Right Wing fascism in the US

Post Reply New Topic

I wonder if maybe deep down "fascism" has always been a core part of America's system? Given our long history of slavery and genocide, not to mention locking certain families up in prison camps like the Japanese during WW2 or the Hispanics trying to cross our border in recent years.

Or perhaps we're just an apartheid state like what South Africa had?

The basis of the US is not fascistic. It was, as the Founding Fathers themselves stated, an “experiment.” They were treading new ground in the late 18th century. They were seeking to expand republicanism beyond what occurred in city-sized places like Athens, Florence, and Venice.

It is unfortunate that we had to BS and murder the Native Americans in order to realize our “Manifest Destiny.”

It is unfortunate that slavery was the basis of a considerable portion of the agrarian economy even amid the “experiment.” It certainly besmirched the purity of the “experiment.”

It is a miracle that this “experiment” has succeeded, by and large, even amid many forces which sought to undo this “experiment.”

Russia doesn’t have that basis. Their basis is monarchism and autocracy. The “experimental” phase started with Gorbachev—but this “experiment” was easily overturned by Putin.

A person like Trump probably would have succeeded better in places which do not have as strong a BASIS as the American Experiment.

I can't remember who said it but it was somewhere in the Interbellum period when fascism was a positively fashionable trend - some Polish politician said that fascism was impossible in Poland because Poles were not disciplined enough.
Hopefully, it's true about Americans, too.

But it would have been healthy to review each nation's own past attrocities. To understand what happened, how it impacts the present and how not to let it happen again.

We have to stop conceding that history will, inevitably, “repeat itself.”

The history never literally repeats itself - yet some patterns often emerge again and again.

What you stated is the preferred interpretation of those who make use of the phrase.

The notions of “patterns” repeating themselves.

I wish more people would undertake a concerted, objective study of the inevitable results of repression.

One only has to read accounts of people in Russian prison camps, going back at least to Dostoyevsky’s “Notes from Underground,” to discern what is meant by Russian repression.

“Darkness at Noon” is the account of a political prisoner during the Stalinist “purges,” which followed the Holodomor.

We almost became one on 1/6/2021.

There are indeed many unpleasant ideologies, even far-right ideologies, that are not fascism.

The US certain was an apartheid state for most of its existence, but it isn’t now. It hasn’t fully recovered, for sure, the effects still linger, but race doesn’t determine where you can live or work or use the toilet anymore.

There are fascists active in the US. Elements of the Republican Party support them, and larger elements would not resist them (the same is true of the Democrats and various leftist revolutionaries, but for various reasons American leftists are not as prone to political violence). The fascists mostly see Trumpism as a useful stepping-stone, but some do not - they particularly view Trump as “weak on race”. As a voting bloc, they are less relevant than Evangelicals across the nation, but probably more relevant in some key areas with lower religiosity, like the Mountain West.