Sheila Nye wrote:
I ran out of time the other day.
I agree with you about echolalia to a point.
It is not only "low-functioning" [functioning labels are not okay] autistics who use echolalia.
Babies use it during the process of language development.
Some Aspie do it too.
I understand your frustration with "do you do this? do autistics do that?" threads. These threads are also valuable for people who are in the process of discovering their own autistic traits.
Actually, both echolalia and stimming ARE including in diagnosis under "repetitive behaviors" in the DSM.
I do not know anything about the ICM or other forms of classifications or diagnostic manuals.
Yes, there are "high functionung" Aspie who employ echolalia. Some use scripting in social situations. Others may engage in repetitive singing of a phrase of a song or have a word that they use when doing certain tasks.
I have my reasons for asking about this.
Thank you.
First of all, babies are not high functioning and that makes a pretty crappy argument for echolallia.
Secondly, since Aspergers got lumped up with Autism in general, yes, labels are perfectly fine. Do not delude yourself that there is no difference.
High functioning is pretty much almost indistinguishable from an NT, but with some traits that cannot be seen.
High functioning is not sitting on the floor screaming because stuff got displaced, or that they remove their clothes because the texture does not feel good, or having no understanding how to read people because they didn't spend one day in their life considering that other people - are people and tried to observe and learn human behavior to fit in more in society.
Again - do NOT delude yourself that there is no difference. I'm not saying that high functioning is "uber" people with superpowers, but i am saying that there is a difference in functionality, and that high functioning in the autism spectrum usually means stuff like: being able to live on your own, being able to hold a job, finding love, starting a family - stuff like normal people do, function in society without "training wheels" on a kids bike - that is high functioning.
It usually means Aspergers or what was called HFA.
This is the main reason why i am against throwing every diagnosis under Autism spectrum disorders in a blender and making a gray generic paste, or a "one size fits all" diagnosis.
_________________
"It is far better to grasp the Universe as it really is than to persist in delusion, however satisfying and reassuring" (Carl Sagan)