Fnord wrote:
ISIL is not some hyped-up non-threat, and all it takes is one or two people - maybe a couple of disgruntled Islamist extremists with an interest in explosives - and mass murders start happening in public places.
It's bad enough we have our own gun-toting nutcases shooting up schools; it would be even worse if ISIL operatives were allowed within our borders and given free access to cookware and household chemicals.
Europeans have been criticizing the USA for breeding violence. Well, they will likely have seen nothing yet. They should really lock down their borders and be VERY careful about what kind of "refugees" they let in.
The thing about ISIL is that it isn't a nationality or something, it's an ideology. We could put a mile-high wall around every border and coastline in Europe, and stop all flights, and they'd still get in. The US could do the same thing and they'd still get in. ISIL will not come to the West by walking here or getting on planes, but by radicalising disaffected young people over the internet.
In the grand scheme of things, the refugees who've run away from terrorism are nothing to worry about.
-------------------------
The main reason people are against refugees coming to the West seems to be that "we can't help everyone in this country yet". A close second is "they'll drain all our resources". The third is "they're terrorists".
I think the first point is an excuse to do nothing; propose helping the homeless, and you'll be told, "well, people have it much worse in the Middle East!". The second is something we need to guard against, but not a pressing issue. If we allow the refugees to participate in capitalism, they'll probably benefit their host countries, particularly as it tends to be the wealthier and better educated who have the resources to flee. The third is xenophobic and/or racist and/or Islamophobic nonsense - "they're brown, Muslim, and Syrian, so they're probably terrorists". So whilst I believe those are the three main justifications people give, I don't think any of them hold much merit.