Who was the true enemy of WW2? Hitler or Stalin ?

Post Reply New Topic

From who's perspective? I mean, from a certain perspective one could insist the Jewish people and left-wingers were the enemy during WWII.

Both were amateurs.

- Mao Zedong

Himmler was the architect of "The Final Solution".
Shouldn't he be given a dishonourable mention?

Hitler including the Axis, and Imperial Japan were the true enemies of WWII.

Stalin was an enemy to those subjugated by the Soviet Union. I would include Russians as Stalin was not himself a Russian. I don't know how most people in today's Russia view Stalin but I have the impression that in Georgia many still revere him as a national hero. He died in 1953 so anything that took place later wasn't his direct responsibility. I believe that most deaths we can attribute to him directly took place before WWII, were politically motivated and were not (as another poster mentioned) a case of exterminating people specifically because of their ethnic ancestry, although it may have worked out that way at times. He was killing people he believed to be enemies. Trump would probably do the same under similar circumstances. Stalin wasn't that different from other world "leaders" in that regard, he simply managed to achieve a much higher body count than anybody else.

The situation becomes much more nuanced when you consider what actually happened in WWII. Even Western Europeans who survived WWII have no real idea how dreadfully people in the Soviet Union suffered during Hitler's invasion, and I would suggest that modern-day Russia's failure to appear as a full partner to other world democracies such as they are, is largely due to a sense on their part that the superpowers simply don't give a toss about this history, meaning that Russia has been and always will be on its own. That and a sense that they had market capitalism shoved down their throats after the fall of the Soviet Union, but as this has little to do with Stalin I'll end my argument there.