why such huge veneration of science?
Did you not experience any benefits at all during that period when you had little emotion?
On this particular experience, anhedonia is often associated with depression, but almost has a life of its own. I had it for a long while, with and without depression. I still get it occasionally, and on some level it's almost always with me now.
For those who don't know, anhedonia is the inability to get joy from things, even from the things you would ordinarily love (hobbies, family, beauty, sex, comedy, a good read, music, thinking.. whatever). According to what I've read, it's usually an indicator of depression, but I've noticed it at times when I wouldn't call myself depressed.
Sorry if that's OT, but as for the science of psychology, sometimes it helps to discover that what you're experiencing has a name and reading about it makes some sense of the experience. I think that's a big part of why any science is good - it helps us make sense of our world.
When I quit coffee, I got some temporary anhedonia but without depression. When it wore off, I regained my desire to look stuff up and found out that decreased dopamine will give you anhedonia. Quitting coffee gave me temporarily decreased dopamine (until my brain re-regulated). Perhaps anhedonia that isn't coupled with depression (always) and comes and goes might be from some sort of dopamine disregulation.
There's this:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3181880/
I experienced anhedonia (for about 2 months) after quitting caffeine because my brain had rejiggered itself to need caffeine to give me sufficient dopamine to get excited about things. So I wasn't depressed but also not thrilled by stuff. Does coffee ever help when that (lack of) feeling hits?
As i said before, I also think about the distinction between emotion and emotional attachment.
This makes me think of how I once listened to a symphonic track while under the influence of cannabis and it was probably the richest music experience I've had. The second time I tried it didn't feel the same way. I guess that might be emotion. I quit using cannabis later so I haven't had a chance to try again. I have been looking for ways to achieve that increased appreciation or depth of perception of music without using drugs. I found this today in a customer review when checking out a book:
That was this book. They recommended this book to begin with so I ordered a copy of that. I have been looking into this kind of thing before in the mix of all kinds of things that I've been researching over the last year and a half. I think I also might have had a kundalini awakening one time.
Science ain't getting no handle in the slightest.
Emotions are no more than neurochemical variables really in line with mechanistic thinking.
Not all the variables are known and that is why medical science is only really in tune with some of humanity.
Did you not experience any benefits at all during that period when you had little emotion?
On this particular experience, anhedonia is often associated with depression, but almost has a life of its own. I had it for a long while, with and without depression. I still get it occasionally, and on some level it's almost always with me now.
For those who don't know, anhedonia is the inability to get joy from things, even from the things you would ordinarily love (hobbies, family, beauty, sex, comedy, a good read, music, thinking.. whatever). According to what I've read, it's usually an indicator of depression, but I've noticed it at times when I wouldn't call myself depressed.
Sorry if that's OT, but as for the science of psychology, sometimes it helps to discover that what you're experiencing has a name and reading about it makes some sense of the experience. I think that's a big part of why any science is good - it helps us make sense of our world.
When I quit coffee, I got some temporary anhedonia but without depression. When it wore off, I regained my desire to look stuff up and found out that decreased dopamine will give you anhedonia. Quitting coffee gave me temporarily decreased dopamine (until my brain re-regulated). Perhaps anhedonia that isn't coupled with depression (always) and comes and goes might be from some sort of dopamine disregulation.
There's this:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3181880/
I experienced anhedonia (for about 2 months) after quitting caffeine because my brain had rejiggered itself to need caffeine to give me sufficient dopamine to get excited about things. So I wasn't depressed but also not thrilled by stuff. Does coffee ever help when that (lack of) feeling hits?
Yes, it can be related to dopamine issues, and anything that stimulates the CNS, including coffee, can be a potential short term fix but for me ABSOLUTELY NOTHING WORKED, AND THE ATTENDING psychiatrist was even wanting to put a stimulating device in my chest to stimulate my vagal nerve, so I could feel something, anything, of emotions.
HE SAID I was his worst case ever, and he was an experienced Air Force Psychiatrist, with some of the worse cases of PTSD, combat fatigue, and Anhedonia, under his clinical belt.
And chronic NEGATIVE stress will kill human beings, PER ALL bodily systems, as science now shows, including obviously, the ability to feel any emotion at all.
If nothing else, physical movement burns off the stress related hormones that when not burned off ARE left in the blood stream, as a result of A CHRONIC state of HUMAN 'fight or flight MODE', so yeah, exercise can and will save lives per ultimate human effect and AFFECT of KILLING STRESS.
