For me it would be a dead heat between...
Patrick McGooyan (Secret Agent Man, the Prisoner)
George Harrison, of the Beatles.
Peter Noone, of Herman's Hermits
Donald Sutherland
Keifer Sutherland
Terrence Stamp (Far From the Madding Crowd)
John Cleese (Monty Python, Fawlty Towers)
John Lithgow
Nick Nolte
-------------
My criteria for choosing is this:whether or not I have been told I look like the guy.
Each one on the list is someone Ive been told I "look like" by at least one person.
So they each HAVE to be a major stud muffin!
Joking aside its a running collection I keep in my head of celebs I supposedly look like. Cant complain so far. They all are rather ...not bad looking dudes.