Parakeets do not exist.

Post Reply New Topic

I think I see an internal contradiction, though that depends on one additional thing I forgot to ask. The contradiction only occurs if your faith being the only true faith implies that anyone not following the One True Faith will be damned. I don't know whether you believe that.

So here is the argument. You agree that human life is too short to examine all proposed religions and make an informed choice between them. Choosing a religion is then a gamble. You can perhaps improve your chances, but when you commit to one religion, you are still gambling.

A god who fails to make an informed choice possible, but condemns all who make the wrong choice forces people into a gamble with the highest stakes possible, then punishes people for being unlucky in gambling. A god who does that is neither just nor merciful.

Therefore if a religion claims only its followers will be saved and all others punished, and if that religion claims its god is just and/or merciful, then that religion contains an internal contradiction. A religion that contains internal contradictions can't be the true religion. Even if there is One True Faith, all those faiths that contain internal contradictions can be ruled out.

Even with the finite lifespan we have, choices can be narrowed down.

Squawk topic

The only thing I am aware of to some extent is that Iamnotaparakeet is not a parakeet, by his own admission, and that to my own knowledge parakeets cannot chat as humans do, in a text format.

I'm nondenominational actually, and I think God will judge everyone on an individual basis. If you want a list off the top of my head as to forms of Christianity which I consider to be most likely to have members which are saved based on their teaching (such as including the Gospel among all the other myriads of teaching), then here is a list of the ones I can remember at the moment: Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican, Protestant, or my own favorite, "I don't give a darn about labels! Jesus Christ is my Lord and Savior, so enough of the branding!"

Even with the finite lifespan we have, choices can be narrowed down. Such as, assuming God wanted us to know him, meaning us as in all mankind throughout history. So, such a religion, under this assumption, would be ancient. And it can be narrowed down further.

Do you agree that it is impossible for a human to witness all chemical reactions going on in the universe simultaneously?

If it is impossible for a human to witness all chemical reactions in the universe simultaneously, then does that mean that it is impossible to understand chemistry?

Is there no possible way to determine how a reaction will proceed just because we have not seen every single reaction?

I take that as a yes, that those who don't accept Jesus as their Lord and Saviour will not find salvation. Just to be sure, let's engage in a thought experiment. Let's say someone lives as saintly a life as any human ever lived, but doesn't believe in Jesus, perhaps never having heard of Jesus. According to your faith, would that person be damned?

Were people saved before Christ?

Today’s Question: So what happens to the people that are not Christians—I mean the people before Jesus? Did they go to hell?

Melinda Fletcher

Bible Answer: This question has bothered many compassionate Christians through the centuries. They rightly do not want to believe that God would cast everyone that was born before Christ into hell. That doesn’t seem fair!

They are right! Gen 18:25 says, “Will not the Judge of all the earth do right?” God never judges righteous people in the same way that He judges the wicked. It is clear throughout the ages, that many people, prior to Christ birth, lived good lives. The question is: How did they live such good lives without Christ saving them? The answer: they could not without salvation. So how could Christ save people before His coming to die on the Cross?

Here is the answer: First of all, Christ birth was not the time that Christ existed. He has always existed, because He is God the Son; He just did not have a flesh and blood body prior to His birth. However, He is the Lamb that was slain from the creation of the world (Rev 13:8). So before His birth, God credited Christ death as an “I owe you.” Just like you write down I owe you to someone, you promise that one day you will pay it. The same is true of God. Before Christ came to the earth, God promised all people that one day He will pay for their debt, and so he counted their debts paid even before Christ died.

So how did He save them without the Holy Spirit regenerating them? Remember, Christ is the wisdom of God (1 Cor 1:24), and His wisdom has been available from the beginning of creation. By wisdom the LORD laid the earth's foundations (Prov 3:19). Jesus is the one who laid the earth’s foundations. Through him all things were made (John 1:3). Jesus, prior to His birth, existed in the form of the wisdom of God. When someone “found Jesus” they found “wisdom.” This wisdom enabled people to live righteous lives, just as the Holy Spirit gives us this ability. People’s noble lives proved that they had touched Christ in some way, or should I say, Christ touched them in some way.

The book of Proverbs is the book of Wisdom. I want you to notice that Solomon wrote nearly all the Proverbs, however, the last two chapters were written by two other men: Agur and King Lemuel. Search Israel’s biblical genealogy and you will notice that these two men are not mentioned in the Bible. A closer look at their names reveals that they were Gentiles and not Jews. How did Gentiles have a part in writing the Old Testament? Simple: wisdom is all inclusive. It belongs to all people who desire it.

