of NTs who have decided they are gluten sensitive say the exact same thing.

It goes back to what I wrote earlier: if your child happens to be gluten sensitive, eliminating gluten will help him by making him feel better. If he isn't gluten sensitive, it won't do a thing. This isn't unique to ASD.

I also want to emphasize how much doing the wrong thing can backfire. I know more people who can't eat soy than I know who cannot have casein (from milk products). Be mindful that in following off the shelf advice you aren't actually making your child sicker.

Celiac disease can be medicially diagnosed. It runs in our family, but my ASD son does not have it. Both him and my husband ARE, however, sensitive to soy.

As normal as it is for kids to narrow their food choices at your child's age, it could also mean he instinctively knows some of these substitute foods make him feel bad.


_________________
Mom to an amazing young adult AS son, plus an also amazing non-AS daughter. Most likely part of the "Broader Autism Phenotype" (some traits).


BTDT
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 26 Jul 2010
Age: 60
Gender: Female
Posts: 7,120

29 Mar 2019, 9:24 am

I used to remove grease soaked batter off fried chicken. Someone pointed out to my parents that that was a very healthy eating habit.



Jon81
Snowy Owl
Snowy Owl

Joined: 4 Jul 2018
Age: 43
Gender: Male
Posts: 168
Location: Sweden

31 Mar 2019, 4:28 pm

kokopelli wrote:
How is it good judgment to suddenly put a kid on some fad diet to try to solve some problem totally unrelated to that diet?

Hint: any time someone suggests a fad diet, punch them in the nose as hard as you can. Maybe they will get the message.


It's good judgment because it won't kill him like a bleach bath would. So many reports saying food and the gut COULD have something to do with autism and how it develops. I'm not totally convinced there's any connection but my wife has a feeling there could be something and wants to explore the field. If you think about it there are plenty of things you could eat or drink that would have an effect on your brain.

However, I'm not totally convinced about it and I feel it's limiting us a lot in life - and we shouldn't be trying to limit ourselves as we already have a lot to deal with. That's the way I feel about it right now. I am also scared that I might ruin something we've started by wanting an easy way out. So I started this thread to see if any parents out there could tell me their experience. I didn't want to ask people who had already bought into the idea.

What I can understand from all the things being written here now is that gluten/dairy-free diets only helps with the medical condition of allergy and not autism - and that kind of answer is actually quite comforting.


_________________
Din Aspie poäng: 102 av 200
Din neurotypiska (icke-autistiska) poäng: 108 av 200
Du verkar ha både Aspie och neurotypiska drag
Diagnosed with ADHD 2022


BTDT
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 26 Jul 2010
Age: 60
Gender: Female
Posts: 7,120

31 Mar 2019, 4:40 pm

If you have autism you may be able to draw correlations based on memory. Some of us can do that. But, normal people either can't remember, or introduce unwanted bias into their recollections, so they need objective records.



DanielW
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 17 Jan 2019
Age: 35
Gender: Male
Posts: 1,873
Location: PNW USA

01 Apr 2019, 12:39 pm

Jon81 wrote:
[

It's good judgment because it won't kill him like a bleach bath would. So many reports saying food and the gut COULD have something to do with autism and how it develops. I'm not totally convinced there's any connection but my wife has a feeling there could be something and wants to explore the field. If you think about it there are plenty of things you could eat or drink that would have an effect on your brain.

However, I'm not totally convinced about it and I feel it's limiting us a lot in life - and we shouldn't be trying to limit ourselves as we already have a lot to deal with. That's the way I feel about it right now. I am also scared that I might ruin something we've started by wanting an easy way out. So I started this thread to see if any parents out there could tell me their experience. I didn't want to ask people who had already bought into the idea.

What I can understand from all the things being written here now is that gluten/dairy-free diets only helps with the medical condition of allergy and not autism - and that kind of answer is actually quite comforting.



And, please remember this is your child, not a science experiment. :-) Its just as likely that a gluten-free, dairy-free and a whatever else free diet can make an already difficult situation for the child, an even worse one.



BTDT
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 26 Jul 2010
Age: 60
Gender: Female
Posts: 7,120

01 Apr 2019, 12:52 pm

In a recent episode of Big Bang Theory Leonard realized that his childhood was a series of science experiments.



Jon81
Snowy Owl
Snowy Owl

Joined: 4 Jul 2018
Age: 43
Gender: Male
Posts: 168
Location: Sweden

02 Apr 2019, 4:58 am

BTDT wrote:
If you have autism you may be able to draw correlations based on memory. Some of us can do that. But, normal people either can't remember, or introduce unwanted bias into their recollections, so they need objective records.


I don't have a great working memory as described by some folks here. I can however remember absolutely stupid details that has nothing to do with the big picture. One example would be a classmate shows up 8:52 for a class that starts at 8:00. For some reason I just remember that irrelevant time he shows up. I later hear him say that he has two options, take an early bus and wait for an hour at school before class starts or grab a later bus and show up late for class. The following week the teacher asks if anyone knows where that guy is I just say straight out: - he will show up 8:52. Of course he shows up 8:52 and all of a sudden I am Nostradamus himself :lol:
But yeah, I don't think I could do that stuff out of memory. Can hardly even remember what I ate - or if I ate at all.

BTDT wrote:
In a recent episode of Big Bang Theory Leonard realized that his childhood was a series of science experiments.


DanielW wrote:

And, please remember this is your child, not a science experiment. :-) Its just as likely that a gluten-free, dairy-free and a whatever else free diet can make an already difficult situation for the child, an even worse one.


He's not a science experiment :) I am just doing whatever I can to help him reach his full potential.


_________________
Din Aspie poäng: 102 av 200
Din neurotypiska (icke-autistiska) poäng: 108 av 200
Du verkar ha både Aspie och neurotypiska drag
Diagnosed with ADHD 2022