British butlers in American movies?

Post Reply New Topic

I've seen a lot of American movies where if a family had a butler he was often a white British male with a snobby attitude and no sense of humour. I'm not saying it offends me, because it doesn't, but how come people in general don't get offended by this but get offended by something like Apu from the Simpsons? (Which doesn't offend me either).

Also I've often seen villains in American movies being British. And nobody is bothered by this? How come?

I would love to see a British set movie, where a British rich family has an American butler, that is a total "yankee".

It just seems that if there was a black butler, or a villain, in a movie of white people, it would be controversial. But if the butler or villain is British, or any other white ethnicity, nobody is bothered by it.

It's like in the Simpsons, Apu is offensive because it is stereotyping Indian people, but Groundskeeper Willie is stereotyping Scottish people and nobody is offended.

Would someone like Khan from Kind of the Hill be considered offensive? He seems more intelligent than the white characters in the show, so would be offensive therefore?

Because that trope appeals to Americans when hiring a butler so it's a reflection of something that occurs in real life.