Oh, man. If you and I didn't see eye to eye before, you're really gonna think I'm crazy now. I'll just copy and paste what I wrote about the 1951 version in another topic:
Quote:
I know I'm in the minority, but I've never been able to stand The Thing from Another World. It's dreadfully boring even by 1950s standards, the monster is a joke (as is the whole "military good, science bad!" tone), and the "zingy" dialogue is only amusing in the sense that it's difficult to believe anyone ever actually talked like that. The remake is often dismissed as nothing but gore, as if there would be nothing left if you took it away, but it's immeasurably more effective at tension and paranoia. If you want a good 1950s sci-fi/horror film, watch The War of the Worlds instead. The Thing from Another World can't compare.
Although I really dig that scene where they set the monster on fire and keep throwing kerosene on it.
Quote:
The dialogue is one of the reasons I hated the movie. I have a hard enough time processing regular speech, but every conversation in the film sounds like this: "Where did he go I don't know well when did you see him last I'm not sure let me think it may have been in the lounge well we should go to the lounge to look for him don't you think sure you go there and I'll search the rest of the facility and..." You get the picture. But that's a subjective complaint. Objectively, I still think it's a pretty poor film. The monster would have been a joke even 15 years earlier in a Frankenstein sequel and the tone is much too lighthearted for the film to ever generate anything approaching tension. Maybe audiences were pooping their pants in 1951, but I don't buy the "it was good for its time" defense. Much better films were being made the same year, like The Day the Earth Stood Still.
Maybe I'll give it another chance soon, but I remember watching it and thinking, "
THIS is what people are raving about?"