adb wrote:
YippySkippy wrote:
Americans are jealous of the Canadian healthcare system ...
Where are you getting these Americans? I don't see many Americans going to Canada to get medical attention, but many Canadians go to the US for faster and better care.
http://www.fraserinstitute.org/uploaded ... ff0712.pdfWe see plenty of Americans coming up to Canada for less expensive care of equivalent quality.
Remember, too, that health care is not limited to doctors and hospitals. How many Americans rely on Canadian pharmacies for their drugs? That price advantage also extends to almost every consumer product with a medical application. Our system provides the same product at 3/4 the price.
Quote:
When referred to a specialist, Americans are usually seen within a couple weeks (if not days). In Canada, the average wait time is 19 weeks.
http://www.fraserinstitute.org/uploaded ... n-2011.pdfFrom a medical perspective, this is not always a bad thing.
Most people visit a family doctor (if they have one, that is) in situations in which they are unwell--not merely their primary condition, but also physical fatigue which many contraindicate aggressive therapy. Many people who die on the operating table do so because they were not physically strong enough to withstand the stress of the operation that they were undertaking.
In non-life threatening cases, it is often best to defer therapy, and provide maintenance care until a person is strong enough to deal with the rigour of aggressive therapy. Some of the longest wait times in Canada are in orthopaedic cases. Given the choice between having a knee replacement next week, and dying under anaethesia, or having a knee replacement in three months, after your family doctor has helped you get you strength up, which is the smarter medical choice?
Now, not all waits are good, to be sure. But where it really counts, like oncology and cardiovascular cases, our wait times are not substantially different than yours--and they often prove superior when they are normalized for community size.
Quote:
Americans certainly have some problems with healthcare, but I don't see any evidence to suggest that Canada's system is superior.
We have our own problems. One that we both share is a paucity of family doctors. Both of us have far too few of them, and that creates great difficulty for people who are trying to establish primary care. Our medical professions have both been far too slow to take on board the services that can (and should) be provided through the agency of nurse practitioners, and other altenative care providers.
But when you get right down to it, we have longer life expectancy than you. We have lower infant mortality than you. And we accomplish this spending less of our GDP on health. Our governments spend less
per capita than your governments do, and within that lower amount of spending, we manage to provide universal, medically necessary coverage.
In all substantive areas but one, there is really little difference between our medical systems. But there is one thing that I believe makes our system superior to yours. And that is found in those last eight words. We manage to provide universal, medically necessary coverage. The singular, appalling failure of your system has been the number of uninsured. But you seem to be on your way to addressing that, which gives me great hope.
_________________
--James