AND AGAIN, truly that should COME AS basic human common sense but NO, for many folks it is not, as they have little mind and body balance, per potential human physical intelligence that is ALL MAMMALS greatest of POTENTIAL intelligences for survival AND BASICALLY A GOOD LIFE PER BASIC ANIMAL HOMEOSTASIS THAT MOST HEALTHY MIND AND BODY BALANCED MAMMALS ENJOY A MAJOR PORTION OF their life.
HUMANS ARE A NOTABLE EXCEPTION TO THIS RULE, SADLY ENOugH, as a direct result of the negative driving force of cultural illusions, particularly the one that 'says' sit still most of the day.
_________________
KATiE MiA FredericK!iI
Gravatar is one of the coolest things ever!! !
http://en.gravatar.com/katiemiafrederick
This makes me think of how I once listened to a symphonic track while under the influence of cannabis and it was probably the richest music experience I've had. The second time I tried it didn't feel the same way. I guess that might be emotion. I quit using cannabis later so I haven't had a chance to try again. I have been looking for ways to achieve that increased appreciation or depth of perception of music without using drugs. I found this today in a customer review when checking out a book:
That was this book. They recommended this book to begin with so I ordered a copy of that. I have been looking into this kind of thing before in the mix of all kinds of things that I've been researching over the last year and a half. I think I also might have had a kundalini awakening one time.
NOOOOOOOOOO
Not Mantak Chia
Read his books couple of decades ago, the microcosmic orbit iirc. Seriously, there is better.
Then you might as well delve into Taoism proper after which you can decide whether you still want to spend money on Mantak Chia books...
Science ain't getting no handle in the slightest.
Emotions are no more than neurochemical variables really in line with mechanistic thinking.
Not all the variables are known and that is why medical science is only really in tune with some of humanity.
Actually science is making some progress, and one can start with a book called the 'Body Keeps Score', easily found by a Google search, if one desires to learn more.
_________________
KATiE MiA FredericK!iI
Gravatar is one of the coolest things ever!! !
http://en.gravatar.com/katiemiafrederick
NOOOOOOOOOO
Not Mantak Chia
Read his books couple of decades ago, the microcosmic orbit iirc. Seriously, there is better.
Then you might as well delve into Taoism proper after which you can decide whether you still want to spend money on Mantak Chia books...
What is better then? I have one book on Qigong but I wasn't impressed by the book.
This makes me think of how I once listened to a symphonic track while under the influence of cannabis and it was probably the richest music experience I've had. The second time I tried it didn't feel the same way. I guess that might be emotion. I quit using cannabis later so I haven't had a chance to try again. I have been looking for ways to achieve that increased appreciation or depth of perception of music without using drugs. I found this today in a customer review when checking out a book:
That was this book. They recommended this book to begin with so I ordered a copy of that. I have been looking into this kind of thing before in the mix of all kinds of things that I've been researching over the last year and a half. I think I also might have had a kundalini awakening one time.
Well, if you haven't tried it, you might start free style dance in moving your body freely in three-dimensional space, as science is now starting to show this both increases the ability to feel emotion, as well as the potential to regulate emotion along with sensory integration.
There is ABSOLUTELY ZERO DOUBT that it works for me every now of every now.
If I stayed on this frigging computer all the time, I would lose my emotions again.
And with that said, I am leaving now to do martial arts and ballet like dance along with extreme strength training to build my emotional intelligence and sensory integration even STRONGER.
THE BOTTOM LINE IS, it works for me, and millions of others, as shown through the history of humankind by written individual reports aka anecdotal evidence.
To wait for science, is truly insanity for me.
I go my own way, and illustrate the amazing results on my own way.
_________________
KATiE MiA FredericK!iI
Gravatar is one of the coolest things ever!! !
http://en.gravatar.com/katiemiafrederick
The dopamine/serotonin thing is part of what some anti-depressants are supposed to help with, but they don't really do more than level me out.
As for the coffee thing... I'm no good without a morning coffee.. lol.
But I think you're onto something there.
_________________
I'm not blind to your facial expression - but it may take me a few minutes to comprehend it.
A smile is not always a smile.
A frown is not always a frown.
And a blank look rarely means a blank mind.
Science ain't getting no handle in the slightest.
Emotions are no more than neurochemical variables really in line with mechanistic thinking.
Not all the variables are known and that is why medical science is only really in tune with some of humanity.
Actually science is making some progress, and one can start with a book called the 'Body Keeps Score', easily found by a Google search, if one desires to learn more.
