Would a saxophone work in this kind of context or no?

Post Reply New Topic

I am scoring a film project which is a crime thriller, where a character is seeking revenge for being raped. One instrument like the sound of is the tenor sax, but since it's been used for 70s porn and erotica, will it be a huge mistake to use an instrument that can be associated with that, for a project dealing with rape?

It's a strange question to ask but it's in my head as to whether or not I should use it for trhat reason. But I do nevertheless, like the sound of it a lot, so it's a tough call. What do you think?

You go by what serves the story. Not by whether or not you're a fan of the sound.

If you were scoring a movie set in ancient Egypt, say, you wouldnt fill the soundtrack with Elvis vocals just because you're an Elvis fan. Elvis would be a nonsequitar to the movie.

Yeah for sure, I would definitely use those in some sections, such as the more suspenseful parts, where I want a real strident sound.

But when it comes to the more mellow parts, I am wondering if I should use a sax or not. I was going for something like this, and was inspired by how the sax is played here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZcQlCxY ... 4E6B5f8lTg

It sounds dark, and thought it might fit since this is a dark story. But since the sax has been associated with erotica in movies, would it be a mistake to use it for a story involving a rape crime, even if it's used in a dark context like in this type of music example?

judgment call. i'd use a trumpet or cornet.

Oh okay, why would you say the sax is the incorrect choice?

not incorrect, just not 100% the best, that is why i said "judgment call."

Oh okay, but why not 100 percent the best in your opinion?

I hope this doesn't sound rude in anyway if anything it's sort of a compliment.

Let me get this straight,your that good of a composer that you have been commissioned for a film score.

You are then asking advice on a non music composition specific website on instrumentation.

I would go to a music composition website or composer subreddit at the very least.

I would email the person you studied composition with an ask them.

If you were commissioned for a film score you would have to have studied at a conservatory.Otherwise no film maker would give you the time of day.
I would call your old professor and talk with him.

No one on WP would know orchestration better than you.If you have doubts,email a professional.

I write music myself but I won't give you advice because I don't do film scores so I'm not qualified for this question.

i suggest watching the type of movie you wish to score, to see what they did.

I love a cello; and they can make very jarring notes if you have anything jarring in the film as well as being very sensitive.

I think it could be made to work. Think of "Requiem for a Dream"; they intentially picked the violins because they're traditionally the go to instrument for soft and soothing, but made the soundtrack itself discordant and disturbing to create a contrasting juxtaposition.

X-MEN.