The rise of right wing narrative in France.

Post Reply New Topic

Not to get off the subject, but for all the talk about the French resistance during WWII, there were in fact far more Pro-Nazi collaborators in France.

France is physically close to North Africa- right across the Mediterranean.

And France was the colonial ruler of the entire Mahgreb (Morocco, Algeria, and Tunisia). Britain gets Muslim migrants from it's former colony Pakistan, likewise France gets many from North Africa.

A French commander who had fought in the French resistance to Nazi occupation of France found himself committing the same atrocities against the people of Algeria that the Nazi had done to the French- the very same crimes that had driven him to join the resistance.

When De Gaul finally gave into the reality that France could longer hold onto Algeria and the war was lost-and finnally withdrew from Algeria- the White French colonists in Algeria felt betrayed...and hired a professional assassin to kill De Gaul. The assassin went by the codename "the Jackel", and the almost successful attempt was the subject of the book/movie "the Day of the Jackel".

So politics on one side of the Mediterranean has long effected the politics on the other side.

Again, not to derail the thread, but it had been found that the same Anti-De Gaullists in France had had a connection to the CIA-Mafia sponsored Anti-Castro underground in New Orleans that had been alleged to have been behind the Kennedy assassination. Hey, even I can get obsessed with conspiracy theories!

A lot of VIOLENT colonial history with North Africa west of Egypt.

That's strange, the Muslims we have known were just ordinary people living a ordinary life and they never tried to impose their religion on anyone and they were not terrorists. Even my cousin's wife is Muslim and so are their kids and they wear regular clothing and have an ordinary life but they are both wealthy. They also do not wear hijabs.

There isn't a "rise" of right wing narratives, as with the rest of Europe anti-immigration sentiment is always bubbling just beneath the surface. France and Austria have always had prominent far right parties.

Incidents like the Charlie Hebdo and Nice killings create a groundswell of reactionary comments from the populace who now feel emboldened to air their inner thoughts.

One of my best friends is a very secular Muslim. He’s of Indian descent from Trinidad. He is a probation officer.

Having to fill out a form to go out of your house is very right wing.

I haven't given this much thought, but my position is:
If you migrate to another country, you should embrace the values of that country and be a true citizen of the country.
My parents did.

Have you been following what, Dan Wuhan Andrews, the Victorian Premier, has done to people of that state?
Now *THAT* is fascism, and he is a leftie.

In the 1930's, there were many German Jews who saw themselves as Germans first.
It didn't save them.

Let's face it.
The human psyche is an abomination.

This is true. Europe has had much more contact with Muslims for much longer. Anti-Muslim sentiment has been stewing in Europe as long as there has been Islam. Before 2001 especially, Muslims here in America were more out-of-sight, out-of-mind.
Muslims being more prone to radicalism in Europe just seems like part of a self-fulfilling prophecy on the part of non-Muslim Europeans: Europeans look down on Muslims as dangerous and inferior -> Muslims are treated as dangerous and inferior -> Muslims live in second-class citizenship and segregation -> Muslims see their religion disrespected left and right -> radical groups prey on disaffected, desperate Muslims looking for an outlet for their frustration -> small percentage of Muslims join terror groups -> Europeans look down on Muslims as dangerous and inferior -> repeat.
Europeans and my countrymen in America often forget that integration is a two-way street. If you reject them, they are not going to find it easy to integrate--or to even want to integrate. When my ancestors came here from Ireland and were spit on as drunks and radicals that sure as sugar didn't make them want to become American if that was what Americans were like.
The Muslims I see every day are not doctors or scientists--they're working people just trying to get by. I've also known Muslims whose parents came here as professionals to live in the suburbs. I've met far more of the former. America gets fewer Muslim immigrants for the same reason Europe gets fewer Latin American immigrants: distance. They both flee violence and political turmoil and poverty, and they both get looked down on for not having more education/money/skills. If they weren't overwhelmingly Christian, Americans would blame the perceived shortcomings of Latino immigrants on their religion in the same way Europeans blame Muslims' religion. (America already puts Christians in cages, I shudder to think what they would do if they were Muslim).
Of course there are radicals who get cherry-picked by right-wing or even mainstream media to fulfil their audiences' pre-conceived notions of what Muslims are like. American news does the same thing. Fearmongering is great for ratings, and islamophobia is still fashionable. Muslims are overwhelmingly ordinary people who just want dignity and respect. And yes I keep up with European news--I'm not another Yankee who doesn't know how to pull his head of the sand. I get sick of consuming just American news sources. I read from the BBC, and if I want a continental perspective I read the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, the Süddeutsche Zeitung, and the Tageszeitung. If I spoke French, I would read French sources too.

Christians here in America have spent the last 400 years imposing their will on non-Christians through the legal system, but that gets plenty of attention. Atheists don't do it here as much as they do in Europe bc atheism is just less accepted here. But there are still the pointless anti-religious policies in the name of secularism, like forbidding public workers from wearing jewelry/clothing with religious symbols on them. It's a solution in search of a problem that just adds to the fundamentalist Christians' victim complex.

So you disagreed previously about an issue that you just happened to change your mind on?

You can't be tolerant of intolerance for your own country.

In which ways (besides perhaps LGBT-related issues) have Christians "imposed" their will on non-Christians in America?

When in Rome...

I have seen that cultural tolerance might be taken too far when trying to accommodate religious/cultural practice such as prayers in public spaces, no go areas for women in public spaces and building permits for structures that don't fit into the community of the area (mosques).

The fuzzy lines are getting more blurry.