Ugly??? You're not at all - far from it. Just objectively, I do know others (the NT variety) often just 'randomly' assign their own value-judgment without thought. Also, for them, POPULARITY is their biggest priority - they will invariably assign a popular person as Better Looking. Doesn't mean anything except their little game playing thingy. Expression may be a factor too; people often regard one who is smiling as more attractive.
I suppose attractiveness is partly objective too. I'm female, but just objectively, sans her so-called sex appeal and popularity, I've seen photos of Jennifer Anniston. She's homely at best. Yet still rated as a beauty. But if she were a nobody, and not glammed-up, she wouldn't get a second look.
Charlize Theron is very pretty, and she herself has said it's all about the presentation! She's said if she's at the local grocery with her hair in a ponytail, wearing sweats, and no make-up, no one even notices her. But once she is recognized, suddenly they're telling her she's a raving beauty.
I cannot read a facial expression. In my opinion, some men I think are handsome: George Clooney. Johnny Depp. Julio Iglesias & his son (don't laugh), The Marlboro Man (I do NOT smoke - hate it, but like his masculine look and seasoned look). I think many men of Middle Eastern descent are really good looking too. One popular actor (forgot his name) is good-looking, and he had a surgically fixed cleft palette where the scar shows above his lip. And MikeH106 - yes, you're good looking.
Bet if you told them, "I'm the most popular guy - ever. And a multi-billionaire, dated Hannah Montanna, an heir to the throne and pop star," you'd get 10s.
Forget the 6.5 rating - it's a popularity thingy. Also, plenty of NTs (yes, going to generalize here) do have jealousy. This means, if they perceive you're threatening to them, such as looks-wise, they'll bash you hard.
_________________
The ones who say “You can’t” and “You won’t” are probably the ones scared that you will. - Unknown