The War in Iraq...
And Eamonn you are well aware that Roosevelt didnt fight in WWII Wilson in WWI or Lincoln In CW does that mean that we shouldnt have fought any of those wars either???[/img]
Im not saying that we shouldnt fight those wars but that if none of the ruling elite's family find it important enough to fight im not gonna risk my life while their sitting in some bloody jacuzzi or on a beach sunning themselves. If conscription came in and they expected the poor common men to do all their fighting for them like in vietnam then id dodge the draft no worries. If however I was in the Army that is different because when you join up you realise what you are getting youreself into.
I agree with Israel or whoever wants to bomb the Iranian nuclear plant, hopefully before it becomes fully nuclear. The Israeli's done it in Iraq when they were in the process of building a nuclear plant (with French help) and that has done the world a favour.
Katze, I know us debating over this is unlikely to save the world or anything but it is better to dabate than to close our minds and not say what we think about things. What is wrong about thinking and discussing things? In WW2 people werent keeping their eye on the ball enough with Hitler and co and it was only after the war that everyone knew the full extent of what went on.
This war reminds me of the war between protestants and catholics in the tudor times.
Both sides believe they're right, this especially applies to the terrorists because their using their god as an excuse to kill innocent people.
Allah teaches peace so he'd never sanction this.
But I still think it was wrong to invade like that, I mean think of all the innocents killed.
Katze, I know us debating over this is unlikely to save the world or anything but it is better to dabate than to close our minds and not say what we think about things. What is wrong about thinking and discussing things? In WW2 people werent keeping their eye on the ball enough with Hitler and co and it was only after the war that everyone knew the full extent of what went on.[/quote]
Transposing this to todays situation, given the fact that a great many people do know what is going on in Iraq (or at least they think they do), what are they doing about it? What are you and me doing about it? Do you really think that if people during WWII had known what was going on, and a great many did, anything would or could have been done?. What would you have done? Some people tried and lost their Heads, such as a group of Generals and young idealistic people with a big heart such as the group called 'The White Rose'. My guess is that they too debated for a while and then decided to act and lost their lives because of it. There is nothing wrong in thinking about or discussing things, but if it doesn't touch life....
I tell you that there were plenty of Debates going on in Peoples homes and Government Offices about the 'German situation', and 'how terrible it was what was happening to the Jews'. My mother and Grandparents were taken to the Gestapo HQ at gunpoint for questioning because they had helped their Neighbouring Jewish Families, thankfully they were let off again.
I am curious for you to tell me why it is 'better to debate things than to close our minds' and how the end result would be different
It doesn't mean that you should stop debating or discussing, or to have a lively and questioning mind, exchange ideas. Does that inspire you, give you hope, determination? If so then all is well, and as Joseph Campbell said:'Follow your Bliss!'
I am not trying to save the world. Right now my concern is that my Computer is running like a Pig and that I need a Memory upgrade and a new Video card so that I can play Halflife 2 but I haven't got the money.
Katze
'Knowledge Kills Action, Action requires the Veil of Illusion ' Nietzsche
I am curious for you to tell me why it is 'better to debate things than to close our minds' and how the end result would be different
It doesn't mean that you should stop debating or discussing, or to have a lively and questioning mind, exchange ideas. Does that inspire you, give you hope, determination? If so then all is well, and as Joseph Campbell said:'Follow your Bliss!'
I am not trying to save the world. Right now my concern is that my Computer is running like a Pig and that I need a Memory upgrade and a new Video card so that I can play Halflife 2 but I haven't got the money.
When i was younger i was thinking about politics and planning on making a difference but after realising i dont have the people skills for it and care less these days its probably more out of passing the time that i debate but i do believe everyone should at least have a little knowledge about things so they can make up their own minds instead of blindly following what we are told by governments or any other group.
I wouldnt waste money on a computer upgrade for games when within the year a playstation 3 will come out and make a PC games graphics look like pong for the atari 2600.
When i was younger i was thinking about politics and planning on making a difference..
'Ahhh... but I was so much older then.... I'm younger than that now'. Bob Dylan
Don't you think that the whole issue about Israel-Palestine and to some extent Iraq is about a 'balance of Power', an attitude that belongs in the 18th Century and has no place in this new century? And that what is missing in both Scenarios is a common denominator to bring some kind of mutual agreement and understanding?