The Body Remembers
I got my own story that started in 1968. Beyond the scope of this topic really. But i only stopped asking questions some 5 years ago. Only diagnosis they can be sure on with me is early childhood traumatisation and for the rest I have actually managed to get kicked out of the funny farm at one point in my life without being permanently labelled
The body remembers. Attachment is a biological process that has it's base in the limbic system I know. I don't actually, but my body does.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limbic_resonance
NOOOOOOOOOO
Not Mantak Chia
Read his books couple of decades ago, the microcosmic orbit iirc. Seriously, there is better.
Then you might as well delve into Taoism proper after which you can decide whether you still want to spend money on Mantak Chia books...
What is better then? I have one book on Qigong but I wasn't impressed by the book.
I ended up in Qigong through my interest in spiritual taoism. That whole episode of my life ended with a mega psychotic episode because I didn't do the qigong right.
Anyway, this was the book
After that I sort of kept meeting the right people that taught me what needed to be taught at the time. There are some good vids on you tube too but ultimately the only way to really learn is of a teacher.
Have done lots of reading over the years too and will share some more links you might find interesting. To really understand what you are doing if you do qigong it will undoubtedly help to understand the chinese medical model
Web That Has No Weaver
Ling Shu
Dragon Rises Red Bird Flies
Got one really old book but good book somewhere upstairs that covers animal forms, will dig it out tomorrow and post the link.
I ended up in Qigong through my interest in spiritual taoism. That whole episode of my life ended with a mega psychotic episode because I didn't do the qigong right.
Anyway, this was the book
After that I sort of kept meeting the right people that taught me what needed to be taught at the time. There are some good vids on you tube too but ultimately the only way to really learn is of a teacher.
Have done lots of reading over the years too and will share some more links you might find interesting. To really understand what you are doing if you do qigong it will undoubtedly help to understand the chinese medical model
Web That Has No Weaver
Ling Shu
Dragon Rises Red Bird Flies
Got one really old book but good book somewhere upstairs that covers animal forms, will dig it out tomorrow and post the link.
@aghogday Not sure why you brought up haters and lovers. Yes, you said you didn't address any particular person. But just to make sure, I'm certainly not a hater, even though I'm very skeptical, and I guess there's a fine line between skepticism or cynicism and hate. Which is a philosophical subject I've been thinking about.
As for all this stuff about emotion, funnily I stumbled across a blog post yesterday when I wasn't even browsing on that subject:
http://jonrappoport.wordpress.com/2014/12/15/energy-depletion-in-a-human-being/
I found this part especially interesting and relevant to me:
As I said, I have been interested in these things, am interested in these things, but I remain skeptical. There are those who say that the spiritual world and the physical world are one and the same and those who say they are separate. I don't know which is true. Why all the Catholic sex abuse for example? If I could strive for something beyond corporeality then that would probably be of greater interest to me than this Dionysus or Isis cult that appears to be in question here.
The god of wine and of an orgiastic religion celebrating the power and fertility of nature.
If I could walk around in some partial out of body experience I think I'd prefer that actually to having a strong degree of interconnection with the physical world, but I don't know for sure. I guess Osiris is more my flavor right now:
[...]
He was also associated with the epithet Khenti-Amentiu, which means "Foremost of the Westerners" - a reference to his kingship in the land of the dead. As ruler of the dead, Osiris was also sometimes called "king of the living", since the Ancient Egyptians considered the blessed dead "the living ones"
I have been thinking a lot about this thing which appears to be some sort of fork in the road, Dionysus/Isis vs Osiris. That appears to be what this passage in the Quran is about:
I have speculated that "Babylon" is what we today refer to as psychosis. When you look at how Islam is very much about preserving the family unit and protecting women etc., the Jewish philosophy seems to be very related to breaking down the family, alienating people. I think this alienation is inevitable. But as I said this is something I've been reflecting on a lot. Here's an interesting video that is relevant to this subject:
Another interesting thing about this is that while both Islam and Judaism are against monasticism, Islam prohibits alcohol while Judaism encourages it. From wikipedia:
However, until the Destruction of the Second Temple, about two thousand years ago, taking Nazirite vows was a common feature of the religion. Nazirite Jews (in Hebrew: נזיר) abstained from grape products, haircuts, and contact with the dead.[17] However, they did not withdraw from general society, and they were permitted to marry and own property; moreover, in most cases a Nazirite vow was for a specified time period and not permanent.[18] In Modern Hebrew, the term "Nazir" is most often used to refer to non-Jewish monastics.
