DW_a_mom wrote:
This is just a sweet piece intended to make certain mothers feel better about their lives and circumstances. WHY is there something wrong with that? We're not waiting for someone to do anything for us.
And, yes, I have faith. Science explains HOW, but it doesn't do a great job with WHY. The world starts to pre-natally select out babies with Downs, and so autism rates (and the severity) rises instead. Why? Oh, yes, there will be a scientific explanation of HOW it happened, but it won't explain the interesting irony in the timing. It can't. It is in these gaps that I look to faith for possible answers. Not facts; faith is not fact; just possibilities.
But I don't expect you to buy it. Just respect my right to it without demeaning my intelligence in choosing it (as those without faith so very often do).
"Why" is the wrong question. "Why" imparts an intelligence behind the observed event (a child born with a disability) and thus narrows the possible causes down to one: a supernatural being for which there is no evidence. But even IF such a being existed and were responsible, how are you able to discern its intent? Or that it has servants called "angels"? The "why" is applied solely by your own mind and turns you away from what you should really be concerned with: your child.
But you are correct in saying that faith is not fact, and that is it's flaw. Faith is believing something for no reason. It is blind and it is dangerous. Were it something else, not a mental disorder, but something like diabetes, would you still rely on faith? People that do that end up with a dead child. And I see no difference in turning to faith when your child has autism or Asperger.
As for the "gaps"... What is so wrong with "I don't know?"
Also, I fail to see where I insulted anybody's intelligence.