Of what real value is evolutionary "knowledge"?
iamnotaparakeet
Veteran
Joined: 31 Jul 2007
Age: 40
Gender: Male
Posts: 25,091
Location: 0.5 Galactic radius
what nonsense. Evolution is a framework that allows for the better understanding of biological process and leads to a more complete knowledge of the gestalt forces surrounding biological processes and what gives rise to speciation events, it allows biologists to understand the mechanisms at play when looking at any number of things. To the results of an opposable thumb to the reason white moths die out in smoggy cities but gray one's flourish.
Evolution is an aspect of knowledge. Once acquired we move on to discover the next truth about reality. We don't discard it because religious people get offended. We used to do that... that's why they were called the Dark Ages.
Can you blame science for being misotheistic? Even when looking at conventional biology (as opposed to physics and astronomy), scientists got into trouble with the Church (da Vinci comes to mind).
In any case, biology would not make sense, unless God has an extremely perverse sense of humour. While that would explain a few things, I am yet to receive his RSVP for my invitation to join the club comedy circuit.
Evolution is not perfect, nor does it claim to be. God, according to all accounts, is. And yet, we are imperfect beings, full of defects. You try to tell me that is divine will, and I will defenestrate you. Through plate glass.
_________________
(No longer a mod)
On sabbatical...
Ragtime, I suggest you read the journal Evolutionary Applications. I promise it is a more reliable source of information than the one you gave me. You still haven't told me what you were thinking of when telling me I could learn something about evolution from that site, with arguments so poor that they only serve to make opponents of evolution look like complete idiots.
I keep hearing that evolution is opposed to God, but haven't yet seen any evidence for it. Can you provide that evidence?
Will you stop with this nonsense? Not all evolutionists are atheists! MOST Christians are evolutionists! Its only a handful of fringe lunatics like yourself that believe evolution is incompatible with religion.
_________________
WAR IS PEACE
FREEDOM IS SLAVERY
IGNORANCE IS STRENGTH
Will you stop with this nonsense? Not all evolutionists are atheists! MOST Christians are evolutionists! Its only a handful of fringe lunatics like yourself that believe evolution is incompatible with religion.
In the deluded minds of those fringe lunatics scientific, naturalistic explanations of the world are nothing but the "religion" of "nihilistic godless secular humanism." They see science as part of a non-existant "atheist ideology."
Will you stop with this nonsense? Not all evolutionists are atheists! MOST Christians are evolutionists! Its only a handful of fringe lunatics like yourself that believe evolution is incompatible with religion.
There is far, far, FAR more evidence for God than there is for evolution. Therefore, I definitely believe in God, but evolution is still very shaky at best.
If evolution is an elective, and it's not required for the successful pursuit of biological study, THEN WHY ALL THE PRESSURE TO UNEQUIVOCALLY TEACH EVOLUTION IN THE SCHOOLS, ALLOWING NO QUESTIONING OF IT WHATSOEVER, AND OUTLAWING ID?
If it's so unimportant to the pursuit of hard science, why is it DEMANDED that the teacher allow room for no other possibility than evolution? It hasn't been proven, so it's basically a fairytale that's drilled into students' heads as fact, by biased leaders who personally dislike God.
Evolution is like a Greek Mythology class where you're told that the mythology is actually true, that Apollo and Athena are real, etc.
If you believe in evolution, for which there is no conclusive evidence, then you should easily believe in God, for whom there is evidence ALL AROUND YOU!
Last edited by Ragtime on 10 May 2008, 10:23 am, edited 1 time in total.
You keep saying that, but when asked to back that up all you had to offer was a link to a web site with arguments ranging from poor to ridiculous. So let's approach this another way. What would you accept as evidence for evolution? Or even proof? Is there anything that could persuade you?
You keep saying that, but when asked to back that up
Uh, how can one back up proof of a negative? I can't show you non-proof.
There is nothing that could persuade me, it is safe to say. I mean, I've heard all the best arguments for years and years -- and they're utter CRAP!
"Nothing in biology makes sense except in the light of evolution." - The title of an essay by Theodosius Dobzhansky
It's pretty much the string that ties it all together. It's the foundation of epidemiology (viruses and bacteria evolve all the time), zoology, paleontology, and pretty much everything else in biology.
(By the way, Dobzhansky was also a Christian and "Nothing in Biology..." is about reconciling evolution with Christianity, and Darwin was a Christian for most of his life but lost his faith after his daughter died, not after publishing On The Origin of Species.)
_________________
I don't post here anymore. If you want to talk to me, go to the WP Facebook group or my Last.fm account.
