Atheism - Joseph Stalin’s Godless 5-year plan of 1928

Page 2 of 6 [ 88 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6  Next

naturalplastic
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 26 Aug 2010
Age: 70
Gender: Male
Posts: 35,189
Location: temperate zone

28 Oct 2023, 5:32 am

blitzkrieg wrote:
naturalplastic wrote:
The original post is pure BS.

Stalin was a Marxist, and it was Marx who wrote that "religion is the opiate of the masses". Basically a tool to help keep the working classes down. That statement is open to interpretation but its usually interpreted to mean religion is the enemy of the working class rising up. So nonreligion was already a tenet of Marxism in the 19th Century. And the revolutionaries who put Marxism on the map in the early 20th century were not friendly to religion. Including Lenin and Stalin. So even within Marxism Stalin did not "invent" atheism.

And Marx didnt invent Atheism either. It existed forever before that.

And the most famous anti Marxist (and contemporary of Stalin) was Ayn Rand, who was also an atheist.

Christianity today is a lot stronger in the former Communist nations of Eastern Europe (which were ruled by Stalin) than in western Europe which was always free of Communist dictators.


Where in my OP did I say that Stalin invented atheism? I merely mentioned the incidence of official, state atheism, which in the extremity of the case of the Soviet Union circa 1928, was a relatively novel occurrence.

I did not focus on Marxism in the OP, nor did I say anything against it, and you seem to be arguing against a strawman.

I never mentioned today - I am aware that in today's Russia even, Christianity has made somewhat of a comeback versus the militant atheism of the 1920's in Russia.

You clearly implied that Stalin invented atheism in 1928.

I KNOW that you never mentioned Marxism. That was my point. You implied that atheism was Stalin's own idea when in fact atheism is part of Marxist ideology. If you talk about the topic you have to provide that as context.

If you were not saying that Stalin some how created atheism then...WTF ...IS your point?



TwilightPrincess
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 28 Sep 2016
Age: 41
Gender: Female
Posts: 32,810
Location: Hell

28 Oct 2023, 8:23 am

Quote:
The only problem with atheism and humanly constructed morals, some might argue, is that morals are changeable and can be overridden by anyone who takes a fancy to bending morals to their own will.
In the Soviet Union, as a means to an end of achieving a socialist, Godless utopia, Joseph Stalin killed many people.

Check out God’s supposed morals in this thread.

He’s apparently changeable AND killed many people if one takes the Bible as the true word of God.

His lack of intervention is concerning from a moral standpoint as well, going with the assumption that he exists for argument’s sake.



blitzkrieg
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 8 Jun 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Male
Posts: 21,499

28 Oct 2023, 9:08 am

naturalplastic wrote:
blitzkrieg wrote:
naturalplastic wrote:
The original post is pure BS.

Stalin was a Marxist, and it was Marx who wrote that "religion is the opiate of the masses". Basically a tool to help keep the working classes down. That statement is open to interpretation but its usually interpreted to mean religion is the enemy of the working class rising up. So nonreligion was already a tenet of Marxism in the 19th Century. And the revolutionaries who put Marxism on the map in the early 20th century were not friendly to religion. Including Lenin and Stalin. So even within Marxism Stalin did not "invent" atheism.

And Marx didnt invent Atheism either. It existed forever before that.

And the most famous anti Marxist (and contemporary of Stalin) was Ayn Rand, who was also an atheist.

Christianity today is a lot stronger in the former Communist nations of Eastern Europe (which were ruled by Stalin) than in western Europe which was always free of Communist dictators.


Where in my OP did I say that Stalin invented atheism? I merely mentioned the incidence of official, state atheism, which in the extremity of the case of the Soviet Union circa 1928, was a relatively novel occurrence.

I did not focus on Marxism in the OP, nor did I say anything against it, and you seem to be arguing against a strawman.

I never mentioned today - I am aware that in today's Russia even, Christianity has made somewhat of a comeback versus the militant atheism of the 1920's in Russia.

You clearly implied that Stalin invented atheism in 1928.

I KNOW that you never mentioned Marxism. That was my point. You implied that atheism was Stalin's own idea when in fact atheism is part of Marxist ideology. If you talk about the topic you have to provide that as context.

