Would an autistic communist nation survive longer than a NT?

Post Reply New Topic

Communism (Economic system) =/= "Communist" bureaucrats

As most threads involving communism tend to do, this one has rapidly ventured into No True Scotsman territory...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communism

You two are implying because I advocate communism I advocate state power. Lenin and Stalin's transitional stage is not communism. They could of thought they were leading the country towards communism, but that doesn't make the economic system communist, it was state socialism. I haven't made any logical fallacys.

"The proletariat will use its political supremacy to wrest, by degree, all capital from the bourgeoisie, to centralise all instruments of production in the hands of the State, i.e., of the proletariat organised as the ruling class; and to increase the total productive forces as rapidly as possible."

Does it sound familiar?

Oh, wait... that quote wasn't a *true* communist quote, right?

I never said Karl Marx wasn't a communist, that quote is describing state socialism, the thing he thought would eventually lead to Communism. You are now just resorting to bully tactics.

Historical fact has proved just how far removed from reality Karl Marx was.

Whenever the Proles take over the only activity that will succeed is f*cking and excessive beer drinking.

ruveyn

Nope implementing and maintaining a communist nation goes against human nature and will fail long term, no matter if the society is autistic or non-autistic. Same goes for any "pure" ideological system including a Capitalistic society.

I do not believe in such extremist ideals and think a mixture of various ideals/laws works the best.

That and punishing their bourgeois enemies, real and imaginary.....

The Proles do not take over but rather decide who their leaders will be.

I assume that you are being facetious.

Of course it would mean order routine and efficiency!

You would define fairness as being equality at the lowest common denominator? Nobody is permitted to excel above others because it would be unfair to the lowest?

Conservatives define fairness as a responsibility of the poor to transfer wealth to the rich.

How?

That is about as crazy a statement as I have ever seen.

But go ahead and try to support it. If conservatives actually were to define fairness in that manner, then there would be plenty of statements to that effect. Where are they?

I dont see myself as an empathless lone wolf. I see myself as a logic dominated being, and from logic views communism is functioning. Its only NTs desire for ape-behaviour, fighting for Alpha positions and such nonsense that let our societies people choose to buy themselves nonsense to increase in the ape hierarchy instead of helping someone else, that still needs basic resources. A lot of the ressources we have are wasted for such nonsense, that has no other use, then to play the ape-hierarchy game. Who can afford new cloths every saison, who can afford a bigger car he dont need, who can afford the new I-phone that cant do anything else then the other 18 month old useless I-phone... the more needless nonsense you can afford to buy, the bigger chimp you are. If others wouldnt really need that ressources, there would be nothing bad about it. No cause to denie yourself some luxury, as long as everyone as good as possible provided, with what you need for basic living. But as long as we are still behaving like previous described as a society communism wont work, because there will always be people with self esteem issues, that need stuff to proof themselves that they are great chimps, and if they live in a system where they cant do that regularly, then they will break the rules and turn the system into a tyranny.

But for me personally, if I ever quit society, I would join one of the existing communes in europe to be free of all that stuff and fighting for nonsense that is nothing more than an animal relict of us. Stay up, do your work, done. No fighting for chimpglory, no feeling sad because of always loosing the fighting for chimpglory, no pressure to involve yourself in the chimpglory games... Many people that simply didnt fit with modern society, found a peaceful place there, where their work is accepted.