Kraichgauer wrote:
To be fair, there are a percentage of prisoners who in fact were seized while simply traveling, then were accused of being POW's. Case in point: an American film maker of Iranian descent, while in Iraq, had been arrested while simply riding in a cab, that had been discovered to have been carrying bomb making components, at a military checkout point. He had been held prisoner for years, underwent interrogation, then was promised by the military he would be released only if he signed a confession he had been captured on the battles field - which he refused to do. Eventually, he was freed by government intercession. All that trouble, just because he had wanted to make a documentary on the Persian King Cyrus the Great.
-Bill, otherwise known as Kraichgauer
That's quite true, the vast majority were snatched, usually sold by militias or bountyhunters or corrupt police. However, the official story is that these were Evil forces taken from the battlefield so if they end up toothless or fingerless at Gitmo well, these people were on a battlefield and sustained injuries in war, that's the explanation, it was nothing we did! Moreover, if we did cut something off, well, there was a valid medical reason. It's very easy to cover up something like that. Oh, and Paul Wolfowitz signed an order that subjected these prisoners to experimentation.