Agur wrote: “I have not learned wisdom, nor have I knowledge of the Holy One.” (Prov 30:3) This was his humble way of saying that he did not know God in the same way as the Jews. Then he adds: “Who has established all the ends of the earth? What is his name, and the name of his son?” (Prov 30:4)

He did not know the name of God’s son, yet he had wisdom—enough that God would place his words in the Word of God. This shows you that non-Jews were saved outside of the Jewish system of sacrifices.

When I look in the past before Christ was born, I discover many religious leaders and philosophers that had the wisdom of God, and so I conclude that they were saved by Christ.

Consider Buddha: he lived 500 hundred years before Christ, yet he was enlightened by wisdom. Look at his eight-fold path and you will recognize much of the Sermon on the Mount. How did he get such truth before Christ was born? He received this truth simply because Christ came to him in the form of wisdom. Don’t misunderstand me: Buddha cannot save; only Christ can. I do not believe today's Buddhists are saved; only that if Buddha were alive today, he would be a Christian. The point is that I believe Christ saved Buddha and the evidence of his salvation was his wisdom. (Of course, only the Lord knows each heart, and He is the final Judge.)

We could say this about some philosophers like Aristotle and Plato. They often showed the spark of wisdom that could only come from Christ. In fact the early church fathers used their writings to confirm the truth of the gospel, and that was one way the western world accepted the gospel.

For those who want a clearer scripture to prove that non Jews were saved prior to Christ, then consider the words of our Lord: "The Queen of the South will rise at the judgment with this generation and condemn it; for she came from the ends of the earth to listen to Solomon's wisdom, and now one greater than Solomon is here." (Matt 12:42) Jesus plainly considered the Queen of Sheba to be saved, or else how could she judge the generation of Christ? What was the evidence that she was saved? She came to hear the wisdom of God spoken through Solomon. There is no evidence in Scripture or in history to suggest that the queen ever became a Jew. Her hunger for wisdom confirmed her acceptance of Christ.

In conclusion, people prior to the birth of Christ were saved through Him by His wisdom. They were not saved in the sense of being born again and filled with the Spirit, but they were saved with the meaning of being forgiven by God. They did not enter heaven upon their death, because the way for heaven was not made available until Christ ascension, however they were in paradise (see Luke 16:19-31). During Christ ascension they were then carried into heaven with Him. That is where they are today—in heaven with Christ.

No Parakeet, you are wrong.

I make the extraordinary claim that parakeets do indeed exist.

I can produce photographic, audio and video evidence.

I can produce an exact set of definitions for the properties that make a parakeet a parakeet

as agreed upon by all biologists.

I can direct you to a pet store

in your area

where you can see a parakeet

and compare it to the defining characteristics of a parakeet.

I can then meet with the employees of the pet store

and confirm

with them that your experience

of a parakeet

was an objective reality

rather then your subjective impression.

I know you make some 'Extraordinary Claims' too,

and your empirically demonstrable 'Extraordinary Evidence' would be? ...

Poor bird. Is that a model or an actual skeleton?

Always a good way to address somebody.
Sorry, you're wrong.
All of it CGI.
I reject your definitions and substitute my own.
Ista sunt argumenta ad populum et ad verecundiam.
Though you can, you may not. Plus the travel times stink during rush's hour.
Which is over 13 billion lightyears away.
I doubt that.
Which I reject, and therefore they do not qualify.
Who have taken, at best, a two week corporate course.
Epistemically impossible.
This is so wrong it doesn't need refuting.
Which does not exist, by definition.
Similarly as possible as confirming epistemically.
Mass hallucination.

Yes, that the chair on the bridge works, and won't kill anyone.
Just have someone, other than me, sit in the chair.

In particular, those who lived prior to Christ still have the chance of being judged on their merits alone. If nobody has told them of Christ and His act of sacrifice for them, and thus not allowing them to decide, then it is not their fault for not choosing. In the case of those born afterward, as per those born prior to Christ's sacrifice, they are not necessarily condemned automatically, but they will be judged on the basis of their actions and volition.

Consider Buddha: he lived 500 hundred years before Christ, yet he was enlightened by wisdom. Look at his eight-fold path and you will recognize much of the Sermon on the Mount. How did he get such truth before Christ was born? He received this truth simply because Christ came to him in the form of wisdom. Don’t misunderstand me: Buddha cannot save; only Christ can. I do not believe today's Buddhists are saved

Congrats on the necro.

I haven't got the faintest idea what you mean by that.