I wrote about how I can see Catholicism sliding into Protestantism and further sliding into rave clubs and beyond. To quote the Catholic E Michael Jones in his book A Coney Island of the Mindless:
In this video a rabbi talks about how Christianity will die out:
Here's a book about Jewish influence in Christian reform movement:
http://www.christianjewishlibrary.org/PDF/LCJU_JewishInfluence.pdf
Another clipping from wikipedia:
In Gnosticism, the world of the demiurge is represented by the lower world, which is associated with matter, flesh, time and, more particularly, an imperfect, ephemeral world. The world of God is represented by the upper world and is associated with the soul and perfection. The world of God is eternal and not part of the physical. It is impalpable and timeless.
The search continues.
Regarding my speculations around the concepts psychosis and delusion, I found this article online:
http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/History/Exile.html
From texts such as Lamentations , which was probably written in Jerusalem, and Job, written after the exile, as well as many of the Psalms, Hebrew literature takes on a despairing quality. The subject of Job is human suffering itself. Undeserving of suffering, Job, an upright man, is made to suffer the worst series of calamities possible because of an arbitrary test. When he finally despairs that there is no cosmic justice, the only answer he receives is that humans shouldn't question God's will. Many of the psalms written in this period betray an equal hopelessness.
But the Jews in Babylon also creatively remade themselves and their world view. In particular, they blamed the disaster of the Exile on their own impurity. They had betrayed Yahweh and allowed the Mosaic laws and cultic practices to become corrupt; the Babylonian Exile was proof of Yahweh's displeasure. During this period, Jewish leaders no longer spoke about a theology of judgment, but a theology of salvation. In texts such as Ezekiel and Isaiah, there is talk that the Israelites would be gathered together once more, their society and religion purified, and the unified Davidic kingdom be re-established.
Found the golden oldie
And this is a really good read too
I don't revere or dismiss science but having had the experiences I did had me see the world differently from a very early age. Surely I have huge chunks of my almost 50 year on this planet in a states of dissociation but I've no real regrets. They're only labels to me that serve more of a purpose to the person doing the labelling than they do to me. This is part of another post of mine
No one can tell me how much time I spent on my comatose nan's lap before my mother came home but she had raised me lovingly enough to give me the strength to pull through till the day I was old enough to leave and do it on my own. My mother, as she is nearing the end, is trying to crawl out of the denial I have denied her all these years but I doubt she'll get there in time. It's not my problem.
Thing is them being the 'good' catholics they were they would have told me nan went to heaven with the angels. And low and behold, I DID have a guiding light as a child. Like a bright soft pastel white with a shadowy face that had wild hair that would pop into my mind and I would hear a voice that told me "don't worry, everything will be allright in the end". And it was the only thing I unconditionally trusted.
Trust is everything. We have more neuroreceptors in our guts than in our brain http://www.nytimes.com/2005/08/24/healt ... d=all&_r=0
It could be argued it is irrational to trust reason over emotion
So I guess I ultimately decided to put my trust into that what got me through in the beginning
Found the golden oldie
And this is a really good read too
I don't revere or dismiss science but having had the experiences I did had me see the world differently from a very early age. Surely I have huge chunks of my almost 50 year on this planet in a states of dissociation but I've no real regrets. They're only labels to me that serve more of a purpose to the person doing the labelling than they do to me. This is part of another post of mine
No one can tell me how much time I spent on my comatose nan's lap before my mother came home but she had raised me lovingly enough to give me the strength to pull through till the day I was old enough to leave and do it on my own. My mother, as she is nearing the end, is trying to crawl out of the denial I have denied her all these years but I doubt she'll get there in time. It's not my problem.
Thing is them being the 'good' catholics they were they would have told me nan went to heaven with the angels. And low and behold, I DID have a guiding light as a child. Like a bright soft pastel white with a shadowy face that had wild hair that would pop into my mind and I would hear a voice that told me "don't worry, everything will be allright in the end". And it was the only thing I unconditionally trusted.
Trust is everything. We have more neuroreceptors in our guts than in our brain http://www.nytimes.com/2005/08/24/healt ... d=all&_r=0
It could be argued it is irrational to trust reason over emotion
So I guess I ultimately decided to put my trust into that what got me through in the beginning
Interesting, thanks.
My interest in Osiris made me order a book on it:
http://www.amazon.com/Mysteries-Osiris-Ancient-Egyptian-Initiation/dp/1258125803/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1420551187&sr=1-1&keywords=The+mysteries+of+Osiris
My reasoning, and gut feeling as well, is that if you're going to reject something at least know what you're rejecting.
