pakled wrote:
that's what happens when you go up against the experts...
thanks. I learned the Mendelssohn bit in music class many decades ago...
There was the romantic idea of the forgotten and misunderstood genius Bach, sometime even spiced up that Bach died impoverished, recovered only by an other genius Mendelssohn.
This just not true: J. S. Bach wasn't popular, but still known and he died not in wealth, also not "impoverished"; his estate is known and there were plenty of books, instruments and even a very few pieces of silver.
Mendelssohn modelled Bach's works also to the taste of his time: Enormous choruses, whilst Bach just had choruses of three of four singer (there was just no more space in organ lock of St. Thomas in Leipzig), playing Bach on organs, which are not fit for baroque music (the so-called "Bach Organ" has a special temperament - mostly found with organs made by Trost; Bach even rejected Silbermann with his strict ideas regarding temperament). To perform Bach's organ works in Leipzig after the lost of all original Bach organs during the war, they build some years ago a special organ with a Bach-temperament, like the organ in Altenburg.