If you were not saying that Stalin some how created atheism then...WTF ...IS your point?


I didn't mean to imply at all that Stalin invented atheism. I find it insulting that you would think that I thought that.

The context was provided by the links I provided.

My post was largely based on the content of the provided link from the history.com article, with a few of my own comments mixed in to the summary of the content.

In my mind, the text gave a good example of how atheism can be a negative force in society. That was the point, if anything.



blitzkrieg
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 8 Jun 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Male
Posts: 21,499

28 Oct 2023, 9:12 am

^ I'll add to the above post - I wrote in the OP:

"the seeds of official, state atheism were being sown long before the decline of Christianity in the western world, way back in the early 20th century – in the Soviet Union."

That comment clearly describes "official, state atheism", and not atheism in general or in and of itself.

Also, the decline of Christianity and the successful rise of mass secularism in Europe is a relatively new phenomenon, hence my mention of the decline of Christianity.



The_Walrus
Forum Moderator
Forum Moderator

User avatar

Joined: 27 Jan 2010
Age: 30
Gender: Male
Posts: 8,878
Location: London

28 Oct 2023, 9:40 am

I think you can see how:

blitzkrieg wrote:
Whilst some modern atheists in the United States of America might think they are cool or edgy or somehow newly enlightened with their atheism, the seeds of official, state atheism were being sown long before the decline of Christianity in the western world, way back in the early 20th century – in the Soviet Union.

could reasonably be read as attempting to imply that the atheism practiced today has its roots in Stalinism. It's a bizarre comparison because the US does not have state atheism - there is constitutional separation of church and state.

Also a bit silly to suggest that atheists tend to think their beliefs are cool or edgy. In my experience, it isn't atheists trying to make themselves seem like oppressed plucky underdogs telling unpopular truths. Most atheists are simply motivated by the lack of a rational reason to believe in gods.



babybird
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 11 Nov 2011
Gender: Female
Posts: 88,948
Location: UK

28 Oct 2023, 9:45 am

It's funny that on social media platforms such as X it seems like every second person is promoting atheism as if it's some new thing.

But the good thing about them is that they're all usually pro choice. But the irritating thing is that some of the women come off as being militant feminists.

I find that a bit of a turn off personally.


_________________
We have existence


TwilightPrincess
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 28 Sep 2016
Age: 41
Gender: Female
Posts: 32,810
Location: Hell

28 Oct 2023, 10:34 am

I think that a lot of women have experienced extensive sexism from religion, especially Abrahamic religion. There are many problematic scriptures as far as women are concerned in both the Bible and Qur’an which leads to a lot of issues in various Jewish, Christian, and Islamic sects. Perhaps people who are the most outspoken have experienced a significant amount of religious misogyny. Just a thought.



Tim_Tex
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 2 Jul 2004
Age: 45
Gender: Male
Posts: 46,400
Location: Houston, Texas

28 Oct 2023, 11:02 am

Even though most of the communist states practiced state-sanctioned atheism (which blitzkrieg is referring to), Albania, under Enver Hoxha, was the only one to have banned religion completely.


_________________
Who’s better at math than a robot? They’re made of math!


naturalplastic
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 26 Aug 2010
Age: 70
Gender: Male
Posts: 35,189
Location: temperate zone

28 Oct 2023, 11:15 am

I guess that in real life its the religious that come at you to proselytize. Knocking on your door.

But online its the atheists who are the...Evangelicals...out to bring you the "good news". :D



babybird
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 11 Nov 2011
Gender: Female
Posts: 88,948
Location: UK

28 Oct 2023, 11:46 am

I'm always quite polite to the jw folk when they knock on my door. I'm not into all that personally but I appreciate that for them it's a job. So I take their pamphlets, look at the pictures and then bin them.

I don't hate religious people or even religion. Its just not my thing.

I wouldn't even consider myself as an atheist because it's just another thing to believe in.

I suppose I just don't care about it all really. It holds nothing for me.


_________________
We have existence


blitzkrieg
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 8 Jun 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Male
Posts: 21,499

28 Oct 2023, 12:31 pm

The_Walrus wrote:
I think you can see how:
blitzkrieg wrote:
Whilst some modern atheists in the United States of America might think they are cool or edgy or somehow newly enlightened with their atheism, the seeds of official, state atheism were being sown long before the decline of Christianity in the western world, way back in the early 20th century – in the Soviet Union.

could reasonably be read as attempting to imply that the atheism practiced today has its roots in Stalinism. It's a bizarre comparison because the US does not have state atheism - there is constitutional separation of church and state.

