Yupa wrote:
What I do find -really- confusing is that a lot of people whom I think would probably be in Gryffindor, judging from their personalities, fancy that they would be good Slytherins.
This applies especially to Draco fangirls.
The allure of evil!! There was a rumour that the person I fancy was a vampire...And I always think that naughty people are attractive. That said, though, Harry was almost put in Slytherin and begged to be put in Gryffindor with his mates. That carries quite an impact in the story - Harry is not by any stretch of the imagination a goody-two-shoes but made a conscious effort to choose the right path, a bit like Edmund in Lion/Witch/Wardrobe but with more initial success.
I went through a spell of siding with the White Witch in Narnia, if only to get away from what I perceived as the tyranny of the "perfect" people at school (and the rather suffocating goodness of the church). I came back to Narnia as an adult and to be honest find it hard to see why I was into the story at that sort of level. However I have been through what I see as a fall and redemption, so maybe I do think in that kind of a way.
_________________
I am the cat who walks by herself, and all places are alike to me --- (after) Rudyard Kipling
People don't want a date with destiny, they just want a date with a dentist. --- Michael Howard