slowmutant wrote:
ouinon wrote:
monty wrote:
Interesting.
You are right, that is very interesting, because by making it illegal for children under 12 to work in factories the govt actually took away a right from children, a right that they had had from time immemorial, which was to work. And by doing so made having children a far less worthwhile/more expensive investment, as you pointed out.
Child-labour is not a good thing. It is even more barbaric than denying women their basic human rights. Victimizing children is always the lowest.
That is what is so interesting about "morals", that when circumstances require a certain response from humans morals/rules arise which seem like absolutes.
In fact there is nothing fundamentally
wrong with children working. The children working in countries where it is still legal are many/most of them happy to do so, glad to be active contributors to the economy and wellbeing of their family and community. Children like to do what the adults around them do, are in fact programmed to copy what the adults in their community do.
If you have seen a boy running errands for his father's business, a child serving in their parents shop, a boy out on the hillside guarding the goats, a girl feeding her family's hens, or caring for her younger brothers and sisters, then you know that there is nothing intrinsically wrong about "child-labour". The number of children who are exploited/abused/overworked is no more than the number of adults.
But it becomes "wrong" in a society which needs/apparently needs to reduce its fertility rate, because so long as children have the right to work, if they are capable of it, like most other humans, they are too valuable a resource, and people will continue to have lots of them.
When the population was steady child-labour was completely normal, but in a society creating food and wealth and sanitation at such a rate that the population soars, "child-labour" becomes something taboo/scandalous, in the same way as a lone/"loose" woman was a taboo when the population was small(er) and the tribe/society was aiming at increasing its numbers, ( being fruitful and multiplying ).
.
You seem to be fanatically devoted to your cause. Don't do that. Don't lose perspective.