tailfins1959 wrote:
Their labor is illegal. Don't be obtuse.
Even sillier. Oh, I picked up a stick in my yard. The government did not sanction it, but its legal. Oh my boss made me pick up sticks at work, but it was not government sanctioned. Suddenly its illegal.
No. Don't be obtuse. Both of these events are
extra-legal. Not
illegal. What
is illegal is remuneration for labour, to a person without legal residency, be it a work visa, residency papers or citizenship. The illegal action is solely in the hands of the agent purchasing the labour(the employer).
Want to bet? Imagine that you have a unpapered Mexican who volunteers to clean up the grounds of the catholic church where his family attends services. Hes certainly doing labour. He has a verbal(or possibly even written) contract with the parish to
work for them. All that is missing in this deal is fiat currency remuneration. He might even be labouring for food and shelter. Happens all the time in the US. Nobody gets busted for it.
Because the law has nothing to say about it. His labour(of any sort) is extra legal. The government is unconcerned(meaning it has no laws written) pertaining to the actions of
anyone in its borders, provided that they are not criminal in nature. ie: impaired/unlicensed driving, drug use/trafficking, theft, murder, rape, and so on. This is the very basis of your freedoms. You can do whatever you want,
unless its specifically banned by law.
Still want to bet?
Say that you and I are both Americans.
Lets say I have a 1972 Stingray Corvette in mint condition.

.
You have a broken guitar.
We both agree to trade straight across.
Is the government(IRS) interested in our trade? Possibly. But they have no means of taxing barter trade. And you did not make an income. Its extra legal. On the other hand, if I had traded that stingray for your house, then there is a specific law on the books pertaining to the taxation of real estate gains. The trade would be legal, but me not paying taxes on my capital gains would be illegal.
The government(and I don't mean your local senator) does not really give a damn whether you or someone with a predilection for habañero laced micturant does the labour. They just want the exchange to be taxable.