Is homosexuality a genetic or cultural phenomenon?

Post Reply New Topic

So why is there overpopulation in China?
Theyve subsisted on soy for millennia and it hasnt made a dent in their heterosexual reproductive talents.

Perhaps only people who eat those tofu hot dogs become homosexual? Tofu is made of soy, and I have empirically proven in this thread that hot dogs lead to homosexuality

does it matter?

Even if it was a choice, then what argument could we pull to make free adults unable to choose what sex to like? Or who to marry?

I am 40 years old now and have come to the conclusion that there is no such thing as gay or straight. They are concepts that our civilised world has come to rely on. I would say most people can be swayed either way. I would say human, and animal, sexuality is a dynamic thing that each person learns during life. Never say never etc. Anyone who thinks it is an absolute is severely misguided.

I saw a documentary once about homosexuality in ancient greece. They concluded by saying the Greeks encouraged it amongst their soldiers. The thinking being that only if two men loved eachother would they fight to the death for eachother.

My own view is slightly different. I believe that sexuality is strongly centred in the hypothalmus, which is a structure that exhibits sexual dimorphism (it is anatomically different in males and females). There are a number of physiological studies that demonstrate divergent anatomical characteristics and physiological reactions in self-identified homosexual and heterosexual men and women.

I suggest that the liberalism of western culture does not encourage people to question their sexuality, but, rather, does not force people into denying their sexuality. Consider two teenagers whose developing attraction is exclusively towards members of the same sex. One teenager in a liberal culture, where gay and lesbian role models are visible will be able to look to the adults in the community and say, "that is me." The teenager in the repressive culture lacks the model in the community that validates the sexuality that is developing.



Thank you for asking such an open textured question.

For my part, I self-identify as gay, and have done since the age of 12. There was never a point at which I was in any doubt about my sexual orientation. Peer pressure and social pressure strongly incentivized a heterosexual orientation. My life would have been considerably easier had I been straight. But all that this incentive managed to do was to cause me to stay "in the closet" as a teen. There was never any doubt that my sexual attraction was exclusively oriented towards men. I may have been unhappy about it--but I was in no doubt about it.