pandabear wrote:
DW_a_mom wrote:
That doesn't mean it's a silly rule; the church is often thinking in far broader terms than most people realize (it would help if they shared the real reasons more often, but that isn't in the nature of the institution).
I've read into this a little more--apparently priests aren't even supposed to masturbate. Surely you would have to agree that this is silly, and going a tad far.
How are you supposed to take anyone seriously who pontificates that he never masturbates?
Maybe you feel safer about eating the communion wafer this way. But if his stand is "I never masturbate, and you should never use condoms", then who is going to take him seriously? Even birth rates among Catholics aren't what they used to be.
If I'm talking to my priest, I'm pretty darn sure that one thing we won't be discussing is whether or not he masturbates.
I don't know how many follow that rule and I have zero desire to find out; that is a level of privacy I don't think should be invaded. Not every rule everywhere is going to be followed all the time, and that includes priests. Assuming you are correct that this is part of the rule; it's not something I've ever looked into. Lol, I can't believed I've actually bothered to post on the subject!
The rest of celibacy serves a rather practical purpose, and those I've known who have entered the priesthood have tended to feel that it was an OK thing to ask of them. Even if it was horribly difficult.
_________________
Mom to an amazing young adult AS son, plus an also amazing non-AS daughter. Most likely part of the "Broader Autism Phenotype" (some traits).