Fnord wrote:
It was Adamantium, and I sent a PM.
I never got that PM--possibly another victim of the new and improved WP? In any case, good to see you back in action, Fnord.
cubedemon6073 wrote:
Answer: Because the saying makes no sense as one of America's maxims because it is inconsistent and contradictory internal to itself and it is contradictory to the concept that life isn't fair. If nothing in life is guaranteed is true then it can't be true that life isn't fair.
I think the "nothing in life is guaranteed" concept comes up in other ways that are complimentary to kraftie's take on this. I have heard people say "nothing in life is guaranteed" in the context of something being a sure bet.
"Nothing in life is guaranteed, but if you step off a cliff..."
The thing about verbal communication is that it is never context free. Meaning is a consensus product and though lexicographers create records of the meanings that prevail in their time,
even dictionaries are products of their context.So you can't just look within and philosophize or ruminate on what people mean by a certain phrase or expression, you have to try to understand what they mean in the context in which they expressed it.
To parse someone's language for inconsistencies or compare it to the language of others that use the same words doesn't help to understand meaning unless the entire focus is on understanding the meaning in the specific context.
For example, Neil Gaiman said:
"The current total of countries in the world with First Amendments is one. You have guaranteed freedom of speech. Other countries don't have that."
You can't find out more about what Gaiman meant by those words by contrasting them with other famous quotes like, "Freedom of the press is guaranteed only to those who own one," just because they share a couple of words.
You might be able to write an interesting essay by playing on the ideas of freedom and guarantee in both quotes, but the meaning of each one is not negated by the meaning or validity of the other.
The exchange of ideas through words is a thing that happens between people, not between words.