GGPViper wrote:
The_Walrus wrote:
Not "use with crime", exactly, but yes, we banned four breeds of dog (most notably pitbulls) because they are extraordinarily fierce. I can't find any statistics other than that 6 people were killed by dog bites in 2011- no info on breeds.
Personally I think our dangerous dog laws are a disgrace. Dogs are "guilty until proven innocent", and they don't even have to belong to one of the banned breeds, just share certain physical characteristics.
The dog example may partly be due to a confusion of cause and effect. Several studies have shown that
owners of so-called "vicious" dogs (including pit bulls) display elevated levels of antisocial traits compared to other dog owners.
See this recent study, mentioned on the wiki pit bull page (with quite a few statistics on dog bites in the US, btw):
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1 ... 1961.x/pdfApparently, 33 percent of fatalities from dog bites come from pit bulls and their mixes.
It is not surprising that pit bulls are meaner than other dogs when their owners are meaner than other owners.
I think it is probably a complicated relationship. Pit bulls are more aggressive than other dogs, which makes their owners more likely to be anti-social, which makes pit bulls more likely to be aggressive...
Jacoby wrote:
The_Walrus wrote:
Not "use with crime", exactly, but yes, we banned four breeds of dog (most notably pitbulls) because they are extraordinarily fierce. I can't find any statistics other than that 6 people were killed by dog bites in 2011- no info on breeds.
Personally I think our dangerous dog laws are a disgrace. Dogs are "guilty until proven innocent", and they don't even have to belong to one of the banned breeds, just share certain physical characteristics.
Do you see how this analogues guns? A pit can be a loving and loyal pet in the hands of responsible owner or a viscous beast with the potential to inflict great bodily injury in the hands of a bad one. The key variable here is the owner.
The difference is that dogs are reasonably sentient living beings, so should be allowed to live if at all possible (though I am in favour of not allowing pitbulls to reproduce). If a gun is destroyed, so what?