Will you stop with this nonsense? Not all evolutionists are atheists! MOST Christians are evolutionists! Its only a handful of fringe lunatics like yourself that believe evolution is incompatible with religion.
There is far, far, FAR more evidence for God than there is for evolution. Therefore, I definitely believe in God, but evolution is still very shaky at best.
There's a ton of evidence for evolution.
1. Because it IS required for the successful pursuit of biological study, as has already been explained in this thread.
2. You can question anything, as long as you bring relevant facts to the table. Creationists don't.
3. ID is not taught because it is a load of bull with no scientific basis, and only very shaky theological basis.
Evolution is like a Greek Mythology class where you're told that the mythology is actually true, that Apollo and Athena are real, etc.
1. Why is it demanded that the teacher allow room for no other possibility than Newtonian mechanics? Why not also teach Aristotelian physics?
2. Personally hate God? You are an idiot and a bigot. MOST CHRISTIANS ACCEPT EVOLUTION YOU DOLT!! My biology teacher is Christian! So am I!
_________________
WAR IS PEACE
FREEDOM IS SLAVERY
IGNORANCE IS STRENGTH
Last edited by Orwell on 10 May 2008, 10:42 am, edited 1 time in total.
There is nothing that could persuade me, it is safe to say. I mean, I've heard all the best arguments for years and years -- and they're utter CRAP!

You admit at least that you will not be bound to reality by saying that nothing could persuade you to change your views. Even Luther, while starting the Reformation, allowed for the possibility of changing his views if he were shown to be wrong. And you evidently haven't heard very many arguments for evolution, if you believe they are all crap. I've heard all the arguments for Creationism, and those are among the most poorly-constructed arguments I've ever seen in my life. Seriously, it's about as easy to construct a good argument for geocentrism as for creationism.
_________________
WAR IS PEACE
FREEDOM IS SLAVERY
IGNORANCE IS STRENGTH
You keep saying that, but when asked to back that up
Uh, how can one back up proof of a negative? I can't show you non-proof.
Isn't that normally the argument employed by atheists? And even that statement betrays a serious misunderstanding of the issue. Evolution is a scientific concept. If you can find evidence that contradicts evolution, or propose an alternate theory that does a better job of explaining the data, then you could refute evolution. However, there is not currently any evidence available that contradicts the basic ideas of evolution, and no alternate theory does a more effective job of explaining the evidence we do have.
_________________
WAR IS PEACE
FREEDOM IS SLAVERY
IGNORANCE IS STRENGTH
Sedaka
Veteran
Joined: 16 Jul 2006
Age: 44
Gender: Female
Posts: 4,597
Location: In the recesses of my mind
well get right on winning your nobel prize with coming up with an alternative SCIENTIFIC THEORY that explains how everything came to be.
_________________
Neuroscience PhD student
got free science papers?
www.pubmed.gov
www.sciencedirect.com
http://highwire.stanford.edu/lists/freeart.dtl
Sedaka
Veteran
Joined: 16 Jul 2006
Age: 44
Gender: Female
Posts: 4,597
Location: In the recesses of my mind
Will you stop with this nonsense? Not all evolutionists are atheists! MOST Christians are evolutionists! Its only a handful of fringe lunatics like yourself that believe evolution is incompatible with religion.
There is far, far, FAR more evidence for God than there is for evolution. Therefore, I definitely believe in God, but evolution is still very shaky at best.
If evolution is an elective, and it's not required for the successful pursuit of biological study, THEN WHY ALL THE PRESSURE TO UNEQUIVOCALLY TEACH EVOLUTION IN THE SCHOOLS, ALLOWING NO QUESTIONING OF IT WHATSOEVER, AND OUTLAWING ID?
If it's so unimportant to the pursuit of hard science, why is it DEMANDED that the teacher allow room for no other possibility than evolution? It hasn't been proven, so it's basically a fairytale that's drilled into students' heads as fact, by biased leaders who personally dislike God.
Evolution is like a Greek Mythology class where you're told that the mythology is actually true, that Apollo and Athena are real, etc.
If you believe in evolution, for which there is no conclusive evidence, then you should easily believe in God, for whom there is evidence ALL AROUND YOU!
WHY HAVE ALL THESE TYPES OF RELIGIONS IF ALL YOU NEED IS BELIEF IN GOD?
SHOW ME THIS INCONCLUSIVE EVIDENCE>>> MAYBE I SPLAIN IT BETTER TO YOU
<3
_________________
Neuroscience PhD student
got free science papers?
www.pubmed.gov
www.sciencedirect.com
http://highwire.stanford.edu/lists/freeart.dtl