Also a bit silly to suggest that atheists tend to think their beliefs are cool or edgy. In my experience, it isn't atheists trying to make themselves seem like oppressed plucky underdogs telling unpopular truths. Most atheists are simply motivated by the lack of a rational reason to believe in gods.


The intention of that part of my post and the thinking behind it, was to highlight the type of folk (in my mind) in the United States that seem to live in a vacuum of sorts and who think that atheism is something new, precisely because of the lack of experience of the world that a lot of people in the U.S.A have - i.e, it's a common trope for citizens of the U.S.A never to have travelled outside of the U.S.A or to Europe. I am not saying this applies to every last person in the U.S.A - obviously it does not.

In short, I was criticizing the ignorance of the Americans of the U.S.A & demonstrating an instance of why atheism is not new and why that would be the wrong to think that - precisely the opposite of what you & naturalplastic seemed to assume that I meant.

I suppose if two people thought the same thing then that may indicate a problem with the communication of the intention of my post. But I can assure you I do not think, and have never thought, that modern day atheism either originated from Stalin's Russia or is practiced today as an extension of that.

I wasn't claiming the U.S. has state atheism either. I was comparing general, cultural atheism (today) in the United States there with the state atheism of a different country almost a century ago. I apologize if that was unclear.



blitzkrieg
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 8 Jun 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Male
Posts: 21,499

28 Oct 2023, 12:37 pm

babybird wrote:
It's funny that on social media platforms such as X it seems like every second person is promoting atheism as if it's some new thing.

But the good thing about them is that they're all usually pro choice. But the irritating thing is that some of the women come off as being militant feminists.

I find that a bit of a turn off personally.


That is the type of person I was alluding to in my initial post. It is apparent on social media that there are a lot of people who seem to think atheism is some new thing, when it is clearly not.

I find militant feminists to be a turn off too, babybird. I am glad you agree! :mrgreen:



blitzkrieg
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 8 Jun 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Male
Posts: 21,499

28 Oct 2023, 12:38 pm

TwilightPrincess wrote:
I think that a lot of women have experienced extensive sexism from religion, especially Abrahamic religion. There are many problematic scriptures as far as women are concerned in both the Bible and Qur’an which leads to a lot of issues in various Jewish, Christian, and Islamic sects. Perhaps people who are the most outspoken have experienced a significant amount of religious misogyny. Just a thought.


Or they could just be trigger happy, young & ignorant folk on social media.

I am sure there are some jaded folk as you describe, however.



blitzkrieg
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 8 Jun 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Male
Posts: 21,499

28 Oct 2023, 12:39 pm

Tim_Tex wrote:
Even though most of the communist states practiced state-sanctioned atheism (which blitzkrieg is referring to), Albania, under Enver Hoxha, was the only one to have banned religion completely.


That's an interesting tidbit of information, Tim_Tex.



blitzkrieg
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 8 Jun 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Male
Posts: 21,499

28 Oct 2023, 12:40 pm

naturalplastic wrote:
I guess that in real life its the religious that come at you to proselytize. Knocking on your door.

But online its the atheists who are the...Evangelicals...out to bring you the "good news". :D


I totally agree with this.

Religious people seem to not be particularly outspoken online nowadays whereas atheists seem to be enthusiastic about their perceived, personal enlightenment or rationality as they may believe.



blitzkrieg
Veteran
Veteran

User avatar

Joined: 8 Jun 2011
Age: 36
Gender: Male
Posts: 21,499

28 Oct 2023, 12:41 pm

babybird wrote:
I'm always quite polite to the jw folk when they knock on my door. I'm not into all that personally but I appreciate that for them it's a job. So I take their pamphlets, look at the pictures and then bin them.

I don't hate religious people or even religion. Its just not my thing.

I wouldn't even consider myself as an atheist because it's just another thing to believe in.

I suppose I just don't care about it all really. It holds nothing for me.


This is a perfectly reasonable thought process, babybird.