(Are you trying to tell me that G.W Bush has People skills?).........he...he..he
Katze
'Ahhh... but I was so much older then.... I'm younger than that now'. Bob Dylan
Don't you think that the whole issue about Israel-Palestine and to some extent Iraq is about a 'balance of Power', an attitude that belongs in the 18th Century and has no place in this new century? And that what is missing in both Scenarios is a common denominator to bring some kind of mutual agreement and understanding?
(Are you trying to tell me that G.W Bush has People skills?).........he...he..he
Katze
He is rich, has former president Dad and very powerful friends. Even better than people skills.
I recently read a book by Phillip Slater (American), written in 1970, he gives an intelligent and elegant observation of American Society. What is disturbing in the book is that in actual fact nothing at all seems to have changed Politically at least, if not socially, since then, over the last 35 years
In fact things got worse. He describes the vietnam war spin that was presented by the White house at the time, such as:"There is no doubt that we are winning the War in Vietnam', and "things are improving on a daily basis in our war against the Vietcong' (Sound familiar?), he outlines the fact that America has alway had some form of Concentration Camp in operation, if not for the 'Reds under the Beds', then for the Japanese, and the fact that if Amercia doesn't have any enemies at one given point in time it will create some.
Neither our Primer Minister (John Howard) nor any of your Presidents since JFK have shown any kind of vision, nor ar they willing to lay their ass on the line, something the founders of the Civil rights movements back in the 60's and 70's were willing to do.
Its easy enough to sit in some nice apartment, munching on a Wendy burger and sucking on a can of Coke while writing commentaries on whats wrong with the War in Iraq, or the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. Its a step towards something more tangible if any of us were willing to forego our nice little Summer Vacation in some comfortable Beach Condo and decided to spend the time in Ramallah or some other Palestinian refugee camp in order to get a first hand view. Do that and I am willing to listen to your points of view.
Am I pissed off about something? you're dam* right I am. While we are writing and debating and contributing to the Forum peple are dying uselessly.
I am going to stop now, my Wendy Burger is getting cold
Katze
Actually, when it comes to issues I feel strongly about, I send letters to my senators and governor. So I can't say that I sit and do nothing.
make it BIG knowledge, then
and make it knowledge you've found out for yourself, rather than stuff which is fed to you.
Is anyone here suggesting that they arent sheep? (figuratively speaking) Some of us might be the kind that strays away from the pack and gets caught in wire and needs untangled but there are no world leaders here, and no-one that doesnt participate to some extent in society.
Anyway, nearly all knowledge is fed by people to people unless they really are omnipresent. Most people tend to put their own spin on things. Also im sure most governments and their leaders have much more knowledge than us but that doesnt necessarily mean they will use it for the benefit of the masses, or that we shouldnt challenge them to show that their policies are for our benefit.
I don't have an expertise in politics, but I do know that the media can't know everything that's going on. I mean, if the CIA or the government gave out all of its plans to protect our nation, then all the terrorists have to do is turn on the t.v. or the radio, and then they have their plan, practically served out to them. It's a whole lot better than having the war over here; if the war was over here, then many more people will be getting killed. I don't see why people have to be complaining about everything that Bush does; it's a heck of a lot better than what some presidents in the past did, like Clinton selling information to the Chinese, stealing stuff out of the White House, almost getting impeached... As a president one has to think of their beliefs, what is politically correct, and the future. Lots of the times, with the government holding information from the media, we don't know what the future holds, and the President must think of the future. Being the President is an extremely hard job because you have to look at all aspects of the world and make decisions based on the information that you have, and some is hidden from our eyes; there may be other parts of the story that doesn't make sense, but in the future they could make lots of sense. Of course everybody's political view is different, and everyone has to accept people's beliefs. I think that Bush has done a good job at taking action, or else we still would have been looking at the t.v. screen and watching to Twin Towers be blown to bits.
_________________
I'm 24 years old and live in WA State. I was diagnosed with Asperger's at 9. I received a BS in Psychology in 2011 and I intend to help people with Autistic Spectrum Disorders, either through research, application, or both. On the ?Pursuit of Aspieness?.
When I see bush, I see a president who takes a seat-of-the-pants approach to making decisions. I see bush as someone who does not weigh his options when making decisions, but does something on whether it not "it feels right", and has little regard for what happens as long the desired results are met.
Was bush right to go to war after 9/11? I would say yes.
But will we win the war on terror? Who knows? Muslim hate for this country began long before most of us here were born, and most defintely be solved by bush, or his methods, and if anything, has only been enhanced by the war on terror.
_________________
I live my life to prove wrong those who said I couldn't make it in life...
